16 Incredible Restaurants in Fort Myers Beach, FL You Need to Try

16 Incredible Restaurants in Fort Myers Beach, FL You Need to Try

This coastal town is a food lover's paradise, from cozy beach shacks to upscale dining.

Let's embark on this flavorful exploration of some of the best restaurants in Fort Myers Beach, Florida.

We extend our heartfelt gratitude to the following individuals for their invaluable contributions to this article: Katalina Winters, Shannon Swart, Felix Davis, Gary Sullivan, Bella Black, David Brennan and Clarence Stoughton.

Mom's Restaurant

Every morning, the scents of freshly baked goods and hearty breakfast meals waft out of Mom's Restaurant, calling me to start my day right.

This humble place, with its austere environs, makes me feel at home.

The outdoor seating is perfect for those serene Florida mornings, allowing me to soak up the sun while indulging in the best biscuits, gravy, and cinnamon rolls I've ever had.

It's not just the food that makes Mom's Restaurant stand out.

There's nothing like being greeted with a warm smile and excellent service to make your day brighter.

Another favorite of mine and others at Mom's Restaurant is their Cuban sandwich.

Many people claim it to be the best they've ever had.

This place is a hidden gem in Fort Myers, a culinary haven I can't recommend enough.

I tell you, their breakfast sandwiches are to die for!

So, if you're in town and looking for an outstanding breakfast/lunch stop, Mom's Restaurant should be your choice.

Mom’s Restaurant · 2450 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Breakfast restaurant

Wahoo Willie's

You know those places that make you feel like you're on vacation even though you're just a few miles from home?

That's how I feel about Wahoo Willie's.

It's a cozy open-air restaurant, just a hop, skip, and jump from Ft. Myers Beach.

I remember the time I went there with my mom.

We shared their Margherita Flatbread while sipping on a cold beer.

The flatbread was tasty beyond words, and the beer was as refreshing as a Florida spring.

I was caught off guard by their reasonable pricing - going easy on my wallet without compromising the quality or taste.

And then there's the ambiance!

It's like a colossal tiki hut with a beautiful open-air dining space.

The Florida sun shining brightly, the cool breeze wafting in, and the smell of the ocean are part of the Wahoo Willie's experience.

It's truly a treat for all your senses.

There's live music every day to add charm to this tropical paradise.

Imagine savoring your favorite dish while listening to the pleasing rhythm of the guitar.

One of my favorite things about Wahoo Willie's is their appetizers.

They have an array of delicious options, but the blackened mahi-mahi bites and the black and blue tenderloin bites are not to be missed.

If you want a sweet ending to your meal, try their mango tango drink.

I guarantee you'll be asking for more.

Every time I visit Wahoo Willie's, it's like a mini-vacation.

It's the perfect place to enjoy good food and drinks, excellent service, and beautiful Florida weather.

I can't wait to go back and make more memories.

Wahoo Willie’s · 645 Old San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Bar & grill

Casablanca Cafe

I often find myself drawn to the warm, inviting atmosphere of Casablanca Café, a local gem tucked away at the picturesque Lanikai Island Resort.

The allure of this place is irresistible, and it’s always a delight to savor its delicious offerings.

Just stepping inside this café feels like stepping into an oasis.

Every sip tasted like it was made with love and care, a testament to the café’s commitment to customer satisfaction.

But it isn’t just the drinks that have won me over.

If you ever find yourself here, I cannot recommend the lamb gyro enough.

It's the best one I've ever tasted - a bold statement, but one that I fully stand by.

The juicy lamb, the fresh veggies, and the tangy tzatziki are an explosion of flavors that will have you returning for more.

Casablanca Café has quirks, but they make it such a charming spot in our local community.

It holds a particular spot in my heart, and I’m confident it will for you too.

Casablanca Café · 1400 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Cōste Island Cuisine

When it comes to dining, nothing captures the essence of island life quite like Cōste Island Cuisine.

Nestled on the beachfront with a stunning view of Fort Myers Beach, this stylish and sleek eatery is more than just a restaurant - a culinary experience that shouldn't be missed.

