18 Best Restaurants in St. Peters, MO

Best Restaurants in St. Peters, MO

Trust me when I say St. Peters isn't just another city in the Show-Me State; it's a delightful gastronomic haven waiting to be explored.

So, let's start this savory journey together with this list of the best restaurants in St. Peters, Missouri.

How this article was written: Our team first analyzed the scores and feedback across major platforms like Google Maps, Yelp, and Trip Advisor, considering not only the ratings but also the consistency of positive feedback. Following this, we conducted interviews with over 30 local residents who have been to these restaurants to gather authentic, first-hand experiences. You can read more about our research process here.

While this list showcases some remarkable restaurants, it's important to note there are many other exceptional dining establishments in St. Peters, MO that are not featured here. Our aim is not just to guide you to popular eateries but to encourage you to venture out and experience the city's diverse culinary landscape for yourself.

Godfather's Pizza

Seriously, who can resist the allure of a perfectly cooked thick-crust pizza?

I've had my fair share of pizzas, but my heart belongs to Godfather's Pizza.

I can't help but daydream about their fully loaded meat lovers pizza; it's a carnivorous delight that never disappoints.

Godfather's Pizza doesn't just do a good pizza; they do amazing pizzas.

But here's a tip, though, ask them to keep it longer in the oven.

Trust me, a well-cooked meat lovers pizza is worth the wait.

I've had times when they took it out slightly early, and it wasn't as perfect as usual.

But don't let that deter you because when it's right, it's absolutely 100% the best pizza.

It's so good that I'm fighting the urge to order a pizza at 9:29 pm while writing this!

Another thing that keeps me going back is their great prices.

Where else can you get a large combo pizza just for $14.99?

And it doesn't taste like a cheap pizza.

It's a bargain for a pizza that tastes so heavenly.

It's not just the pizzas that make Godfather's Pizza special.

They also offer mouthwatering calzones, delicious sides, and heavenly desserts.

Each visit is a culinary journey with so many flavors to explore.

Godfather’s Pizza · 2875 St Peters Howell Rd, St Peters, MO 63376, United States
★★★★★ · Pizza restaurant

BeerBBQ Shop St. Peters

Crackling sounds of grilling and the tantalizing aroma of BBQ sauce.

That's what first strikes you when you step into the BeerBBQ Shop St. Peters.

A haven for craft brew enthusiasts and BBQ lovers alike, this place is a flavorful adventure that never fails to impress.

Back in the day, this place used to be known as BeerSauce, with a mind-boggling array of hot sauces on offer.

A lot has changed since then, though.

Now, it's more of an upscale liquor store, with a focus on craft brews and artisanal BBQ sauces, and dry rubs.

They've even introduced bar food like BBQ sandwiches which, I must say, are a delicious addition.

They also introduced an impressive variety of craft brews and an array of artisanal BBQ sauces and dry rubs.

They now carry whiskey too and even offer beer and whiskey flights, which is a nice touch.

BeerBBQ Shop St. Peters · 318 D, Mid Rivers Mall Dr, St Peters, MO 63376, United States
★★★★★ · Beer store

Noto Italian Restaurant

Ever stumbled upon a culinary haven so magnificent that it completely redefines your dining experiences?

That's Noto Italian Restaurant for me.

Just a casual visit to Noto Italian Restaurant to quell my pizza cravings turned into a love affair with the place, and now it's my go-to destination for all things Italian in St. Peters.

Nothing screams authentic Italian cuisine more than Noto!

Every single dish, be it pasta, pizza, or mouth-watering Italian-inspired appetizers, is served with such devotion to perfection that it transports you straight to the heart of Italy.

The Neapolitan-style pizza, certified authentic by Italy itself, is an absolute must-try!

But it's not just the food that sets Noto apart.

Their service is unmatchable!

They just elevate the dining experience to a whole new level.

And don't even get me started on the drinks.

From bourbon cocktails to wine, each is a delight in its own right.

The desserts are the cherry on top - simply to die for!

Noto Italian Restaurant · 5105 Westwood Dr, St Peters, MO 63304, United States
★★★★★ · Italian restaurant

Third Wheel Brewing

You know that feeling of stepping into a place and instantly feeling at ease?

That's what it's like every time I walk into Third Wheel Brewing.

Admittedly, my first visit was marred by a buffalo chicken wrap that didn't quite hit the mark and a service team that seemed a little disinterested.

