12 Incredible Restaurants in Buffalo, NY You Need to Try

Incredible Restaurants in Buffalo, NY You Need to Try

Embark on a delicious journey through the city known as 'The Queen of the Great Lakes' with our guide to 12 must-visit restaurants in Buffalo, NY.

This northern city boasts an impressive culinary scene that fuses traditional American flavors with international influences. From comforting classics to innovative gastronomic experiences, these curated restaurants cater to every flavor profile, promising an unforgettable culinary exploration.

Join us as we navigate the vibrant dining landscape of Buffalo, revealing hidden gem eateries and renowned establishments that solidify this city as a gastronome’s delight.

Let's dive into the diverse, sumptuous world that makes Buffalo, NY an irresistible sensation for food lovers everywhere.

We extend our heartfelt gratitude to the following individuals for their invaluable contributions to this article: Rhea Sanford, Thelma Nall, Jennifer Harris, Esteban Long, Cathy Chandler, Eula Norman and Jay Mahaffey.

A Southern Soiree at Toutant

Toutant radiates with Southern charm nestled in the heart of Buffalo. Their contemporary Southern cuisine and industrial-chic decor form an enchanting, cozy ambiance that is hard to resist.

Walking into Toutant, you're met with a warm, inviting setting, and an awe-inspiring bar. Their attention to detail extends to dietary nuances and restrictions—an endearing quality not often seen in many places.

Featured at the forefront of their culinary delights is the unforgettable, melt-in-your-mouth buttermilk fried chicken. Complemented with home-made biscuits and fruit preserves, it's indeed an experience for the senses. The Piccadilly Special Fried Chicken Bucket makes for a hearty shareable feast, with seafood lovers finding delight in their mild, house-made jambalaya.

And don’t forget the cornbread, quintessentially southern and delectably prepared. The satisfying food, the attentive waiting staff, and an amicable ambiance make Toutant an irresistible spot for any occasion.

Toutant · 437 Ellicott St, Buffalo, NY 14203
★★★★★ · Southern restaurant (US)

A Charming Night at The Left Bank

The Left Bank presents itself as a delightful blend of Italian elegance and global flavors packaged in a charming bistro setting. The bistro exudes an inviting energy, complemented by a welcoming ambiance, making it the perfect setting for a relaxed brunch or a romantic dinner.

The menu offers an exciting array of choices, featuring Italian classics fused with flavors from around the globe.

Despite a slightly slow kitchen, the attention to fresh, quality ingredients is apparent in each dish served. The attentive service, generous portion sizes, and customer-oriented approach make it more than just a dining venue.

I eagerly anticipate my next visit to The Left Bank and can highly recommend it for those who enjoy a cozy atmosphere paired with delightful food.

The Left Bank · 511 Rhode Island St, Buffalo, NY 14213
★★★★★ · Restaurant

In Vogue at Bacchus Wine Bar & Restaurant

Step into a tranquil culinary refuge at Bacchus Wine Bar & Restaurant. The ambiance is dominated by soft, candlelit romance, a contrast to the city's rush. Starting with a crisp, flavorful red wine from their extensive list, the complexities of taste paired beautifully with the tender rack of lamb.

The mussels are an unmissable seafood delight, praised for their wattling sauce that soaks into every bite. The restaurant’s professional servers, like Matt and Sean, show an impressive dedication to their work, making each visit seamless and enjoyable.

The open and peaceful setting of their courtyard is an excellent choice for quiet dinners, where dishes like their flavorful Pork Chop take center stage. So, when seeking an unforgettable dining experience, look no further than Bacchus Wine Bar & Restaurant.

Bacchus Wine Bar & Restaurant · 56 W Chippewa St, Buffalo, NY 14202
★★★★★ · Restaurant

An Evening to Remember at The Dapper Goose

One enchanting evening, I ended up exploring the unexpected inner-city charm of The Dapper Goose.

This urban oasis offered a fresh palate of flavors, memorable for its unique dining atmosphere. With its cleverly crafted cocktails and inviting outdoor seating, this place truly felt like a home away from home. Nudging my culinary curiosity, I found their small plate selection packed with surprising delights, such as the Korean fried chicken, and the halibut with clams.