Picture yourself gazing out at the azure Gulf of Mexico while sipping on an artfully crafted cocktail and relishing the freshest seafood - it's a local paradise.

From the outset, Cōste sets the bar high.

The ambiance is perfect, reflecting the natural beauty that surrounds it.

But the real star here is the food.

Each dish is a revelation of flavors, from the fresh oysters that make you crave another serving to the spicy jam that perfectly partners with their homemade bread.

If you're a dessert lover, their decadent ice cream dessert is a treat for the eyes and taste buds.

One of my favorites is the blackened grouper Rueben, a dish that packs a punch with unique and delicious flavors.

It's the kind of dish that makes you want to return repeatedly.

Cōste Island Cuisine is not just about great food, though.

Every time I dine at Cōste Island Cuisine, it reminds me of why I love living here - the breathtaking views, the freshest seafood, and the warm hospitality.

It captures the charm of island life perfectly.

If you haven't dined here yet, you're missing out on one of the best culinary experiences on the island.

Cōste Island Cusine · 2000 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Petey's Upper Deck Bar

You know you've found a gem when even the locals can't get enough of it.

Petey's Upper Deck Bar is my go-to spot for laid-back evenings and delicious food.

The live music is vibrant, albeit a bit loud, but it makes the atmosphere lively and engaging.

While the crowd is generally older, don't let that fool you into thinking this place isn't fun.

With games set up outside, I've had many enjoyable evenings sipping drinks and engaging in friendly competitions.

Their food selection, though, is what keeps me coming back.

I've indulged in their pizza, wings, and fries more times than I can count, and I've never been disappointed.

The service is always friendly, and with a view as beautiful as theirs, every dining experience feels straight out of a postcard.

If you're coming by boat, docking is available, and there's plenty of parking for those driving in.

They operate daily from 11:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m., giving ample time to soak in the ambiance and enjoy their delightful menu.

So, if you're in the area, don't miss out on Petey's Upper Deck Bar.

It's a local treasure worth experiencing!

Petey’s Upper Deck Bar · 416 Crescent St, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Bar

Snug Harbor Waterfront Restaurant

Just when you think you've tasted all the best seafood Fort Myers Beach has to offer, you discover Snug Harbor Waterfront Restaurant!

This spot has become my go-to for fresh seafood dishes; their dishes are always brimming with newly-caught treasures from the Gulf.

Once in a while, I’ll find a dish that could use a little more seasoning, like the mashed potatoes, but overall, the food excites my taste buds.

The service is always impeccable, which makes the experience even more enjoyable.

Not to mention the lovely views of the waterfront as I dine. It's an atmosphere unlike any other.

I remember seeing the Christmas boat parade from Snug Harbor a few years ago.

It was a weekend of live music, good food, and great company.

The outdoor seating enhances the experience, but if you prefer a covered area, they have a well-stocked bar too.

As a small restaurant, the menu might not be extensive, but rest assured. They have perfectly curated their offerings to guarantee exceptional dishes.

On my lighter eating days, I adore their salads.

And my husband swears by their sea scallops.

They are even dog-friendly, so our pets are never left out!

So, if you're strolling down the streets of Fort Meyers Beach, looking for a delightful dining experience, stop by Snug Harbor.

It’s a place that truly embodies the beach town's spirit, and it’s always worth the visit.

Snug Harbor Waterfront Restaurant · 645 Old San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Seafood restaurant

Dixie Fish Company

After a long week, there's nothing like unwinding at my favorite local spot, Dixie Fish Company.

This down-to-earth hangout stuns with its delectable seafood, lively music, and a breezy patio overlooking the gulf.

It's a hidden gem where you can experience the authentic flavor of the coast right on your plate.

The drinks are refreshing, perfect to quench your thirst on a warm day.

Here, the food is not just served; it's presented like a delicious ode to the sea.

Remember to ask for the off-menu Yucatán Shrimp, a recipe borrowed from the currently closed Doc Ford's.

