20 Best Restaurants in Lancaster, OH

Best Restaurants in Lancaster, OH
Eric Glenn / shutterstock.com

Lancaster is a charming city in Fairfield County, Ohio.

It's also known as "The Glass City" because it was a leading glassware manufacturer.

Lancaster has a great small-town feel with many small business owners and a wide variety of eclectic and unique shops.

Tourists can visit museums, explore wineries, and travel back in time with a drive-in movie at the Skyview Cruise-In Theatre.

Besides such attractions, Lancaster, Ohio, also offers unique dining options, including barbeque dishes or Chinese and Italian cuisine.

If you're visiting Lancaster and looking to experience incredible local flavors, visit these best restaurants in Lancaster, Ohio:

Cherry Street Pub

Chicken and Waffles at Cherry Street Pub
Foursquare City Guide

Cherry Street Pub is the place to go if you're after homemade comfort food.

When visiting this 100-year-old building, you'll feel like you're visiting an old English Pub.

It's casual, cozy, and has a few modern finishes with an old-worldly charm.

Mac and Cheese at Cherry Street Pub
Foursquare City Guide

When dining at the Cherry Street Pub, try popular dishes like the Pecan Chicken and waffles, pork tacos, lobster mac and cheese, and traditional bread pudding.

The Cherry Street Pub is open from Tuesdays to Saturdays and is located at Cherry Street.

This restaurant, unlike others, has been around since 1966 and operated under the name Billy Crickets.

Frisch’s Big Boy

Breakfast Burritos at Frisch’s Big Boy
Foursquare City Guide

Frisch's Big Boy is a chain restaurant located at River Valley Circle.

The first ever Frisch's was opened in 1905 in Ohio and continued to grow and gain popularity among locals.

Pancakes and Bacon at Frisch’s Big Boy
Foursquare City Guide

Frisch’s Big Boy is famous for its classic American-style menu items.

If you're visiting Lancaster, stop at Frisch's for that classic diner feel.

You can enjoy traditional American dishes like buffalo popcorn shrimp baskets, pecan pie, and a club melt.

Texas Roadhouse

Texas Roadhouse is not your average steakhouse.

This iconic establishment offers hand-cut steaks, mouth-watering ribs, ice-cold beer, and freshly baked bread.

Kent Taylor opened the first Texas Roadhouse in 1993, and more branches were established as the restaurant started making a name for itself.

Besides visiting for a basket of freshly made bread, Texas Roadhouse is ideal for anyone who loves steakhouse classics.

The restaurant is located on Lincoln Highway.

Rockmill Brewery

Rockmill Brewery opened in 2010 on a 23-acre, 19th-century horse farm.

It's a must-visit if you want to try exciting craft beer flavors amid a stunning relaxing outdoor space.

However, its offerings are not limited to beer, as it has various delicious food options too.

Rockmill Brewery is located on Lithopolis Road.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Are you looking for a delicious classic Italian meal?

The Olive Garden is a great restaurant to experience exquisite Italian dishes, conveniently located east of Highway 33 across the River Valley Mall at Schorrway Drive.

It's perfect for family dining, especially if you're on a budget.

It offers family-style meals that serve four to six people and include options like lasagne, chicken alfredo, and chicken and shrimp carbonara.

The Olive Garden was founded in 1982 and offers a casual dining atmosphere.

Wild Ginger Asian Bistro

Wild Ginger Asian Bistro is known for its incredible sushi and Asian dishes.

This Chinese restaurant is famous for its modern interpretation of classic dishes and the freshest ingredients.

Whether you're dining in or ordering take-out, the Wild Ginger Asian Bistro is worth trying.

Some of its best dishes are the Lancaster roll, rainbow roll, and their love boat for two.

if you don't like sushi, you can order their famous Sesame Chicken or their Hong Kong chicken.

If you’re exploring Lancaster, stop by Wild Ginger Asian Bistro on Memorial Drive for delicious authentic Chinese food.

Todd’s Mountain View Restaurant

Like many other restaurants in Lancaster, Todd's Mountain View Restaurant has an old-school diner feel.

However, locals love Todd's because it offers home-style cooking, generous portion sizes, and affordable rates.

It's also the only restaurant that provides all-day breakfast in Lancaster.

The menu includes pancakes and bacon, chicken wrap, sweet potato fries, and French toast.

Todd’s Mountian View Restaurant was founded in 1968 and is a family-run business.

Some locals have been visiting Todd’s for over 25 years.

This establishment is located on West Fair Avenue.

Red Lobster

The Red Lobster on River Valley Circle has been around since 1968.

It has a few branches across the U.S and is one of the most popular seafood restaurants in America.

The Red Lobster is popular because of their daily specials, endless shrimp, and signature feasts, including a date night feast for two.

It's your perfect go-to restaurant if you want to indulge in seafood.

Ale House 1890

Tomahawk Steak at Ale House 1890
Foursquare City Guide

Ale House 1890 is located at 149 Main Street in downtown Lancaster.

Before it was called Ale House, the restaurant was known as the minute bar, and a portion of the restaurant has been around since 1890.

Kitchen of the Ale House 1890
Foursquare City Guide

In 2014 Ale House 1980 expanded, but it continues to showcase the history of the town of Lancaster to this day, drawing locals due to its long-standing reputation

The restaurant is known for delicious food and incredible craft beer and spirits.

