15 Best Restaurants in Stuart, FL

Best Restaurants in Stuart, FL
Noah Densmore / shutterstock.com

As the “Sailfish Capital of the World,” the city of Stuart in Florida presents countless adventures on the water for everyone.

Stuart is situated along Florida’s Treasure Coast, near Palm Beach and Vero Beach.

It was incorporated as a city in 1914 and is the seat of Martin County.

Blessed with a pleasant climate, Stuart makes an exceptional tourist destination for anyone looking for recreational activities on the water.

It also offers exciting tours of the streets, especially the historic downtown.

It’s also a perfect place to indulge your cravings with the many seafood restaurants and dining options representing different cuisines.

Check out the best restaurants in Stuart, Florida!

The Gafford

Meal in The Gafford
Foursquare City Guide

“Casual meets upscale” at the Gafford, a restaurant in Downtown Stuart that showcases American cuisine through sophisticated dishes.

Grab a taste of its signature steak, a bone-in prime ribeye served with house-made mac and cheese, inspired by the story of one of the restaurant’s owners.

Customers of the Gafford also talk about its Southern-style meatloaf, made tasty with a barbecue glaze and caramelized onion sauce.

Appetizer in The Gafford
Foursquare City Guide

Its menu features seafood entrées, too, that bring out the flavors of salmon, tuna, grouper, swordfish, and shrimp.

Moreover, the Gafford is famous for its Happy Hour in the entire bar, where you can have quick bites and sip great wines and cocktails.

Hang out with your family or friends at the Gafford on Southwest Flagler Avenue!

Riverwalk Cafe and Oyster Bar

Housed in one of the city’s historic downtown buildings, many customers admire the quaint, cozy atmosphere of the Riverwalk Cafe and Oyster Bar.

Its chef and owner, Steven Feder, has appeared in a 2017 local magazine as one of the rising chefs on Treasure Coast.

Riverwalk Cafe and Oyster Bar specialize in fresh seafood such as tuna, clams, salmon, shrimp, and oysters.

Immerse in the sea flavors from the soups, appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and main dishes served at Riverwalk Cafe and Oyster Bar.

Most customers love the Oysters Rocka “feder” and the made-to-order Oyster Stew.

Its fresh oyster raw bar is a must-try too.

Make time to visit Riverwalk Cafe and Oyster Bar on Southwest St. Lucie Avenue!

Michelina’s Italian Restaurant & Catering

Enjoy traditional Italian classics at Michelina’s Italian Restaurant & Catering, a casual and relaxing dining spot along the Southeast Federal Highway.

It features a sizeable purple-walled dining area and a private room for special events and celebrations.

For over two decades, Michelina’s Italian Restaurant & Catering has served made-from-scratch dishes and desserts using Italy’s freshest ingredients and flavors.

Besides its regular menu of mouth-watering dishes, you may want to check out its Sunset Menu.

Specials include homemade soup or salad, garlic knots, pasta, dessert, and beverage.

Visitors will delight in the chicken parmigiana, homemade lasagna, and spaghetti & meatballs.

Dine at Michelina’s Italian Restaurant & Catering for date nights or family bonding time.

Bonefish Grill

Sushi in Bonefish Grill
Foursquare City Guide

Bonefish Grill is a casual dining seafood restaurant chain across the United States, focusing on market-fresh fish, wood-grilled specialties, and hand-crafted cocktails.

Bonefish Grill has earned several awards and recognition for its excellent service and high-quality food.

In Stuart, you can enjoy the Bonefish experience, too, along South Federal Highway!

Reserve a table at Bonefish Grill, and you may start your meal with the popular Bang Bang Shrimp appetizer tossed in its signature creamy, spicy sauce.

As for the main dishes, Bonefish Grill recommends the Cod Imperial stuffed with mozzarella and parmesan cheeses and the Lily’s Chicken with goat cheese, spinach, artichoke hearts, and lemon basil sauce.

You may also want to try one of its perfect pairings, the Sirloin & Shrimp, which combines wood-grilled center-cut sirloin and five jumbo shrimps in your plate.

Finish your meal with a glass of its hand-crafted cocktails, fine wines, or signature martinis.

If you’re visiting Bonefish Grill, watch out for its locally created, seasonal menu.

Bonefish chefs work with local fishermen to find the freshest and top-quality ingredients for these featured specials!