But the beer - oh, the beer!

It was a decent enough initiation to Third Wheel Brewing.

Over time, I've come to appreciate the comfortable space of this taproom.

It's neither pretentious nor a dive, just a sweet spot where you can relax with a pint of artisanal beer.

The game nights and live music add to the friendly and laid-back atmosphere that I've grown to love.

It's somewhere you could easily lose track of time.

My personal favorite beers, the ones that keep me coming back, are Gotta Have It (formerly known as No Pun), Sandman, and Broken Arm Blonde.

They are proof of Third Wheel Brewing's capability to blend creativity with tradition.

They offer an impressive variety, catering to both adventurous beer enthusiasts and those who prefer the classic 'beer-flavored beers.'

Third Wheel Brewing · 4008 I-70 North Outer Rd, St Peters, MO 63376, United States
★★★★★ · Brewery

Heavy Smoke BBQ

Everyone talks about the charm of St. Louis—its beautiful arch, the bustling city vibe—but for a foodie like me, the real charm lies in the humble, smoke-scented quarters of Heavy Smoke BBQ.

You know you're in for a treat when the hardest decision is choosing between the Cuban and the Brisquet egg rolls.

I remember the first time I tried the Cuban sandwich; it was an orchestra of flavors.

I did feel it could use a bit more balance with the toppings and meat, but the meat itself was cooked to perfection, so tender it melted in my mouth.

However, the real star of the show is the Brisquet egg rolls.

Those little packages are bursting with flavor.

They are a testament to the fact that sometimes, simple things can create an extraordinary experience.

And let's not forget about the BBQ sauces.

They have five different ones, each unique and each more delicious than the last.

The best part?

They now provide bottles for the table, so you can slather your BBQ in as much sauce as you want.

And the place is always spotless, even during the Saturday lunch rush.

It's no wonder that the place is always full of happy customers, myself included, lost in the delicious world of BBQ and momentarily forgetting about their phones.

Heavy Smoke BBQ · 4270 N Service Rd, St Peters, MO 63376, United States
★★★★★ · Barbecue restaurant

Golden Chicken

You wouldn't believe the culinary treasure I found hidden in the heart of St. Peters.

Tucked away in an unassuming spot lies an eatery that would transport your taste buds straight to the Mediterranean without having to leave the city.

Trust me, once you visit Golden Chicken, you'll find yourself coming back for more.

Their menu is a delight, full of Mediterranean classics served in the most relaxed and casual manner, just the way comfort food should be.

The food, oh the food, is simply out of this world.

Want a recommendation?

Try the crispy fries, excellent shawarma, kebabs, and hummus.

It’s a meal that will leave you craving more.

And hey, if you're a fan of wings like me, do yourself a favor and try their lemon garlic wings and the hot honey wings.

The latter is an amazing blend of sweetness and heat, while the former is a refreshing surprise with its citrusy lemon flavor complemented by a deep savory garlic note.

The quality of the chicken is top-notch, and the wings are just the right size for a satisfying bite.

Golden Chicken · 632 Jungermann Rd, St Peters, MO 63376, United States
★★★★★ · Mediterranean restaurant

Hobos At The Legion

'Hobos At The Legion' has become my go-to place for some good old Southern comfort food.

Now, I am a sucker for their fried chicken, but I must admit, their catfish is a close competitor.

The crunch when you bite into it, followed by the soft, flaky fish inside, is just divine.

Each meal here feels like a warm hug from a loved one, and the accompanying potato salad and baked beans are simply the cherry on top.

There's no way you can go wrong with anything you order!

And the atmosphere, oh boy, it's like stepping back in time to a simpler era.

The walls are adorned with an array of beautiful patriotic art, which sparks conversations and brings back many a memory while you wait for your food.

I've tried their burger and traditional pizza as well during a family outing.

The cheese fries were a hit with the kids, while the adults enjoyed the heartier fare.

That pizza, my friends, is something I still fantasize about.

It’s a perfect blend of crisp crust, tangy sauce, and melting cheese.

Hobos At The Legion · 200 Main St, St Peters, MO 63376, United States
★★★★★ · Bar & grill

El Mezon Mexican Restaurant

Every time I crave authentic Mexican food, I find myself drawn back to El Mezon.

Nestled in the heart of St. Peter’s, this local Mexican eatery is my go-to relaxation spot.

