15 Best Restaurants in Sheridan, WY

Restaurants in Sheridan, WY
Maciej Bledowski / shutterstock.com

On the east slope of the Bighorn Mountains near the Montana border is Wyoming’s emerald city: Sheridan.

It’s a place with a colorful history and magnificent views.

Sheridan got its name from American Civil War’s Union Cavalry leader, General Philip Sheridan.

This city is halfway between Yellowstone Park and Mount Rushmore by US Routes 14 and 16.

Besides its bounty of nature, Sheridan has several restaurants offering a range of cuisines.

Here are the best restaurants in Sheridan, Wyoming:

Cowboy Cafe

Chicken steak at Cowboy Cafe
Cowboy Cafe via Yelp.com

Keeping with the Old West spirit of Sheridan is Cowboy Cafe.

The cozy seating space outside the cafe’s entrance has umbrella-shaded tables where you can sit comfortably, even with your pets.

Serving classic yet simple dishes since 1993, the restaurant offers breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

The portions are impressive, from their filling breakfast platters to mouth-watering burgers, sandwiches, and healthy salad options.

The thoughtful inclusion of plant-based meat options on their menu makes it suitable even for vegans.

Don’t forget to try their special homemade desserts.

And what would a hearty meal be without a good drink to go along with it?

You can take your pick from a range of beers, house wines, or cocktails like a mimosa, Bloody Mary, or sangria.

Cowboy Cafe on North Main Street is bound to have you returning for more.

Wyoming’s Rib & Chop House

Perfectly cooked Sirloin steak at Wyoming’s Rib & Chop House
Wyoming’s Rib & Chop House via Yelp.com

Wyoming’s Rib & Chop House is the place to visit for the best steak and seafood in the West.

The chain has been committed to Rocky Mountain hospitality since 2001.

You can enjoy fine dining in a casual-style atmosphere at this restaurant.

Their dinner menu includes a range of appetizers, including fried green tomatoes, crabmeat stuffed mushrooms, chicken wings, and boudin balls.

They offer premium hand-cut certified Angus steaks, with your choice of a dinner salad or soup and a house side.

The star on the menu is their award-winning baby back ribs.

Kids will be equally delighted to eat at this restaurant.

Their kids’ menu has meals that include a beverage and a side of fries, all served in a classic car to kids under 10.

You mustn’t fill up too much on the entrées, for you might miss out on their delightful desserts like the ice cream brownie sandwich, creme brulee, and apple cobbler, among others.

The drinks menu from their full-service bar is equally vast, including different wines and local beers.

Walk into Wyoming’s Rib & Chop House on North Main Street restaurant for a sumptuous lunch or dinner.

Silver Spur Cafe

Protein rich meal at Silver Spur Cafe
Silver Spur Cafe via Yelp.com

Serving some of the best breakfasts in Sheridan, Silver Spur Cafe has been around since 1934.

Over the years, they have been serving consistently fantastic food.

The Silver Spur Cafe favorites are the El Taco Grande, Calamity Jane (a French toast cinnamon roll and egg), and the Spur special.

They take pride in using locally purchased meat.

Choose from the various omelets, pancakes, and cinnamon French toast to satisfy your hunger.

Whether you go for their breakfast burrito, sticky buns, sausages, or steak, they’re a hit with the locals and a can’t-miss for visitors.

You must visit this splendid breakfast spot on North Main Street.

The Pony Bar and Grill

Sandwich at The Pony Bar and Grill
The Pony Bar and Grill via Yelp.com

Sitting on the corner of Gould and Loucks Street is The Pony Bar & Grill.

This local restaurant has been around since 1978 and sees plenty of foot traffic.

In the summertime, they offer outdoor seating on their large deck, with magnificent views of historic downtown Sheridan.

True to its name, the Pony offers 14 beers on tap and a full bar.

Among the grilled specialties are the Pony tuna melt, buffalo chicken wrap, BBQ brisket sandwich, Pony grilled cheese, and your choice of BLT.

Their range of salads, charbroiled burgers, sandwiches, tacos, bistro burgers, and platters make for a vast choice.

The Pony wings (crispy wings in your choice of flavors, served with carrots and celery and your choice of dipping sauce) are another one of their specialties.

Kids aren’t left out at The Pony Bar & Grill, thanks to their kids’ menu, which has a choice of drinks and sides.

This is an excellent place to hang out with friends over beer and for families to dine in.

Las Delicias

For some authentic Mexican food, Las Delicias on Broadway Street is the place to visit.