One of my personal favorites is their whole fried fish.

I've had it twice, and it was cooked to absolute perfection.

For something different, you have to try their Moonshine Mussels.

As someone who cooks at home, I can tell you this dish is culinary perfection, despite my usual aversion to fennel.

It's one of the best things I have ever tasted.

Also, don't miss the grouper cheeks, fried until golden and irresistible.

If you're not a seafood fan, don't fret, Dixie Fish Company has more to offer.

They serve drool-worthy Mahi, key lime pie, homemade chips, roast potatoes, and wings.

I have been so obsessed with their cuisine that I have been there two days in a row just to try more of their dishes.

Complementing the food and drinks is the relaxed and friendly atmosphere.

The servers, like Michelle and Josie, are super-friendly, ensuring you are well taken care of.

Try their fried green tomato appetizer on Josie's recommendation; it's a tasty treat.

Dixie Fish Company is not just a restaurant; it's an experience that celebrates coastal cuisine in a fun, friendly setting.

It encapsulates the essence of a perfect day by the water, with great food and stunning views.

So, if you're in town and looking for an enjoyable dinner, this is the place for you.

Dixie Fish Company · 714 Fishermans Wharf, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Seafood restaurant

Matanzas on the Bay

Let me take you on a culinary journey to my slice of paradise, where the water sparkles, the live music plays, and the aroma of perfectly cooked seafood wafts through the air - Matanzas on the Bay.

Nestled on the serene shores of Matanzas Bayside Inn, this casual eatery has become my go-to spot for a perfect blend of atmosphere and delectable dishes.

What makes Matanzas on the Bay unique is its waterfront patio, boasting an unobstructed view of the bay, and its extensive menu of pizzas and seafood.

The first time I ordered their coconut shrimp and sipped on their banana daiquiris, I knew I had found a gem.

And don't get me started on their surf n turf, filet, and lobster – it's the stuff of dreams!

But that's not all.

On numerous visits, I've taken delight in their Seafood Chimichanga, accompanied by garlic-smashed potatoes, a Matanzas's signature dish that never disappoints.

And when I'm in the mood for something a bit more Italian, their large Margherita pizza is my first pick - the crust is crispy, the cheese is melty, and the tomatoes are always fresh.

They warmly welcome boaters by offering dockage, and if you're lucky, you might spot a friendly manatee as you dine on the upper deck.

So, join us at Matanzas on the Bay – where food meets serenity.

Let’s share a meal, a moment, and support our local businesses as they bounce back from adversity.

Matanzas on the Bay · 416 Crescent St, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Seafood restaurant

Doc Ford's Rum Bar & Grille

It's no secret that the best seafood in town can be found at Doc Ford's Rum Bar & Grille on Ft. Myers Beach, a casual dining haven that brilliantly combines Caribbean and South American flavors.

As a regular patron, I've had the pleasure of delving into their well-balanced menu numerous times, and I can confidently say their seafood dishes are a gastronomic revelation.

The seared tuna appetizer is a fantastic way to whet your appetite, and their Cuban sandwich is a must-try.

And for those who aren't big on seafood, their coffee-rubbed pork loin is a delectable choice that never fails to impress.

Not every day you find a seafood restaurant that caters so well to non-seafood customers.

The ambiance at Doc Ford's is another reason I keep returning.

If you're planning a family dinner, their redfish bowl is a crowd-pleaser, and their dessert selection is phenomenal.

Their key lime pie, in particular, is so exquisite it's practically become a legend around here.

Moreover, Doc Ford's offers an assortment of hot sauces to spice up your meal.

And the best part? You can purchase these hot sauces at the front before you leave!

This is a treat for anyone looking to recreate Doc Ford's experience at home.

So, if you're in Ft. Myers Beach and looking for a place to enjoy great food, drinks, and live entertainment, Doc Ford's Rum Bar & Grille should be at the top of your list.

