12 Incredible Restaurants in Sandusky, Ohio You Need to Try

Sandusky, Ohio

In the heart of the Midwest, nestled along the shorelines of Lake Erie, lies Sandusky, Ohio - a quaint city known for its rich history, beautiful scenery, and welcoming community. But for the enthusiastic gastronome, Sandusky is a hidden treasure trove, offering a delightful blend of traditional American fare and innovative culinary experiences.

Unbeknownst to many, this Ohio gem is home to a myriad of incredible restaurants, each exuding its unique charm and boasting menus that would satiate even the most discerning palate.

Join us, as we embark on a culinary journey through Sandusky's dining scene, where we'll unearth the city's best-kept gastronomic secrets, from unassuming local diners to elegant fine-dining establishments. W

A Bite into Eclecticism: Zuppaman Sandwich Shop

Zuppaman · 1186 Cleveland Rd W, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Sandwich shop

Don't judge this sandwich shop by its cover. Zuppaman sits modestly in Sandusky, not too far from the bustling shopping stores. Once past its unassuming exterior, a world of eclectic charm, friendly staff, and an extensive menu of mouth-watering sandwiches unravel before your eyes.

The menu offers a stellar selection of sandwiches that cater to all palates, with the added option to build your own for those who prefer a more personalized meal. Each sandwich is made to order, a testament to the shop's commitment to serve only the freshest to its patrons. Among the crowd-pleaser is the 'Momma Mia', a tribute to hearty Italian sandwiches, massive enough to satiate two hungry souls.

Zuppaman goes the extra mile to offer side dishes that echo the homemade charm of its sandwiches. Their pasta salad, which looks and tastes like your grandmother's own recipe, is a hit among regulars.

The owner of Zuppaman, known for his affable disposition, greets guests and walks them through the menu, adding a personal touch to the dining experience. While the quality and quantity of food already put this hotspot on the map, this unique customer service is truly the icing on the cake.

While the city of Sandusky has a plethora of dining options, Zuppaman with its out-of-the-world taste and unique style makes it a must-visit on every food explorer's list. Be it for its amazing food, the bang for your buck, or the promise of a novel dining experience, Zuppaman surely deserves more than a 5-star rating.

A Slice of Heaven at Brick Oven Bistro

Brick Oven Bistro · 1012 Cleveland Rd W, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Pizza restaurant

Imagine savoring a perfectly prepared pizza, with toppings of your choice, in a cozy, friendly environment after a long day of exhilarating experiences at Cedar Point. That's precisely what patrons get at the Brick Oven Bistro.

The pizzeria, which you can visit at brickovenohio.com, has been serving customers since 2022, and its reputation has been steadily accumulating ever since. The crowd favorites are the build-your-own pizzas and calzones, and there's even a gluten-free option for health-conscious diners.

The Brick Oven Bistro's offerings are not limited to pizzas alone. The Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, meatballs served with garlic bread, and their garlic parm wings are reportedly to die for. After a long day at the park, this pizzeria is the perfect pit stop to satiate one's hunger in style.

The ambiance within the Bistro is both inviting and comfortable, with clean, well-maintained facilities. For young diners, the Bistro provides activity papers and crayons, ensuring the little ones are entertained as the adults dine. The waitstaff, such as Erin who was singled out for her pleasant demeanor and attentive service, contribute to the overall enjoyable dining experience.

So, for those planning a trip to Cedar Point, ensure to include a visit to Brick Oven Bistro. It's not merely a meal, but a culinary experience that blends delicious food with a warm and welcoming environment.

A Homestyle Experience at Berardi's Family Kitchen

Berardi’s Family Kitchen · 1019 W Perkins Ave, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Family restaurant

The nostalgic charm of small-town family-run restaurants is a rare find in the modern gastronomy world. One such gem is Berardi's Family Kitchen, located in the heart of Sandusky. This delightful eatery presents a sense of familiarity, greeting all its customers with amicable service as if they've been treasured regulars for years.