You can't beat their vivacious décor, comfortable patio, and the rhythmic hum of pleasant chatter.

Believe me, from the moment you step in, you are bound to fall in love with this place.

An enticing aroma of seasoned meats greets you as you walk in, instantly sparking your appetite.

The salsa here is beyond compare - tangy and fresh.

And those chips, oh those chips!

They are always crunchy and seem to be fresh out of the oven.

A word to the wise - try their special extra hot sauce.

It adds an exciting kick to the dishes.

What's even better is the value for money.

The place is known for its jumbo margaritas and heaping plates of classic Mexican food.

You're looking at generous portions for about 15 bucks per plate.

But the cherry on top is their margarita towers.

If you’re in for a real treat, you can't miss it.

It's not just the food that's great.

The customer service is top-notch.

They really go out of their way to make you feel welcome.

El Mezon - Mexican Restaurant · 140 Salt Lick Rd, St Peters, MO 63376, Verenigde Staten
★★★★★ · Mexicaans restaurant

Erio's Ristorante

Have you ever had one of those meals that you just can't stop raving about?

That's exactly what I experienced at Erio's Ristorante.

This gem, tucked away in our city, has been serving mouth-watering Italian dishes for well over a decade.

I've been a regular patron here for the past 10 years, and not once have I had a disappointing meal.

I've crunched on their crisp salad, relished their delicious pizza, and savored every bit of their classic Italian dishes.

A personal favorite is the garlic cream pasta sauce on the Tortellini all Tricia, though some might find it a bit thick.

Getting a table on a Friday or Saturday night can be challenging, especially for larger groups, so advance reservations are prudent.

Don't let the hustle and bustle scare you away, though.

Despite being packed, the cleanliness is always top-notch.

You'd be hard-pressed to find a speck of dust on their old-fashioned furnishings.

Erio’s Ristorante · 951 Jungermann Rd, St Peters, MO 63376, United States
★★★★★ · Italian restaurant

Albadia Mediterranean Cuisine

From the very first time I set foot into Albadia Mediterranean Cuisine, I felt an immediate sense of belonging.

The warm ambiance and the friendly atmosphere wrap around you like a cozy blanket, and that's even before you've tasted the food.

I have to admit, the lamb chops here are easily the best I’ve ever had, and believe me, I've tried my fair share of lamb chops in the city.

Not to mention, the lentil soup, pita with zatar, and foul are all to die for.

But what truly sets Albadia apart is the mint tea.

It’s the perfect end to the feast, leaving me with a distinct, refreshing aftertaste that lingers on the palate.

Albadia Mediterranean Cuisine · 3957 Mid Rivers Mall Dr, St Peters, MO 63376, United States
★★★★★ · Mediterranean restaurant

Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant- St. Peters

Oh, the gastronomic wonders of the world, hidden in the cozy corners of our quaint city!

My taste buds were taken on an adventure at Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant- St. Peters.

Here's my tale of an evening filled with fine dining, fabulous wine, and an ambiance that wraps you in undeniable comfort.

From the moment I walked in, the aromatic symphony of delectable cuisines filled the air, painting a beautiful picture of what awaited me.

I found comfort in their extensive menu, with a special vegetarian entrée section to cater to my dietary preferences.

No need to worry about modifications - a true luxury for anyone who's chosen to tread the plant-based path.

They were well-versed with both the menu and the extensive selection of wines.

Their friendly demeanor and ability to recommend dishes and wines that complemented each other significantly enhanced my dining experience.

How can I not mention the Wine Club?

It's an absolute treat for wine lovers like me!

A free wine taster a month - who would want to miss out on that?

Every visit to this little haven comes with a promise of a pleasing new wine experience.

As for the food, it was nothing short of a culinary masterpiece.

I indulged in the Dinner size Chicken Madeira - a delicious concoction that left my palate satisfied yet yearning for more.

To top it all, the heavenly trio of encrusted medallions, served with mashed potatoes and asparagus, was a visual and gastronomic treat!

Oh, and if you're a seafood enthusiast, like my partner, don't miss out on the Crab, Shrimp, and Lobster bisque.

With every visit to Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant, I find myself falling in love with the place a little more.

It's a delightful spot that promises a memorable dining experience.

Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant- St. Peters · 5300 N Service Rd, St Peters, MO 63376, United States
★★★★★ · American restaurant

Other Restaurants Nearby

The Crooked Boot (St. Charles)

The aroma alone will draw you in, but once you taste the food at The Crooked Boot, there's no turning back.