Doc Ford’s Rum Bar & Grille - Ft. Myers Beach · 708 Fishermans Wharf, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Seafood restaurant

MoJoe's Coffee Cafe

One doesn't simply walk past MoJoe's Coffee Cafe without being lured in by the tempting aroma of freshly brewed espresso.

As I weave through the crowd to get my daily fix of coffee, I am greeted by friendly faces and the comforting hum of conversations.

The baristas behind the counter have a knack for making each cup of coffee feel like a crafted work of art, never skimping on the rich, bold espresso that's the soul of my favorite drink.

Aside from their delicious coffee offerings, MoJoe's is also the place for a hearty breakfast.

Their cafe menu is breakfast-centric, and they have a knack for presenting their delicious food.

What's a morning without some delicious pancakes with my cup of Java?

What truly sets MoJoe's apart is its charming, tree-shaded patio - a little oasis in the heart of town.

It's where I love to sit back and observe life as it goes by, a coffee cup in hand.

And the best part is the cute and friendly cats lounging around, freely adding a touch of whimsy to the setting.

It feels like visiting a cat cafe without having to pay extra.

There's a certain charm about MoJoe's Coffee Cafe that's kept me coming back over the years.

From the fantastic food to the perfectly brewed coffee and the friendly felines, you get to pet.

MoJoe’s Coffee Cafe · 1740 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Coffee shop


It's hard to beat an evening at Flippers on the Bay.

This casual yet delightful open-air hub has become my regular hangout spot.

After a long day, looking out over the picturesque bay view while sipping on a glass of wine or an expertly mixed cocktail is the relaxation one needs.

Each visit to Flippers is a culinary adventure, thanks to the international-inspired menu.

My favorites are the coconut shrimp, tortilla soup, and lobster mac & cheese.

The appetizers are just the right size, leaving enough room for the moreish main courses.

And the rum buckets made with Wicked Dolphin? It's a must-have for every visit!

Something about the moving misted air from the fans and the open-air dining makes me feel like I'm on a tropical vacation.

And on special occasions, they go all out.

For instance, on Mother’s Day, the chef went around giving out long-stem roses - these little touches make Flippers on the Bay more than just a restaurant.

I cannot recommend this place highly enough!

Flippers · 8767 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Lighthouse Tiki Bar & Grill

Not every day do you stumble upon a tropical oasis like our hometown's Lighthouse Tiki Bar & Grill.

It's the kind of place where every evening feels like a mini-vacation.

Imagine a lively Polynesian-themed spot where you can feast on pub grub, sip fruity cocktails, and be entertained by energetic live performances all under one roof!

My go-to for a casual catch-up with friends or just to unwind is the Lighthouse Tiki Bar & Grill.

The karaoke nights are legendary around here, not just for the fantastic singers but also for those like me who just love to have a go, regardless of the pitchy notes and misread lyrics.

They pack the place out every time, and the atmosphere is electric.

The fun doesn't stop at karaoke; the food and drink are worth raving about.

I tried their cheeseburger once, and let me tell you, those fries were perfectly cooked and simply delectable.

And you must try the bucket Margherita - it's the best I've had at any restaurant or bar in years.

I can't stress enough: skip the glass and go straight for the bucket!

There's something about an outdoor lounge under the resort that makes you forget about the hot and muggy days.

And yes, if you're wondering, it's family-friendly!

Kids are more than welcome in the lounge area and the pool.

So, there you have it - my little slice of tropical paradise in our town.

It's time you experienced the magic of the Lighthouse Tiki Bar & Grill!

Lighthouse Tiki Bar & Grill · 1051 Fifth St, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Bar & grill

Eats at the Beach

You know, there's something magical about island life.

The freedom, the vibes, and the endless party are all a little intoxicating.

But what makes it even more intoxicating is the island's jewel - Eats at the Beach.

This place is no ordinary beach shack.

It's like the island's lifeblood, throbbing with energy day and night, filling me with hope and leaving me with a full belly.

And the music is a constant, pumping heartbeat that keeps the party going.

But it's not just about the party.

Eats at the Beach also serves a fantastic menu.