Each bite expressed a testament to the thoughtfulness and creativity behind their menu. Their impressive wine list is expertly curated to accompany their menu, with their servers acting as helpful guides in navigating your choices. The evening reached its crescendo with the mouthwatering dessert - a slice of their olive oil cake, truly dessert decadence.

The Dapper Goose is a place that captivates you with every morsel, every sip, and endless joy. Do include it in your gastronomic journey through Buffalo.

The Dapper Goose · 491 Amherst St, Buffalo, NY 14207
★★★★★ · New American restaurant

An Enchanting Night at Mothers Restaurant

As the city lights mellow, there's one haunt that sets my heart aflutter - Mothers Restaurant. The ambience is beguiling, the romantic dim lighting creating the ideal mood and the innate, laid-back aura irresistibly captivating. The menu, available on their website, is a tantalizing tour de force of culinary options.

Upon my first visit, the handwritten menu seized my attention, a testament to the unrestrained creativity of the talented chefs. Indeed, securing a reservation on a busy weekend proved a rewarding challenge, as their tables are hotly contested.

On a serene, breezy evening, I found myself luxuriously ensconced in the outdoor patio, the air perfumed with a melange of delicious aromas and the gentle hum of convivial chatter. The service is nothing less than flawless. Prompt, courteous and with a keen understanding of the menu, the staff grace the overall dining experience.

Delving into the vibrant food offering is a delight unto itself. The Malbec wine was paradigm-shifting, bold and evocative to the palate. The ribeye steak cooked to perfection, each bite unfurling an explosion of flavors.

The pièce de résistance, however, was their Crème Brûlée, a heavenly indulgence that positively melted in my mouth, imprinting a delicious, lingering sweetness that overshadows any potential wait times.

In the ebb flow of crowd engagement, I had the opportunity to tantalize my palate with the Roasted Red Pepper Soup and the Stuffed Banana Peppers. Though the soup is subtle, the Crab Cakes astonish with a scrumptious sauce that is worth craving. There's an undeniable charm about Mothers Restaurant, it's a delightful testament to the joy of dining!

Mothers Restaurant · 33 Virginia Pl, Buffalo, NY 14202
★★★★★ · American restaurant

Discovering Buffalo's Best Kept Secret: Chef's Restaurant

Stepping into Chef's Restaurant transplants you to an era lifted straight from your favorite black-and-white movie, complete with the homely aroma of homemade tomato sauce, the merry clatter of dishes, and the nostalgic appeal of photos adorning the walls - creating a truly magical experience.

Being a Buffalo resident, I've been a frequent visitor to Chef's, with every visit serving as a delicious dive into the heart of Italian cuisine. The spaghetti parmigiana, served piping hot with a generous dusting of cheese, conjures memories of treasured family dinners.

Don't overlook the calamari rings! With their satisfying crunch, they are an inviting complement to your meal. The house Moscato wine, fresh and fruity, is an impeccable pairing with our meals. The staff go above and beyond in their service which is a testament to a cherished legacy of this beloved institution.

Chef’s Restaurant · 291 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY 14204
★★★★★ · Italian restaurant

Decadent Evenings at Coco Bar & Bistro

Spending an evening at Coco Bar & Bistro is akin to unearthing a hidden treasure ensconced within the heart of Buffalo. The place seamlessly combines the modern and homey, adorning its interior with inviting greenery and warm, brick walls.

Reserving a table at Coco Bar & Bistro is recommended, particularly during peak hours. The winter menu is truly a feast to behold, featuring mouthwatering dishes like succulent lamb bolognese and tantalizing BBQ shrimp.

They host special event nights, showcasing cuisine from across the globe, each meal cooked to perfection, presentation delightful, creating an engaging palette of taste and aesthetics.

Coco Bar & Bistro · 888 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14202
★★★★★ · Restaurant

A Touch of Italy at Osteria 166

Stumbling upon a restaurant where you can't help but rave about the salads is a rarity in itself. Osteria 166 is just such a place. From the buzzing energy to the lip-smacking salads, every moment here is delightful. If you're a bread lover, you'll adore their serving of fresh Italian bread.