Mario’s Restaurant

Mario’s Restaurant is a long-running dining spot serving Italian dishes in the city, just a short walk from Michelina’s Italian Restaurant & Catering.

Order one of its signature homemade pasta or Italian veal dishes that customers talk about after their dining experience here.

Don’t miss trying the gourmet pizzas at Mario’s Restaurant and its flavorful seafood, chicken, and eggplant plates.

Satisfy your sweet tooth by having a dessert, like a tiramisu, tortoni, or cheesecake.

Mario’s Restaurant serves beers and wines that are perfect for your Italian favorites!

Uncle Giuseppe’s Lil’ Bit A Brooklyn

Along Northwest Federal Highway is another Italian restaurant with a welcoming, cozy atmosphere, a full bar, and televisions to provide entertainment.

Uncle Giuseppe’s Lil’ Bit A Brooklyn prides itself as a place where you can enjoy a little taste of authentic and delectable Sicilian fare without traveling to Italy.

It has an extensive menu of pizzas, pasta, appetizers, hot subs, and more hearty meals for seafood and chicken lovers.

Dishes at Uncle Giuseppe’s Lil’ Bit A Brooklyn are made from scratch to bring fresh flavors to its customers.

There are also menu items of kids’ favorites, like pasta and meatballs, cheese ravioli, pasta with butter, and chicken fingers and fries.

Uncle Giuseppe’s Lil’ Bit a Brooklyn offers large cannoli, Italian cheesecake, tiramisu, and zeppole for desserts.

The Black Marlin

Fish dish in The Black Marlin
Foursquare City Guide

Since 1993, the Black Marlin has become a part of downtown Stuart’s favorite hubs to dine and drink.

The Black Marlin’s exposed brick walls and wooden booths make a pleasant, cozy atmosphere where families and friends can hang out and have a good time.

What was once the oldest tavern in Stuart has become a place to savor flavorful seafood and pasta dishes, and char-grilled fish.

In addition, you can order some starters, salads, sandwiches, and pizzas.

Customers also talk about the Black Marlin’s unique and friendly bartenders.

Visit the Black Marlin on West Osceola Street and catch the Happy Hour for great deals on healthy drinks, house wine, and select draft beers.

Krua Thai Restaurant

If you want to try another culture's cuisine, you can head to Krua Thai Restaurant, which serves palatable Thai and Asian dishes.

Located along Southeast Federal Highway, this restaurant will bring you to Thailand with its intimate setting and interior decoration.

There is something for everyone on its menu, whether you like fried rice, noodles, soups, or curries.

Krua Thai Restaurant notes that customers often order duck noodles soup, which combines crispy duck, egg noodles, and bean sprouts.

You may also want to try the classic Pad Thai, duck curry, or Panang curry.

If you’re a fan of spicy food, you might find your next spicy favorite at Krua Thai Restaurant!

The Flamingo Diner

Do you love eating breakfast food any time of the day?

You can visit The Flamingo Diner on Southeast Federal Highway, a quaint restaurant serving home-cooked breakfast favorites.

Customers praise this place for its friendly staff and a wide variety of menu options.

You can order egg omelets, pancakes, sandwiches, burgers, and other American comfort food here.

In addition, the Flamingo Diner offers lunch and dinner options based on seafood, steaks, pork, and chicken.

The Flamingo favorites consist of homemade meatloaf, roast turkey, and breaded pork cutlets.

Moreover, you can find dishes inspired by Greece’s and Italy’s tastes and flavors.

If you’re dropping by The Flamingo Diner, find out what’s on its daily home-cooked specials!

Sailor’s Return

Seafood meal at Sailor’s Return
Foursquare City Guide

Sailor’s Return is a popular alfresco dining spot in the city, offering breathtaking views of the St. Lucie River.

It also has 930 feet of courtesy docking for customers coming by boat.

Visit Sailor’s Return off Southwest Anchorage Way and relish the casually elegant atmosphere of this tropical harbor setting.

It has various menus, whether you’re looking for a light meal or a feast to enjoy with your family and friends.

Cake at Sailor’s Return
Foursquare City Guide

Most of the dishes at Sailor’s Return revolve around seafood and steaks, and it has an extensive list of wines, beers, and specialty cocktails to pair.

People also stop by this place to enjoy the live music, so if you want a glimpse of the city’s nightlife, head to this restaurant.

Catch the sunset and dance the night away at Sailor’s Return!