An unexpected delight in our city, The Crooked Boot has quickly become my go-to spot for food that tantalizes my tastebuds.

I remember my first encounter with their Voodoo fries - a perfect blend of savory and spicy.

The shrimp and chicken were flavorful, though they could’ve been a tad warmer and the cheese a bit more melted.

The fries were a bit on the dry side, but nothing a little extra sauce wouldn't fix.

It was a minor hitch in an otherwise splendid dish.

Their menu never fails to surprise me with its quality.

A while ago, I treated myself to the Lafayette po boy.

Despite being one of the pricier items on the menu, it was worth every penny!

The bread was fresh, the shrimps were cooked to perfection and abundant, truly a dish I gladly reminisce about.

What also deserves mention are their onion rings, served hot and fresh.

I regret not getting a side of Vodou sauce to compliment them, but there's always a next time.

And without a doubt, there will be many next times for me at The Crooked Boot.

But what truly sets this place apart, beyond their delicious food, is the remarkable customer service.

I can't forget to mention their delectable desserts and the voodoo sauce that is so good, I ended up ordering my own container for home.

You can order yours too or explore their menu at The Crooked Boot..

The Crooked Boot · 2012 Campus Dr, St Charles, MO 63301, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Jafra (St. Charles)

A little piece of the Mediterranean Sea has washed ashore right here in our city, and it's called Jafra Mediterranean Restaurant.

Nestled in the heart of the city, Jafra offers a delightful escape from the mundane, a gastronomic journey that whisks you away to sun-drenched beaches and vibrant markets with every bite.

The moment you step through Jafra's doors, you're greeted with warm smiles that instantly make you feel at home.

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, just right for intimate dinners or fun-filled get-togethers.

One of the standout offerings at Jafra is their rich and robust Arabic coffee, infused with the exotic fragrance of cardamom.

It's a savory symphony that dances on your taste buds, making it an absolute favorite with visitors and locals alike.

When you're here, this is a must-try.

As you navigate through their menu, you'll discover a variety of fresh foods that celebrate the essence of the Mediterranean.

The grilled kebabs are succulent, the salads are fresh, and the rice is aromatic and perfectly seasoned.

Each dish is a testament to the rich culinary heritage of the Mediterranean, bursting with vibrant flavors that leave you craving for more.

Jafra Mediterranean Restaurant · 3551 Veterans Memorial Pkwy, St Charles, MO 63303, United States
★★★★★ · Mediterranean restaurant

Fratelli's Ristorante (St. Charles)

Ever have one of those nights where you just crave good, authentic Italian food?

That's what drove me and my partner to Fratelli's Ristorante last night.

This long-established bar and pizza parlor is a local favorite, known not just for its pies but also for its traditional Italian comfort food.

The ambiance was laid-back, making us feel right at home amidst the lively chatter of fellow diners and the alluring scent of Italian cuisine wafting through the air.

The food, let me tell you, was nothing short of amazing.

The meatballs were succulent, bathed in a delicious sauce that had us mopping up every bit with the bread they provided.

There was a minor hiccup with my partner's Caprice salad, but it did little to dampen our spirits.

We made a mental note to request “light cheese” on our next visit, as our entrees were a smidge heavy on the dairy.

However, my lemon chicken entree more than made up for it with its zesty flavor and generous portion.

Despite the hiccup with the soda's odd chemical flavor, my iced tea was perfectly refreshing.

It seemed as if the soda was perhaps an unfortunate one-off mishap.

The restaurant was packed with energy, and we found ourselves lost in a wonderful hour or two of dining decadence.

We left the restaurant with full stomachs and the promise of return lingering on our lips.

Fratelli’s Ristorante · 2061 Zumbehl Rd, St Charles, MO 63303, United States
★★★★★ · Italian restaurant

Spiro's St. Charles (St. Charles)

Spiro's St. Charles has become my go-to spot for Greek and Mediterranean cuisine.

With its laid-back atmosphere and dishes intended for sharing, it's the perfect spot to gather with friends and family for an unforgettable dining experience.

I remember one particular evening when I took my children out for dinner, and our dining experience at Spiro’s was nothing short of fantastic.

We ordered a variety of dishes from the menu, starting with the calamari.

