12 Incredible Restaurants in Lancaster PA, You Need to Try

Lancaster PA pizza restaurant

Embodying the vibrant soul of Pennsylvania, Lancaster offers a veritable banquet of culinary delights that cater to diverse palates and preferences.

From rustic farm-to-table establishments to ethnic cuisine hotspots, Lancaster is a treasure trove of gastronomic gems waiting to be discovered. Let's embark on this delectable journey.

We extend our heartfelt gratitude to the following individuals for their invaluable contributions to this article: David Howard, Aurora Lane, Gus Massengale, Elaine Estrada, Harry Huss, Julian McSwain and Lawrence Fowler.

Callaloo Trinidadian Kitchen: A Caribbean Oasis

Callaloo · 351 N Mulberry St, Lancaster, PA 17603
★★★★★ · Caribbean restaurant

Providing a taste of the Caribbean right in the heart of Lancaster, Callaloo Trinidadian Kitchen serves up authentic Trinidadian comfort food. The restaurant's ambiance is akin to a tropical retreat, with a cozy, intimate interior dotted with green plants.

The menu offers an exhilarating blend of flavors, with dishes like char siu pork belly and chili lamb noodles showcasing the chef's inventive culinary flair.

The restaurant's popularity necessitates calling ahead during peak dinner hours, but the culinary rewards are well worth the effort.

Route 66 Restaurant: A Nostalgic American Diner

Route 66 Restaurant - Lancaster PA · 45 W Liberty St #2700, Lancaster, PA 17603
★★★★★ · Hamburger restaurant

Route 66 Restaurant transports patrons back to the 1950s, offering a classic American diner experience. This old-fashioned joint serves up divine burgers and freshly cut fries, with a unique seasoning that sets it apart.

Its vintage ambiance, combined with the comforting lure of American comfort food, makes Route 66 a favorite among locals.

Sukhothai: A Thai Culinary Delight

Sukhothai · 398 Harrisburg Ave #450, Lancaster, PA 17603
★★★★★ · Thai restaurant

Sukhothai offers an authentic Thai dining experience in a relaxed, contemporary setting. From the incredible service to the remarkable steak salad and crab fried rice, this restaurant delivers on all fronts.

The slightly higher price point is justified by the quality of food and the overall dining experience, making Sukhothai a firm favorite for Thai food enthusiasts.

Mountville Family Restaurant: A Cozy Diner

Mountville Family Restaurant · 350 Highland Dr #150, Mountville, PA 17554
★★★★★ · Restaurant

The Mountville Family Restaurant is a hidden gem known for its breakfast and lunch offerings.

Its scrambled breakfast and creamed chipped beef are crowd favorites, but it's the warm, welcoming atmosphere that keeps patrons coming back. The restaurant embodies the spirit of a small-town diner, making it an indispensable part of Lancaster's culinary scene.

International Restaurant: A Global Gastronomic Adventure

International restaurant · 356 S Prince St, Lancaster, PA 17603
★★★★★ · Latin American restaurant

International Restaurant offers an expansive menu in a down-to-earth setting. The owner, Cruise, ensures a warm and welcoming environment, while the food, particularly the seafood soup and rice, meat, and beans combo, is satisfyingly hearty.

Boasting value for money and a menu to cater to all palates, this restaurant embodies the essence of home away from home.

John J Jeffries Restaurant: An Upscale Dining Experience

John J Jeffries Restaurant · 300 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603
★★★★★ · Fine dining restaurant

John J Jeffries Restaurant represents the epitome of elegance and sophistication in Lancaster's dining scene. With an ever-changing menu of farm-to-table, seasonal dishes, this restaurant offers a culinary experience that is as pleasing to the eye as it is to the palate.

Whether you're there for a date night or a special occasion, the ambiance, the food, and the top-notch service make every visit memorable.

Rice & Noodles Restaurant: A Vietnamese Haven

Rice & Noodles Restaurant · 1238 Lititz Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601
★★★★★ · Vietnamese restaurant

Rice & Noodles Restaurant is a bright and airy space that specializes in Vietnamese cuisine.