Spritz City Bistro

Spritz City Bistro on Southwest Osceola Street is famous for its tapas and small plates, and items for those on special diets.

It presents a “casual upscale dining atmosphere” for its customers and gives them a taste of American classics with a twist.

Spritz City Bistro also offers various creative dishes that are vegan, vegetarian, or gluten-free, ranging from its appetizers to its large plates.

You can either have your brunch, lunch, or dinner here.

They have desserts, too, for a sweet ending to your dining experience, as well as a wide array of craft cocktails, local beers on tap, and wines for a fun time.

Watch out for its Happy Hour and other great deals if you add Spritz City Bistro to your itinerary!

Pepe & Sale

If you’re looking for a place to immerse in a refined dining atmosphere, you can drive to Pepe & Sale off Southeast Ocean Boulevard.

It’s a wine lounge and restaurant specializing in modern Italian dishes, and customers describe their experience as being transported in Italy.

One of the most-talked dishes at Pepe & Sale is its homemade potato gnocchi, which customers say “melts in your mouth.”

Aside from its exquisite pasta plates, it also serves main dishes based on seafood, chicken, and beef combined with spices and the freshest ingredients that make up Italian cuisine.

Pepe & Sale is open during dinner hours, so reserving a table is recommended.

Flanigan’s Seafood Bar and Grill

Barbecue ribs at Flanigan’s Seafood Bar and Grill
Foursquare City Guide

Flanigan’s Seafood Bar and Grill is a family-run restaurant chain recognized as a South Florida institution since 1959.

It gives off “island vibes and saltwater adventures” through its interior design and photos that decorate its walls showing families and friends having fun on the water.

You can visit the Stuart branch along Southeast Federal Highway.

People rave about the rich flavor of the Legendary Baby Back Ribs marinated in tangy-sweet BBQ sauce, one of the signature dishes of Flanigan’s Seafood Bar and Grill.

You may also want to try Joe’s Rockin’ Rib Rolls for appetizers, one of its signature burgers and sandwiches, or another savory dish under the seafood section.

Complete your Flanigan’s experience by checking the bar serving dessert martinis, beers, wines, and more!

Fruits and Roots Juice Bar and Vegan Café

What sets Fruits and Roots Juice Bar and Vegan Café apart from other restaurants in the city is its thoughtfully crafted 100% plant-based vegan offerings.

Found along South Colorado Avenue, this restaurant has a warm and relaxed ambiance, and you may sit either in its interior dining setting or outside on the expansive patio.

You’ll receive an extensive menu of inventive vegan fare, ranging from appetizers and small plates to salads and sandwiches.

There are also healthy options that kids will enjoy, such as cheesy flatbread, mac, and cheese, house-made hummus, and sliced cucumber.

Don’t miss the refreshing drinks at Fruits and Roots Juice Bar and Vegan Café made with locally sourced and organic ingredients.

It has cold-pressed juices, smoothies, flavored mylk, nourishing elixirs, and shots.

Dune Dog Cafe

Exterior of Dune Dog Cafe
Foursquare City Guide

Dune Dog Cafe started in business in 1994 in Jupiter, Florida, to give locals and tourists a spot to experience a “happy island” atmosphere as they enjoy great food and company.

Stuart residents and visitors can now taste its signature hot dogs and superb seafood dishes on Southwest Federal Highway!

Dune Dog Cafe is in the southern part of Roosevelt Bridge, providing indoor and outdoor seating for its customers.

It offers a wide array of hot dog plates with different toppings to make them rich in flavor and texture, plus burgers, sandwiches, combo platters, and more to satisfy your hunger!

Sandwich in Dune Dog Cafe
Foursquare City Guide

Dune Dog Cafe also has a “puppy menu” for the kids consisting of a corn dog, fish fingers, and grilled chicken sandwich served with waffle fries, beverages, and ice cream.

The customers’ favorites include the crispy fish and chips, crunchy fish sandwich, clam chowder, and grilled mahi mahi sandwich.

Check out the weekly dinner deals at Dune Dog Cafe!

Final Thoughts

Come and see what makes Stuart, Florida, the “Sailfish Capital of the World.”

You’ll never go hungry, too, with the vast array of restaurants where you can taste Stuart’s delightful flavors and other places worldwide.

There are also great options for people on a special diet.

Save this list of the best restaurants in Stuart, Florida, once you embark on a gastronomic journey in this city!

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.