The Carl, a beautiful confluence of Italian sausage, meatball, cheese, and onions, is a flavorsome adventure. Potent martinis and buzzing crowds make for a vivacious outing, truly embodying a slice of Italy right in the neighborhood.

Osteria 166 · 166 Franklin St, Buffalo, NY 14202
★★★★★ · Italian restaurant

A Memorable Night at CRaVing Restaurant

Walking into CRaVing Restaurant is akin to finding a whole new world, where warm, cozy lights, irresistible aromas, and an intimate ambiance make your evening unforgettable.

The start of the meal with mouthwatering appetizers sets the mood, followed by delectable entrées that tease the palate. The cocktails are crafted with precision by expert bartenders, enriching the dining experience.

The finale of dessert leaves an indelible mark. The sheer magic that is CRaVing Restaurant captures the joy of culinary exploration in ways you could scarcely forget.

CRaVing Restaurant · 1472 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
★★★★★ · American restaurant

When Cravings Call, Venture To Hutch's!

What a sheer delight to dine within the cherished halls of Hutch’s! This gem is tucked away in the heart of Buffalo and is my top choice for a memorable dining adventure. As I cross the threshold, the warm, relaxed ambiance of this exposed-brick restaurant instantly embraces me. On those balmy summer evenings, the patio becomes a haven of gastronomic indulgence.

A dive into the menu at Hutch's unearths fine American cuisine seasoned with global flavors. Each offering is more tantalizing than the last - succulent prime meatballs, perfectly cooked steak frites.

And oh, the sea scallops and halibut, they simply melt in your mouth with delight. An excursion to Hutch's is not complete without sampling the divine carrot cake and crème brûlée - the perfect sweet end to any delectable meal here.

The knowledgeable, friendly, and attentive staff create an atmosphere of exceptional service. They craft an exquisite dining experience that pulls you back time and time again. Hutch’s is not simply dining; it's a gastronomic journey filled with exceptional food, service, and unlimited memories!

Hutch’s · 1375 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14209
★★★★★ · Fine dining restaurant

A Night To Remember at Buffalo Chophouse

Welcome to the Buffalo Chophouse, a little jewel in the heart of Buffalo. As you stride through their doors, the plush velvet banquettes and exquisite dog paintings pull you into a space that’s charming, quirky, and elegant, all in a delightful harmony.

One of my cherished memories is celebrating my father’s 80th birthday here. The warmth, professionalism, and personal touch of the staff made the occasion even more special. The star of the evening? The steak! Each mouthful was a tender, juicy dream. To mark this splendid occasion, we were given a $50 discount on our bill and a delightful birthday cake.

Beyond the steak, other culinary jewels await your palate. The braised short ribs with mashed potatoes and carrots are an absolute delight. Their sundae is an indulgent finish to any meal. Worth every penny, their delicious servings make any food lover's heart content. What’s more, they have free valet parking, a service as rare as a perfectly cooked steak.

Buffalo Chophouse is more than just a restaurant; it’s an unforgettable dining experience that should be at the top of your eating-out list!

Buffalo Chophouse · 282 Franklin St, Buffalo, NY 14202
★★★★★ · Steak house

A Delectable Evening at Oliver's Restaurant

Searching for a memorable culinary journey? Look no further than Oliver's Restaurant. This town's jewel offers a dining experience like none other, transforming a simple meal into an unforgettable encounter.

At Oliver's, the spotlight shines brightly on the food – an exquisite adaptation of classic American fare with a playful, innovative twist. From the flawlessly executed steaks to the unique spinach loaf, each dish is a symphony of flavors waiting to tantalize your taste buds.

The Oliver's wine list offers a rich palette of choices; the unique cocktails, potent yet nuanced, are a delightful revelation with my personal favorite being the fuzu blossom cocktail.

The ambiance, sophisticated yet inviting, adds a layer of charm to the exceptional dining experience. Whether a special celebration or casual outing, every moment at Oliver’s is royal.

In conclusion, Oliver’s stands unmatched when it comes to delivering a memorable dining experience. From simple dinners to grand occasions, Oliver’s consistency in quality and service is a testament to its cherished place in the city’s culinary scene.

Oliver’s Restaurant · 2095 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
★★★★★ · Fine dining restaurant

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.