The marinara sauce that accompanied it added a tangy depth to the tender squid and was an instant hit.

The beef kebab, though a little different from the ones you get from a typical Mediterranean restaurant, was also delicious.

We also tried the seafood pasta, which was a delightful medley of fresh seafood tossed in a creamy sauce.

The twice-baked potatoes that we ordered as a side were so delicious we were left wanting more.

Spiro’s St. Charles · 2275 Bluestone Dr, St Charles, MO 63303, United States
★★★★★ · Greek restaurant

Seasons Restaurant (St. Charles)

Picture this: A lazy Sunday with a decadent brunch spread out before you, the tranquil beauty of a sprawling golf course framing your view.

That's what my Sundays look like, thanks to the delightful Seasons Restaurant.

Nestled within the Old Hickory Golf Club, this establishment is a gem that adds a touch of luxury to my regular weekend routine.

Their Sunday brunch is a cornucopia of culinary delights, with every dish prepared thoughtfully and to perfection.

The best thing?

It's open to the public, so even non-golfers can savor the delicious food and drink in the warm and welcoming ambiance.

They even take reservations to save you from long waiting times - a testament to their great customer service.

As you dine, you are treated to stunning views of the golf course, making the experience even more enjoyable.

But Seasons Restaurant isn't only about Sunday Brunch.

Recently, for our company’s annual holiday dinner, we decided to host it here.

The food was excellent, and the portions were generous.

Seasons Restaurant · 1 Dye Club Dr, St Charles, MO 63304, United States
★★★★★ · Fine dining restaurant

Gingham's Homestyle Restaurant (St. Charles)

There's something about the scent of freshly brewed coffee reaching your senses that can turn even the gloomiest mornings into brighter ones.

That's the feeling I get every time I step into Gingham's Homestyle Restaurant, a place that truly lives up to its name.

I remember my first visit to Gingham's; it was a late-night craving that got me there.

They are one of the only true 24-hour diners in the city and definitely safer than your average Waffle House.

Imagine my surprise when I discovered their extensive menu filled with comforting American classics like the Buffalo Chicken Melt that I ordered.

The bread was perfectly toasted, not overly dry, and the chicken was moist, slathered with just the right amount of melted cheese.

It was one of those moments when you sigh with the first bite, knowing you’ve made an excellent choice.

One mustn't overlook their dessert menu either, despite the pies not being made in-house.

On that first visit, I took a slice of coconut cream pie to go.

It wasn't the best I've ever had, but it was still creamy, satisfying, and, well, comforting.

These days, Gingham's has become a breakfast ritual for me.

The dogs are always great with fresh hot coffee, and the menu offers so many home-cooked meals that I sometimes forget how long it's been since I ate that well at home.

And on the rare occasion when I decide to have dinner at Gingham's, I usually opt for their fried chicken with mashed potatoes or the soup of the day, which is always a delightful surprise.

Last time, it was the Chicken and Dumplings, a creamy and flavorful concoction that was incredibly filling.

The fried chicken, cooked to perfection, had just the right balance between outside crispness and inside juiciness, while the mashed potatoes were light and fluffy, complemented by the rich brown gravy.

Gingham’s Homestyle Restaurant · 1566 Country Club Plaza Dr, St Charles, MO 63303, United States
★★★★★ · American restaurant

Saullo's Restaurant (St. Charles)

Here I was thinking I knew all the food joints in the city, and then I stumbled upon Saullo's Restaurant.

A hidden gem right in our own backyard.

I must confess, this cozy Italian spot stole my heart with its familiar, soulful mains and the homemade marinara sauce that added a delightful robust flavor to my dish.

Walking into the restaurant, I was greeted with a charming and clean ambiance.

The quiet atmosphere was relaxing and provided the perfect setting for a laid-back dinner.

I decided to try the hand-rolled pizza, and boy, was it a treat!

The pizza dough was ultra-thin, just the way I like it.

Saullo’s Restaurant · 2778 Muegge Rd, St Charles, MO 63303, United States
★★★★★ · Italian restaurant

Final Thoughts

St. Peters offers an astonishing array of dining options that cater to all kinds of culinary preferences.

From mouth-watering barbecue at Heavy Smoke BBQ to the authentic flavors of Mediterranean cuisine at Albadia, there's something for everyone.

There's no shortage of great places to eat in St. Peters, each offering a unique dining experience that leaves a lasting impression.

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.