They have a wide variety of authentic Mexican dishes for lunch and dinner.

If you’re over 21, you can access a full bar serving margaritas, tequila shots, wines, whiskies, and Mexican and American beers.

You have various options for lunch and dinner, including fajitas, ranchero, chimichanga, enchiladas, burritos, and quesadillas.

The menu also has kid-friendly meals.

To end your Mexican meal the right way are some wonderful choices of Mexican desserts: strawberry banana chimichanga, sopapillas, churros, deep-fried ice cream, flan, and chimichanga de Manzana.

While it opened its doors in the summer of 2011, Las Delicias remains a local favorite and is committed to providing an excellent customer experience.

Sapporo Japanese Steakhouse

Salmon Avacado Rolls at Sapporo Japanese Steakhouse
Sapporo Japanese Steakhouse via Yelp.com

Sapporo Japanese Steakhouse is a fancy Japanese restaurant located on East Brundage Lane.

They provide a truly authentic Japanese experience with hibachi, sushi, and a full bar.

A good thing about Sapporo Japanese Steakhouse is that it also provides several gluten-free options on the menu.

For lunch, the menu includes sushi, sashimi, hibachi (served with mushroom soup, vegetables, and fried rice), and teriyaki (served with miso soup, fried rice, and steamed vegetables), among others.

The appetizers have a handful of raw options and several cooked ones—all fresh and eloquently displayed.

There are also soups, salads, and rolls to pick from.

For dinner, you could opt for a bento box (served with miso soup, house salad, California roll, gyoza, shrimp, tempura, and rice) or go with a hibachi dinner (served with soup, shrimp appetizer, mixed vegetables, and fried rice).

Some decent options are available for vegetarians, and a children's menu with no raw fish.

QDOBA Mexican Eats

Burrito bowls at QDOBA Mexican Eats
QDOBA Mexican Eats via Yelp.com

QDOBA Mexican eats on Coffee Avenue is all about genuine Mexican flavors.

This modern Mexican restaurant promises unique flavors and varieties you won’t find anywhere else.

They offer a classic menu, including burritos (and burrito bowls), nachos, quesadillas, and signature flavors (like their irresistible creamy three-cheese queso).

That’s not all; they let you top your entrées with guacamole and queso at no extra charge.

If you’re on a low-carb diet, a vegan or vegetarian, or prefer keto, gluten-friendly, high protein, or even low calories, QDOBA Mexican Eats has you covered.

With over 30 flavor-packed ingredients and almost endless flavor combos, you can create your own burrito (wrap or bowl).

This is the perfect place for family and kid meals.

Established in 2012, QDOBA Mexican Eats aims to bring a little flavor to your next meal.

Powder River Pizza

Pizza at Powder River Pizza
Powder River Pizza via Yelp.com

If you’re craving some great pizza in Sheridan, your next stop must be Powder River Pizza.

This pizzeria is on North Main Street and offers some of the most delicious pizzas.

You can build your own pizza here.

The range of soups, salads, sides, sandwiches, and broasted chicken specialties is as much as the range of pizzas.

If you’re not able to make up your mind on which premium pizza you’d like to order, they offer a premium sampler.

You can choose any four premium pizzas, and Powder River Pizza will combine them into one pizza; you get to check out several of their premium pizzas at once.

Apart from their bottomless beverages, they also have kids’ meals with drinks, a pickle spear, and a choice of sides.

They even have some delightful desserts like funnel cake, towering carrot cake, virgin root beer float, and adult root beer float.

PO News and Flagstaff Cafe

Sticky bun at PO News and Flagstaff Cafe
PO News and Flagstaff Cafe via Yelp.com

Located on the corner of South Main Street and East Loucks Street is PO News and Flagstaff Cafe, which was established in 2007.

The popular items on their menu include the no-carb omelet, gluten-free hot cakes, breakfast burrito, the Monroe, the Reuben, and English muffin.

They also have classic breakfast items like biscuits and gravy, thick-sliced French toast, eggs and toast, and oatmeal.

PO News and Flagstaff Cafe’s signature smash burgers and specialty sandwiches, with the lunch sides make for a filling meal.

Their drinks menu has many iced and hot beverages and espressos, like you would expect in a cafe.

With a friendly waitstaff and some of the best breakfasts in Sheridan, PO News and Flagstaff Cafe will have you returning regularly.

Midtown Cafe

Burger with curly fries at Midtown Cafe
Midtown Cafe via Yelp.com

Located on North Main Street, Midtown Cafe serves breakfast and lunch.

They use fresh ingredients and make their sauces and dressings from scratch.

