Rochester's Finest: 18 Incredible Dining Experiences in Rochester, NY

Travel Lens

Nov 12, 2023 • 13 min read

Rochester, New York, is home to a dynamic culinary landscape, ranging from quaint family-owned establishments to sophisticated gastronomic venues. Each restaurant enriches the city's varied food culture.

Common features of these culinary sanctuaries include enticing smells, lively patrons, and an inviting ambiance.

However, the appeal extends beyond mere sustenance. The dishes served embody narratives, uphold traditions, and nurture community bonds.

This article provides an overview of Rochester's top restaurants, where every dish offers a unique experience.

Rella Oysters

The inviting atmosphere at Rella Oysters immediately gives patrons a sense of comfort and familiarity. Known for its throwback charm and eclectic seafood menu, it's an ideal spot for a casual dinner or a cozy date night.

Upon entering Rella's, the unique open kitchen concept is immediately noticeable. The steam-powered wok-like pans contribute to the ambiance, blending seamlessly with the retro decor.

However, it's the food that truly distinguishes Rella's. With a limited menu, every dish is guaranteed to be fresh and prepared to perfection. Highlighted offerings include shrimp rolls, mushroom bruschetta, and a special Branzino filet, all of which are flavorful masterpieces, expertly balanced and perfectly seasoned.

The raw oysters are particularly exceptional. Served ice-cold, they're so fresh that they seem to melt in the mouth, and are topped with scallion and tuna for a unique flavor combination.

Complementing the outstanding food is Rella's excellent service. The staff are friendly and attentive, ensuring that every customer feels welcomed and taken care of. The restaurant's cozy, close-knit atmosphere enhances the overall dining experience.

For those who haven't yet visited Rella Oysters, it's a must-try destination. Whether a seafood lover or just in search of a unique dining experience, there's something for everyone to enjoy. And, after one visit, it's likely patrons will be eager to return and sample more of the menu.

Rooney's Restaurant

Rooney's Restaurant, nestled in a serene residential area, offers an inviting and unassuming atmosphere.

Its long wooden bar sets a warm and welcoming tone.

The menu at Rooney's promises a gastronomic journey with each bite.

The teres major, a tender beef cut, is a notable highlight.

Other standout dishes include rack of lamb, shrimps, escargot, and the signature dessert, crème brûlée.

The caramelized sugar top of the crème brûlée reveals a creamy, vanilla-infused custard beneath.

In addition to its remarkable food, Rooney's boasts excellent service.

Its quiet ambiance encourages engaging conversation, making it an ideal location for a relaxed, romantic dinner.

Rooney's Restaurant has become a 'must-visit' for locals and visitors alike.

Tapas 177

Tapas 177 stands out in the city's culinary scene, impressing with its global fusion of flavors. Ranging from egg rolls to empanadas, it serves as a gastronomic haven.

The restaurant consistently evolves its menu, maintaining an unwavering quality of food since its establishment.

The ambiance of Tapas 177 adds to its appeal. Its dimly lit space, courtyard, and salsa dancing nights create an inviting and intimate atmosphere.

Despite its higher-end pricing, the quality justifies the cost. The food, consistently excellent, compensates for any potential cocktail discrepancies.

Tapas 177's unique offerings, like the fresh avocado roll, showcase its approach to global fusion cuisine, making diverse dishes palatable for all.

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que is an irresistible destination known for its Southern-style barbecue.

Its retro setting and live music create a charming atmosphere.

The smoked wings, smoked to perfection, are a highlight, offering intense flavor.

An impressive selection of draft brews accompanies the meats.

The ribs are another standout, known for their delectable taste.

The restaurant's Mac and cheese is creamy, cheesy, and unexpectedly spicy.

Their cornbread is a fantastic addition that complements any barbecue dish.

The service at Dinosaur Bar-B-Que is commendable, contributing to its reputation as a local favorite.

Visitors to the area are encouraged to experience a meal at this popular establishment.

Nosh

Nosh, a Rochester gem, artfully combines modern American cuisine with a Korean twist.
Its industrial-chic decor in a restored factory sets the stage for a gastronomic journey.

The restaurant's efficient online reservation system ensures a smooth booking process.
Exceptional customer service further elevates the Nosh experience.

Their cocktails offer a diverse range of flavor profiles.
The food consistently delights, with special mentions for the prime rib and the Big Kahuna.

The dishes, while generously portioned, maintain a delicate balance of intense flavors and freshness.
These features make every visit to Nosh a memorable culinary experience.

The Cub Room

The Cub Room, located in Rochester, offers an outstanding dining experience. The gourmet food aroma wafting from the kitchen sets the stage for a delightful meal. Exceptional service, with knowledgeable staff providing excellent menu and cocktail suggestions, complements the food.