There's a variety to choose from - paninis, salads, burgers. You name it.

And let's not forget the water sports.

Yes, you read that right.

Apart from satiating your hunger, they also offer all-day jet skis.

Now, isn't that something?

The beach itself is a sight to behold.

Pristine and inviting, it's the perfect place to lay back and soak up some sun.

If you're around, do drop by.

Who knows, we might just cross paths!

Eats at the Beach · 61 Avenue C, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Bonita Bills Waterfront Cafe

Sunsets, seafood, and soulful music - that's what my regular visits to Bonita Bills Waterfront Cafe are made of.

It's my go-to place whenever I seek some peace and comfort.

Its soothing live music always sets the right tone for my time there.

The food at Bonita Bills makes you feel right at home, even though you're dining out.

One of my personal favorites is their biscuits and gravy.

Those fluffy biscuits drenched in rich and flavorful gravy are delectable.

To add to the goodness, their hashbrowns are a must-try as well.

And if you love seafood, you're in for a treat.

The shrimp here is succulent and utterly satisfying.

I always make sure to start my day with their breakfast.

They've got a range of breakfast options, and I often add an egg to my order.

After all, what's breakfast without some protein, right?

And let's not forget their mimosas!

They're so good they'll make you want to return for more.

As for the place itself, it's an informal, open-air space where you order your food and drinks at the bar, and they're delivered to your table.

And while it might seem a bit unorthodox to some, I find it adds to the place's charm.

Bonita Bills Waterfront Cafe is an experience that's always been worth every penny.

So, if you're looking for a place with great food, reasonable prices, and a pleasant atmosphere, Bonita Bills is the place to be.

After all, who wouldn't enjoy a day filled with delicious food, terrific drinks, live music, and stunning water vistas?

Bonita Bills Waterfront Cafe · 702 Fishermans Wharf, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Seafood restaurant

Fresh Catch Bistro

Escaping the ordinary is always a pleasure, and Fresh Catch Bistro is the right place to do that.

Take a casual evening stroll along the beach, and there it was, the all-new Fresh Catch Bistro, adorning a swanky bar and a deck overlooking the magnificent Gulf.

The new location lets you breathe in more salty air, making your seafood dining experience even more refreshing.

The charred octopus was the star of the evening - a delicacy prepared to perfection!

Moreover, the breathtaking views from the Bistro are worth every penny.

The beautiful waters of the Gulf, combined with the inviting ambiance of the restaurant, elevate an ordinary dinner to a memorable evening.

Although a little different from the old location, the new Fresh Catch Bistro still brings the same charm and delight.

The ambiance, the service, and the location are enough to keep me coming back.

After all, we locals know; the best seafood is always by the sea!

Fresh Catch Bistro · 4761 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★★ · Seafood restaurant

Bayside Grille

When the hustle and bustle of the day in Ft Myers gets the better of me, I escape to my local haven, the Bayside Grille.

This laid-back place captivates the heart with its warm ambiance and flat-screen TVs, perfect for catching a game.

But let's not forget the charm of outdoor seating, a rare luxury in our urban sprawl.

The food is also something to write home about!

For instance, my little cousin, a notoriously picky eater, was smitten by the diverse offerings.

Let's talk about the location.

It's conveniently near where I live, with easy access, so I often find myself behind the wheel, heading towards Bayside Grille.

Need a fun fact? They've got a TV in their bathroom!

Yes, you heard that right!

And if you're ever there on a Taco Tuesday, let me tell you, the special is too good to pass up.

So, next time you're in town, whether for the Tuna Melt, the fries, or some good old-fashioned hospitality, make sure you drop by Bayside Grille.

Bayside Grille · 17853 San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States
★★★★☆ · American restaurant

Final Thoughts

Fort Myers Beach, Florida, offers a unique blend of culinary delights that cater to various tastes and preferences.

Each of these establishments has its unique charm and delectable menu that keeps locals like me and tourists coming back for more.

So the next time you're in Fort Myers Beach, check out these joints - you won't be disappointed!

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.