The variety of meals on their menu will satisfy your appetite and tastebuds.

From French toast platters and burritos to Philly cheese steaks and grilled cheese sandwiches, they offer good portions.

There are lunch combos and popular items like quesadillas, panini, fish tacos, pizzas, and chicken strips.

You can even build your own salad at Midtown Cafe.

They offer a vast selection of teas, frappes, espressos, and hot and cold drinks.

Equally vast are their choice of dairy- and gluten-free smoothies made with fruit, with the option to choose vegan milk for milk-based smoothies.

The warm cafe ambiance and generous portions will leave you one satisfied customer.

Killy’s Smokehouse Deli

Ribeye at Killy’s Smokehouse Deli
Killy’s Smokehouse Deli via Yelp.com

From starting as a grocery store in 1968, Killy’s Smokehouse Deli is a family-owned business that transitioned into a barbeque restaurant in 2016.

They offer traditional starters, including brisket rolls, tater tots, onion rings, jalapeno poppers, and mozzarella sticks.

Along with sandwiches and burgers, they also have fish and fries and Shepherd’s pie.

Smoked plates are their specialty, and they serve smoked baby back ribs, smoked beef brisket, and the smoked trio (baby back ribs, beef brisket, and BBQ pulled pork).

The beer options have domestic, imported, Wyoming-brewed, and craft beers.

There’s also the choice of seltzer, cider, and coolers.

You’ll be spoilt for choice with the whiskeys, gins, vodkas, rums, schnapps, tequilas, liqueurs, and brandy.

Drop by Killy’s Smokehouse Deli on East Brundage Lane for great food and drinks.

El Tapatio Dos

Tacos at El Tapatio Dos
El Tapatio Dos via Yelp.com

Adding to the amazing Mexican places to dine at Sheridan is El Tapatio Dos on North Main Street.

Located in a former residence, they have indoor, outdoor, and backyard patio seating, with prompt and friendly service.

El Tapatio Dos serves authentic Mexican food, as the owner of this place is also from Mexico.

Their menu is all things Mexican from start to end—burritos, tacos, enchiladas, chimichanga, quesadillas, fajitas, and combos.

Eating excellently prepared fresh food at the quaint little house feels like dining at home.

Firewater Smokehouse Grill

Meat combo plate at Firewater Smokehouse Grill
Firewater Smokehouse Grill via Yelp.com

Situated on North Main Street is Firewater Smokehouse Grill.

You can have some good wine or delicious beer alongside perfectly cooked onion rings, pork, or chicken wings.

Firewater Smokehouse Grill is known for their fantastic chicken fried steak and ribs that fall off the bone.

Apart from steaks and chops, their burgers and sandwiches will have you drooling.

With an almost homely atmosphere and a friendly staff that provides good service, Firewater Smokehouse Grill is an excellent place for lunch and dinner.

They even have a comfortable, shaded outdoor seating area if you like outdoor dining.

Perkins Restaurant and Bakery

Pie at Perkins Restaurant and Bakery
Perkins Restaurant and Bakery via Yelp.com

From being founded as a single pancake house in Ohio in 1958, Perkins Restaurant and Bakery has expanded to nearly 300 restaurants.

Their Sheridan outlet is located on Coffee Avenue.

They serve breakfast all day and have a kids’ menu, a senior menu, and healthy and vegetarian options.

At Perkins Restaurant and Bakery, you have the option to build your own breakfast with the items you like and choose from their categories.

During the pumpkin season, they even have a special Perkins Pumpkin menu, including a pumpkin spice pancake platter.

They have some delicious pies, muffins, cookies, and cakes you can’t miss after a hearty meal here.

Smith Alley Brewing Company

Sandwich and nuggets at Smith Alley Brewing Company
Smith Alley Brewing Company via Yelp.com

Smith Alley Brewing Company is a brewing company and a public house on North Main Street.

Good beer needs to go with good food.

At Smith Alley Brewing Company, it’s all about good burgers, sandwiches, appetizers, craft wings, chili, and salads.

They have a rotating cheesecake for desserts that you must try.

You can ask for gluten-free and vegetarian options as well.

Kids aren’t left out here—they have food for the kiddos, too!

Final Thoughts

Some of the best restaurants in Sheridan, Wyoming, complement the scenic views and the Old West vibes.

Most of the famous restaurants here are big on their breakfast offerings.

Good portions, a range of cuisines, and excellent service are typical of Sheridan’s eateries.

You’ll return happy, content, and with a full tummy from any of these places.

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.