The cuisine stands out for its culinary excellence, with every dish cooked to perfection and unique flavor pairings that delight. Standout dishes include the scallops and a perfectly prepared chicken. The humble brussels sprouts are transformed into something extraordinary.

On another occasion, the halibut and a spaghetti special with razor clams and roe pleased the palate, showcasing a balance of ingredients and flavors. The desserts provide a fitting end to an impressive culinary experience.

Despite slightly loud background music, the overall journey remains seamless. The ahi tuna appetizer and the gnudi, a delightful dish, are worth noting. The vegetarian options are creative and appealing, presented brightly and colorfully.

The Cub Room, a hidden gem, blends an industrial-style tavern aesthetic with elevated cocktails and an upscale seasonal menu.

Good Luck Restaurant

Discovering hidden gems in the city is always thrilling, such as the Good Luck Restaurant. Its unassuming entrance belies the culinary treats that await within its industrial yet intimate warehouse-style interior.

Good Luck offers an innovative, upscale dining experience. Despite a relatively static menu, the dishes consistently impress with their mouth-watering appeal.

The restaurant's unique approach encourages sharing dishes, reminiscent of Tapas style dining. The menu features a wide variety, from burgers and salads to braised fennel, walnut pasta, and duck breast.

The standout dish is their house-made malloreddus, a must-try for any visitor. However, reservations are recommended to avoid being seated at the bar.

Their cocktail menu is equally impressive, boasting a range of unique concoctions. The peach, black tea, and violently citrus cocktail are particularly noteworthy.

Dessert lovers will appreciate their homemade ice creams and the Basque cheesecake. An unexpected delight is the fries' accompanying sauce - a surprising blend of ketchup, mayo, and brandy.

In essence, a visit to Good Luck is a culinary adventure, offering a unique food journey with each visit.

Redd

Redd, a top-notch restaurant in the city, is renowned for its California wine country-inspired cuisine.

The elegance of Redd's sleek design and spacious environment enhances the dining experience.

Diners can enjoy watching the culinary masters at work from their tables, a delightful feature of the restaurant.

Redd's personalized service and attention to detail make any celebration feel special.

The menu is a gateway to an extraordinary culinary journey, with each dish crafted to perfection.

The extensive wine list offers a curated tour through the world's most exquisite vineyards.

Innovative cocktails are another highlight at Redd, with the 'How to disappear completely' bourbon cocktail being a standout.

Main courses, such as the Cioppino and the bee sting pizza, offer unique and delicious flavors.

The 'Cookies and Cream' trifle is a recommended dessert, providing a perfect end to the dining experience.

Redd is more than just a restaurant; it's an extraordinary dining experience.

The Owl House

The Owl House, a unique restaurant in Rochester, offers an ever-changing menu within a converted house, providing a bohemian ambiance.

Its picturesque backyard setting enhances the overall charm, creating an illusion of a quaint European town.

The Owl House stands out for its vegan-friendly menu, offering both vegan and non-vegan options.

The flavorful food, including a popular Tofu Sandwich, is served promptly and hot, ensuring customer satisfaction.

Other crowd favorites include Tofu n Waffles and the Tofu Breakfast Sandwich, with perfectly cooked tofu scramble and flavorful potatoes.

Despite the potential for noise due to table proximity, The Owl House is a notable addition to the Rochester food scene.

Cure

Located in Rochester's heart lies Cure, a unique blend of French cuisine and craft cocktails.

This local favorite buzzes with energy.

Cure's ambiance is akin to a chic market eatery, instantly invigorating its visitors.

Known for its baking prowess, Cure's bread is often compared to comfort on a chilly evening.

The focus, however, remains on the seasonal French cuisine, each dish either striking a perfect chord or presenting a familiar flavor with a novel twist.

Every meal served is a gastronomic delight.

Beyond the food, Cure is renowned for its craft cocktails.

Custom-made cocktails based on customer preferences are a regular feature.

Cure serves as an ideal location for unwinding or indulging in a gourmet meal.

The exemplary service further elevates the dining experience.

Repeated visits to Cure are a testament to its consistent quality and enjoyment.

It provides a much-needed respite for adults seeking a culinary retreat.

Edibles Restaurant and Bar

Edibles Restaurant and Bar offers a lively atmosphere, ideal for a Friday night out.

The establishment is renowned for its exquisite American Bistro cuisine with an organic focus.

Signature dishes include a sangria special, hearty lobster bisque, artichokes French, and the standout Burkle Burger.

The food at Edibles is not just delicious, but a memorable experience.

Despite a bustling environment, the service maintains its high standard, reflecting professionalism and customer focus.

The warm, friendly environment, accentuated by brick and wood decor, is inviting.

The lively cocktail bar, featuring specials like the gummy bear martini, adds to the appeal.