The Spicy Beef and Pork Pho, alongside Shrimp and Chicken Fresh Rolls, provide a hearty meal, while the macarons offer a decadent end to your meal. This restaurant is a gem for those in search of an authentic Vietnamese culinary experience.

The Belvedere Inn: A Blend of Music, Ambiance, and Food

The Belvedere Inn · 402 N Queen St, Lancaster, PA 17603
★★★★★ · American restaurant

The Belvedere Inn is a unique blend of music, ambiance, and food. This Victorian space offers a jazz-infused dining experience that transports you to a different era. The Mushroom Arancini and the Espresso Martini are truly remarkable. Despite its imperfections, The Belvedere Inn holds a special place in the heart of Lancaster's dining scene.

Gran Sabor Latino: A Caribbean Flavor Fest

Gran Sabor Latino · 120 N Franklin St, Lancaster, PA 17602
★★★★★ · Dominican restaurant

Gran Sabor Latino brings the vibrant flavors of the Caribbean to Lancaster. Despite some dishes falling short, the fish, grilled onions, and peppers stand out for their rich flavors. The restaurant's vibrant colors and rich aromas make it a must-visit for those craving a taste of the Caribbean.

Gibraltar Restaurant: A Mediterranean Retreat

Gibraltar Restaurant · 488 Royer Dr #101, Lancaster, PA 17601
★★★★★ · Seafood restaurant

Gibraltar Restaurant is Lancaster's crown jewel, offering a taste of the Mediterranean in an upscale setting.

The restaurant's staff ensures an unparalleled dining experience, and the food, from the duck fat fries to the seafood, is exceptional. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or looking for a relaxing dining experience, Gibraltar Restaurant promises to leave you yearning for more.

Plaza Azteca Mexican Restaurant: A Mexican Fiesta

Plaza Azteca Mexican Restaurant · Lancaster · 1700 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601
★★★★★ · Mexican restaurant

Plaza Azteca Mexican Restaurant is the go-to spot for hearty Mexican meals in Lancaster. The casual ambiance, combined with a broad menu of classic Mexican dishes, makes for an enjoyable dining experience.

From the tableside guacamole preparation to the ample portions, the Plaza Azteca offers a satisfying Mexican food journey.

Sa LaThai: An Exotic Thai Sojourn

Sa La Thai restaurant · 339 N Queen St, Lancaster, PA 17603
★★★★★ · Thai restaurant

Sa La Thai is an oasis of authentic Thai cuisine in Lancaster. The aromatic charm of the place captures you the moment you step in.

The curry dishes are as flavorful as they look, and the spice levels cater to a variety of preferences. The friendly and attentive staff, along with the vibrant flavors and warm ambiance, make Sa La Thai a culinary jewel in Lancaster.

The Pantry Restaurant: A Breakfast Haven

The Pantry Restaurant · 2715 Marietta Ave, Lancaster, PA 17601
★★★★★ · Breakfast restaurant

Weekend mornings in Lancaster are made even more delightful with a visit to The Pantry Restaurant.

Known for its signature skillet breakfast and French toast sampler, The Pantry offers a delectable start to the day in a quaint setting. The warm aroma of coffee and the sound of sizzling skillets add to the charm of this local favorite.

A Celebration of Lancaster's Culinary Diversity

In conclusion, the restaurant scene in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, offers a culinary kaleidoscope of flavors. From the Caribbean vibes of Callaloo Trinidadian Kitchen to the authentic Thai cuisine at Sukhothai, the gastronomic landscape is as diverse as it is delicious.

Whether you're in the mood for homey comfort at Mountville Family Restaurant, a sophisticated dining experience at John J Jeffries Restaurant, or a Mexican fiesta at Plaza Azteca, Lancaster's dining scene caters to every palate.

Each restaurant offers a unique showcase of the city's vibrant culture and heritage, making Lancaster a must-visit destination for food lovers.

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.