On your visit, try popular dishes like calamari, pretzel bites, Barnyard Burger, and prime sirloin steak.

Jb’s Downtown Grill

Jb’s Downtown Grill on North Columbus Street grinds and trims their beef chuck and brisket from scratch to make their signature burgers.

Jamie and Beth Brumbaugh own the restaurant, with Chef Jaimie creating all the meals.

The restaurant features wooden floors, exposed brick walls, and tables with checkered tablecloths.

It's a great spot for breakfast or lunch, with their cinnamon rolls an absolute must-try.

You shouldn't miss Jb's Sunday brunch if you prefer to eat later in the day.

If you’re in downtown Lancaster, visit Jb’s for tasty, wholesome, and thoughtfully made food.

Kanji Japanese Steakhouse and Sushi Bar

Peacock Sushi Platter at Kanji Japanese Steakhouse and Sushi Bar
Foursquare City Guide

Kanji Japanese Steakhouse and Sushi Bar has the finest hibachi and sushi in Lancaster.

They offer dine-in and take-out options and is located on North Memorial Drive.

Dragon Sushi Platter at Kanji Japanese Steakhouse and Sushi Bar
Foursquare City Guide

Kanji Japanese Restaurant has outstanding chefs and has won awards for being the best in Fairfield County.

If you’re visiting Lancaster and looking for authentic Japanese cuisine, try Kanji's lunch special, which includes Hibachi chicken, shrimp, and steak.

Fiesta Tropicana

Drinks at Fiesta Tropicana
Foursquare City Guide

Experience unique flavors, Mexico's art and culture, and laid-back dining at Fiesta Tropicana.

At Fiesta Tropicana, you'll enjoy authentic Mexican-style Fajitas, burritos, chimichangas, and enchiladas.

This establishment is one of Lancaster’s best Mexican restaurants and has been open for over 20 years.

It's popular among locals and is one of the best restaurants to visit if you want authentic Mexican food.

Fiesta Tropicana is on North Memorial Drive.

Osteria Alla Romana

Pasta at Osteria Alla Romana
Foursquare City Guide

Osteria Alla Romana is a quaint little Italian restaurant on Tiki Lane.

This gem of a restaurant serves authentic Italian food made by an Italian chef.

Every Italian dish is made fresh on order, and although it does take a while for your dish to arrive, it's guaranteed to be delicious.

Ravioli at Osteria Alla Romana
Foursquare City Guide

Osteria Alla Romana opened in 2016, and the owner Cris still runs the restaurant today.

Expect to taste classic lasagne, pizza, and ravioli dishes.

While this restaurant doesn't look like much from the outside, it's worth visiting for its authentic Italian food.

O’huids Gaelic Pub

O’huids Gaelic Pub on  Main Street is a family-run pub that offers an authentic Irish take on American pub favorites.

If you love an authentic Irish pub atmosphere with some classics like corned beef, loaded fries, homemade kettle chips, and bangers and mash, you must visit O’huids Gaelic Pub.

The pub opened its doors in 2017 and is popular among locals.

If you love pub-style food and are looking for a great dinner spot to visit, stop by O’huids Gaelic Pub.

The Pink Cricket Restaurant

The Pink Cricket is the longest-standing restaurant in Lancaster.

This family-owned establishment offers a relaxed dining experience with family and friends and is popular for its delicious pizzas.

The Pink Cricket is located on Main Street.

If you want to enjoy pizza in a retro-style diner, the Pink Cricket is the perfect place.

The Mediterranean

Dessert at The Mediterranean
Foursquare City Guide

The Mediterranean is a traditional Greek, Italian, and American restaurant.

The restaurant is family-owned, and all the meals are prepared fresh and purchased from local suppliers.

Try their bestsellers, which include the Chicken Gyro, fries, tzatziki, and falafel sandwich.

Pasta at The Mediterranean
Foursquare City Guide

The Mediterranean satisfies your craving for Greek food and is a good option if you want a flavourful dining experience.

It was established in 2008 and is located on Memorial Drive.


You'll be spoilt for choice when visiting Castaways on N High Street.

It has an extensive menu offering steak, pizza, seafood, and sandwiches.

This American restaurant offers cozy and quaint dining with a menu of all-time favorite dishes.

Whether you prefer dining inside or outside on the patio, Castaways is a great place to visit for authentic American food.

Castaways has been around for more than 70 years.

Briggs Sandwiches

Briggs Sandwiches on Garfield Avenue is known for the best burgers and fries in Lancaster and its friendly service.

It's a family-owned restaurant that has been around since 1965.

Besides offering delicious burgers and very generous portion sizes, Briggs Sandwiches also offers affordable meals.

All their ingredients are locally sourced, including non-GMO beef for their burgers.

If you're on the move and looking to grab a burger that will curb your hunger pangs, Briggs Sandwiches is a great place to eat out.

Final Thoughts

Most of the restaurants in Lancaster are pub-style or diners that offer comfort food and a family-friendly dining experience.

Whether you're after buttermilk pancakes and bacon for breakfast or seafood for dinner, Lancaster has some excellent restaurants.

Their portion sizes are impressive, and most restaurants have affordable rates.

You'll have a pleasant dining experience when you visit these best restaurants in Lancaster, Ohio.

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.