The expansive menu at Berardi's Family Kitchen is a delightful blend of homestyle American and Italian favorites. One can relish a hearty breakfast or lunch at reasonable prices, with the generous portion sizes amplifying the value for money. Some of the standout dishes include their perfectly cooked omelets and their outstanding potatoes.

One noteworthy feature of Berardi's Family Kitchen is their innovative approach to substitutions. Guests rave about the decision to exchange the regular diced potatoes for the establishment's celebrated fries. These are renowned for their perfect texture - crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside, and the added garlic seasoning elevates them to another level of deliciousness.

But the satisfaction doesn't end there! The restaurant delivers an exceptional brunch experience as well, with dishes like steak and eggs drawing widespread approval and the steak remains undeniably delicious.

Savoring a Modern Spin on Classics at J Bistro Downtown

J Bistro Downtown · 129 W Market St, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Fine dining restaurant

In the heart of Sandusky, there's a chic establishment that whips up classic American fare with a modern twist, J Bistro Downtown. The interior is tastefully decorated with wooden accents that create a contemporary yet cozy atmosphere.

However, the ambiance can get lively, especially on bustling Friday nights, when the restaurant transforms into a vibrant dining area echoing with cheerful chatter. This is not just a spot for quiet, fine dining but a place to catch the vibrant energy of the city. Here, guests might need to be prepared for some unexpected surprises on their plates. An unusual example would be the shrimp tacos appetizer, where the seafood is blanketed in shredded cheddar cheese, a twist not commonly seen elsewhere.

Continuing its streak of surprising its patrons, J Bistro Downtown sometimes substitutes regular ingredients with innovative alternatives. A prime example would be replacing standard mashed potatoes with their sweet counterparts in their steak dishes. Although this might not be to the liking of traditional palates, the steaks themselves are perfectly cooked and packed with flavor.

Dine at The Club Restaurant & Bar

The Club Restaurant & Bar · 1220 Sycamore Line, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Stepping into The Club Restaurant & Bar is like stepping back in time. With an atmosphere reminiscent of an old-style pub, it's easy to imagine the establishment as the backdrop for intriguing tales of yesteryears. The Club, prominently located in Sandusky, can make a visitor feel nostalgic even on their first visit. Visit their website here for more details.

The restaurant's stylings are quaintly vintage, right down to the ceiling fans powered by a single motor and linked together with belts. However, it isn't just the atmosphere that's noteworthy. The food here goes beyond typical pub fare and definitely warrants a try. A special mention goes to their lasagna, which is so popular that they might run out by the end of the night.

The Club also draws praise for its generous portion sizes. The Tomahawk steak, for instance, is nothing short of amazing, while the perch served on a bed of fries is considered one of the best around. The Club's Rosa Pasta and Pasta Capri are other crowd pleasers. And, of course, a meal at The Club wouldn't be complete without their cannolis.

The Club is a restaurant that puts customer satisfaction first. They are known to accommodate last-minute diners, even when the kitchen is about to close. Visitors can appreciate the dedication of the staff, with the chef personally serving meals to ensure the best experience. The Club Restaurant & Bar is a shining gem in Sandusky, providing a perfect setting for a date night or a hearty meal after a long day at Cedar Point.

Exquisite Dining at Vita

Vita · 256 Columbus Ave, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Bistro

In the heart of Sandusky, Ohio, is an alluring establishment known for its delectable cuisine and unique dining experiences - Vita. Its website - vitasandusky.com - offers a snapshot of what to expect when you step into the captivating building. Patrons are often entranced by the bewitching architecture and elegant interior.

Vita is renowned for its hot plate dinners, allowing you to cook your own meat right at your table. A carnivore's delight, the meat served is succulent and flavorful, and the experience of cooking it yourself is an enjoyable novelty.