Jines Restaurant

Strolling down Park Avenue, the inviting atmosphere of Jines Restaurant stands out. This Greek diner is a popular spot for hearty breakfasts and relaxing Sunday brunches. The sidewalk seating adds to its charm.

The Mediterranean Omelette is a standout, with an exquisite blend of flavors. Other favorites include a savory spanakopita and a sweet potato, apple, walnut, dried cranberries, and goat cheese quiche. Apple cinnamon mimosas provide a heavenly finish.

Jines has been a staple in the Rochester restaurant scene for decades. Be aware of potential parking challenges during peak hours. Enjoy the local architecture on a short walk to the restaurant.

Roux

Roux, a hidden gem in the city, offers a unique experience reminiscent of a French bistro.

Its sophisticated French cuisine is far from simple, presenting extraordinary dishes that captivate the palate.

The onion soup stands out, while the innovative treatment of vegetables sets a new standard.

Unexpectedly, Roux's burgers rank among the city's best.

However, the real showstopper is the brunch, complemented by cocktails and specialty coffee.

The Camambert appetizer, paired with jellied fig spread and fresh herbs, is a delightful surprise.

For the main course, the Croque Madam or the Waffle Sammy come highly recommended.

Beyond the food, Roux's ambiance, welcoming atmosphere, and excellent service enhance the overall experience.

Despite the cozy seating arrangement, it contributes to the charming vibe of the place.

Tournedos Steakhouse

An evening at the iconic Tournedos Steakhouse in the city center promises a memorable experience.

The valet service and plush mahogany-bar lounge set the stage for a versatile dining experience, be it a romantic dinner or a family gathering.

Under new ownership, the restaurant maintains its excellent service and enhances the ambiance with refurbishments.

Tournedos' menu is a haven for meat enthusiasts, boasting an extensive selection of over 500 wines.

Their dry-aged steaks consistently achieve perfection, and the seafood offerings are equally commendable.

The crab cake stands out, rivaling even Maine's finest seafood, while the scallops, oysters, and pork belly are also noteworthy.

A side of onion rings with Cajun dipping sauce adds a delightful touch.

Tournedos makes celebrations special, often offering complimentary champagne toasts for birthdays.

Lento

Lento, a renowned restaurant in the city, is a beacon of the vibrant culinary scene. Its warm, softly lit ambiance provides a relaxed evening setting.

The menu showcases New American cuisine, with dishes crafted from locally sourced meats and produce. A paradise for oyster lovers, Lento offers a wide range of options.

The salads are as enticing as the meat dishes, with the Venison Bolognese being a standout. Desserts, especially the crème brûlée and profiteroles, are a must-try.

In addition, Lento uses locally sourced sodas, providing a refreshing break from big brand names. The service is exceptional, adding to the overall experience.

The Gate House

The Gate House, located in Rochester, is a casual, kid-friendly American café with a creative menu.

It offers hearty, satisfying meals with generous portions, ensuring customers leave content.

The food is flavorful, expertly balancing comfort and culinary craftsmanship.

The ambiance of The Gate House radiates coziness and warmth, making it suitable for various occasions.

Highlighted dishes include The Wease burger with garlic rosemary fries and the Strong Margherita pizza, both offering unique flavors that distinguish them from typical café fare.

Pane Vino On The River

Pane Vino On The River, a charming Italian restaurant, is ideally situated by the riverside.

The setting is atmospheric, with an outdoor patio offering stunning river views and cozy outdoor heaters.

The restaurant is renowned for its divine Italian cuisine.

From tantalizing coconut shrimp appetizers to hearty lasagna and perfectly cooked Eggplant Parmesan, the menu is diverse.

Accompanying fresh bread, seasoned butter, spiced olive oil, and grated cheese add a delightful touch to any chosen dish.

An impressive cocktail and wine menu, featuring an unbeatable Moscato, complements the food.

The restaurant's standout feature is its welcoming staff.

Rocco

Rocco, a cozy Italian eatery in the city, offers an authentic Italian experience. Its quaint, compact space exudes an old-world charm, making reservations advisable for larger groups.

The food is a highlight, with housemade ricotta cheese standing out as a classic Italian favorite. The menu, while varied, maintains appealing simplicity; the squid dish is expertly cooked and highly recommended.

Complementing the food, Rocco also offers a rotating Italian wine list and unique cocktails. The robust red wines pair well with the meals, enhancing the dining experience.

Exceptional service and standout dishes like the Paulie G pizza have made Rocco a popular spot in the city.

Final Thoughts

Rochester, New York, boasts an impressive array of top-tier eateries.

The city's vibrant dining scene is a constant source of excitement.

New culinary discoveries are always on the horizon.

💌

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.

✍️

Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.