As if the delightful dinner offerings weren't enough, Vita also serves up a remarkable breakfast. The Prosciutto Croissant has been hailed as the best breakfast sandwich by some patrons, a testament to the culinary prowess at Vita.

It’s not just the food that makes Vita a must-visit destination. The atmosphere is vibrant and light, making it an ideal location for a family outing or a large group gathering. Whether you’re seeking an interactive dining experience, a delectable breakfast, or just a perfect spot to unwind, Vita is sure to leave a lasting impression.

Experience the Fusion of Brews and Asian Cuisine at Small City Taphouse

Small City Taphouse · 202 Columbus Ave, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Asian fusion restaurant

In a city brimming with culinary delights, Small City Taphouse stands out as a unique fusion of a craft brew pub and an Asian gastronomic adventure. Residing within an industrial-chic interior, this popular outpost serves an eclectic mix of draft microbrews, sushi, and Pan-Asian plates.

The highlight of the Taphouse is the emphasis on quality and flavor. The dishes, notably the spicy tuna and spicy crab rolls, showcase the complexity and richness of Asian cuisine. Each plate is a carefully crafted balance of spices and fresh ingredients, creating a gastronomic experience that is worth savoring.

The beer list at Small City Taphouse is nothing short of spectacular. It showcases an eclectic mix of local drafts and bottled brews, catering to both novices and seasoned beer enthusiasts.

Indulge in Wake Up And Waffle

WAKE UP AND WAFFLE · 122 E Water St, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Imagine starting your morning with a sip of an excellent carrot mimosa and a bite of the best eggs benedict you've ever had. Welcome to the gastronomical world of Wake Up And Waffle, a breakfast haven that is winning the hearts of its patrons with its scrumptious food and friendly staff.

This delightful restaurant has built a reputation for serving food that is not just delicious, but made from scratch every time. Their chicken and waffles are a testament to this commitment. The chicken is hand-breaded and is fresh out of the fryer, pairing perfectly with waffles that are elevated by the addition of pearl sugar. The only caveat is the small size of the establishment, so if you plan a visit on the weekend, getting there early is advisable.

Not just a paradise for meat lovers, Wake Up And Waffle also has an extensive creative menu for vegetarians. Their brioche waffles, either sweet or savory, are among the favorites, offering a diverse range of options for any palate. Many patrons find it hard to resist a second visit, making it an essential stop before heading back home.

Uncover the Barbecue Magic at Derrick Jr's BBQ

Derrick Jr’s BBQ · 133 E Market St, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Barbecue restaurant

If barbecue is your culinary Achilles heel, there is no better place to satiate your cravings than at Derrick Jr's BBQ. This hidden gem, tucked away in Sandusky, has been winning hearts with its slow-cooked meats and unique offerings.

The star of the show without a doubt, are the fresh, hot, and delicious brisket, ribs, and pulled pork that are so perfectly seasoned and sauced. The waiting time might stretch up to around 25 minutes, especially during peak hours, but every second is worth the wait. The barbecue feast here is complemented by creamy mac and cheese and custom seasoned nachos with cheese, which further elevate the eating experience.

Kid-friendly cornbread served as cupcakes is an added bonus, offering a delightful twist to the traditional barbecue meal.

The pulled pork mac & cheese is another crowd pleaser, much noted for its tender and flavorsome characteristics. Derrick Jr's BBQ doesn't shy away from experimenting, and once upon a time, fried chicken, hibachi, and yum yum chicken sandwiches were part of the menu, leaving customers in anticipation of what could be served next.

A Culinary Voyage at DeMore's Offshore Bar & Grill

DeMore’s Offshore Bar & Grill · 302 W Perkins Ave, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Bar & grill

With an ambiance that echoes a sailor's hideout, DeMore's Offshore Bar & Grill is an inviting casual, wood-paneled eatery that brings together the flavors of land and sea. Located right in the heart of the city, DeMore's is known for its delectable array of dishes including steak, burgers, and seafood. To complement your dining experience, the restaurant also houses a self-serve beer wall, adding to the uniqueness of this establishment. One can learn more about their offerings on their Facebook page.

For those who fancy a juicy, well-flavored burger, a visit to DeMore's must include savoring their stuffed burgers, a dish that has garnered a fair share of admirers. The seafood offerings, however, seem to have gotten mixed reviews. While some patrons found the fish tacos a bit on the dry side, others couldn't stop raving about the perfection of the beer batter walleye and the seasoned shrimp, dubbing it the best they ever had.

The menu at DeMore's isn't just confined to the savory. Their mac and cheese, adored by many, is a dish that deserves special mention. For a dash of festive cheer, their seasonal pumpkin pie martini comes highly recommended by those who have had the pleasure to try it.

The pricing at DeMore's is on par with similar style restaurants, making it a worthy consideration for those planning a casual dining outing.

While DeMore's Offshore Bar & Grill may not be a unanimous choice for repeat visits, its unique offerings and laid-back ambiance certainly make it a place food lovers should consider exploring.

A Toast to Taste at Crush Wine Bar

Crush Wine Bar · 145 Columbus Ave, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Amid the hustle and bustle of Sandusky, a culinary treasure awaits the discerning palate. Enter Crush Wine Bar, an establishment that stands out as an epicurean dream, offering an ultimate gastronomic experience that seamlessly marries fine wine with exquisite cuisine. The stylish haunt is a treasure trove offering an eclectic range of wines both by the glass and bottle. But that's not all, alongside the stellar wine list, Crush Wine Bar also boasts an eclectic menu of small plates and entrees, creating a unique dining experience that is both sophisticated and intimate.

A visit to the Crush Wine Bar (sanduskywinebar.com) is like a delightful journey for wine lovers. The impressive selection, widely acclaimed as the most amazing in Sandusky, is managed by a knowledgeable and accommodating staff. This team's expertise not only enhances the overall experience but has also made this venue a beloved choice for locals and visitors alike for more than a decade.

But let's not forget the food. The culinary experience at Crush is just as delightful as its wines. Patrons rave about the cocktails and oysters, and the sushi is a particular favorite. However, those with a penchant for hearty dishes won't be disappointed either. The chicken Alfredo, though pesto-heavy, and the Ribeye steak, cooked to perfection without being over seasoned, are standouts.

One of the highlights of the menu, however, is the duck wings, a dish that has garnered phenomenal reviews from patrons. This, along with other delectable offerings like the Thai cucumber salad and pizza, makes every dish at Crush Wine Bar a culinary adventure.

Adding to the allure is the wonderful ambiance, particularly when sitting outside along the building. The great service further rounds off this exceptional dining experience. It's no wonder that those who visit are already planning their return.

Savoring Delights at Shore House Tavern

Shore House Tavern · 306 W Water St, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Bar

The city abounds with culinary wonders, but Shore House Tavern stands as a noteworthy gem in its rich dining landscape. A visit to this splendid eatery, nestled at shorehousetavern.com, is a must for any food enthusiast who finds themselves in town.

Patrons rave about the food, which continually surpasses expectations with every visit. The breakfast flatbread and burger are a delight, but the most talked-about offering is the chicken and waffles. An American classic, this dish is taken to new heights at Shore House Tavern - it's not just good, it's remarkable. The quality and taste justify the slightly higher price tag compared to other lunch spots in the city.

Shore House Tavern is also known for its unique and flavorful specials. The lobster roll, for instance, is an astounding delight that keeps the diners coming back for more. But the standout is their homemade coconut lime vinaigrette. This tangy, tropical dressing is so beloved it has customers begging for it to be bottled and sold.

Soak in the Scenery at Al Fresco Waterfront Dining on the Bay

Al Fresco Waterfront Dining on the Bay · 701 E Water St, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Restaurant

An epicurean journey is incomplete without a stop at the Al Fresco Waterfront Dining on the Bay. Nestled along the picturesque waterside of Sandusky, this dining haven stands out as a crowd-favorite, offering an immersive al fresco dining experience that sets the senses alight.

Having earned a stellar reputation for its exquisite menu and top-notch service, the restaurant is a culinary hotspot that draws in patrons from far and wide. Whether you arrive by car, boat, bike, or on foot, the gastronomic delights offered at Al Fresco Waterfront Dining are undeniably worth the trip.

The dining venue exudes an invigorating ambiance, thanks to its breathtaking view of the water and boats. But what truly sets this place apart is the personalized attention from the staff. The owner and chef, Benny Vito, is known to step out of the kitchen and engage with guests, adding a touch of warmth to the overall dining experience.

The restaurant's menu features a range of delectable choices, from fresh salads, appetizing starters, to hearty burgers and sandwiches. The lobster rolls have already become a crowd favorite, drawing in seafood enthusiasts from across the region. However, the culinary adventure doesn't stop at lobster rolls. The restaurant also offers an impressive selection of dinners and sides to satiate the palate of every patron.

Chef Benny's humor is as delectable as the food, making the dining experience all the more delightful. In addition to the food, guests can enjoy live entertainment on certain nights and afternoons, adding to the overall charm of the place.

Deliciously Traditional at Cameo Pizza

Cameo Pizza · 702 W Monroe St, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Pizza restaurant

In an era where food franchises dominate, it is a rarity to stumble upon places like Cameo Pizza. This long-standing local pizzeria chain, located in a cozy corner of the city, still serves up thin-crust pies and mouth-watering sandwiches in a casual atmosphere, reminiscent of its humble beginnings.

Travelers visiting this city find Cameo Pizza a must-visit spot, entrusting their culinary experience to this local business. Not only do they serve pizza, but their menu is a smorgasbord of delectable delights, guaranteed to satisfy diverse palates. The cheezy bread, for instance, is a crowd-pleaser, with its rich, melt-in-your-mouth goodness. But the real star has to be the pizza. The BBQ chicken pizza, known as the chicken delicacy, has been described as one of the best, while the taco pizza also receives rave reviews for its unique twist.

The excellence does not just end with pizza, the meatball sub deserves an honorable mention. The deliciously soft bread is the standout in this dish, making it one of the most popular choices. For those with a sweet tooth, the cinnamon bread, likened to fried dough, is an absolute delight.

A Unique Dining Experience at Sandusky Orioles Club

Sandusky Orioles Club · 1235 W Perkins Ave, Sandusky, OH 44870
★★★★★ · Bar & grill

Nestled in the heart of Sandusky, Ohio, the Sandusky Orioles Club offers a unique and delightful dining experience that is reserved to its members. Visit Sandusky Orioles Club for a taste of culinary excellence, coupled with a warm and lively atmosphere.

The moment one steps into the club, they are welcomed with friendly smiles of the patrons and a team of top-notch staff hustling to ensure every customer's need is promptly met. Despite being a private club, non-members are welcomed as guests, offering a perfect opportunity to experience the club's hospitality.

One of the club's main attractions is its remarkable menu. The calves liver, a particular favorite among many, is described as the absolute best. It is incredibly tender with a mild taste, reflecting its freshness. Equally impressive are the walleye bites, juicy, moist and crispy on the outside. The club ensures to serve these delights in oil that is extremely clean, resulting in a light and golden appearance.

Sandusky Orioles Club also offers a prime rib dinner that is described as being 'off the charts'. Served with potatoes and green beans with bacon bits, it is a must-try for any meat lover. Despite the high-quality food and service, the prices are surprisingly low.

At Sandusky Orioles Club, the ambiance is as splendid as the food. The atmosphere is teeming with happiness and pleasant conversations making it a great place to enjoy a meal and socialize. The only drawback, as some might see it, is that it's a private club. But the membership, as many affirm, returns two-fold, making it worthwhile.

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.