United States

15 Best Restaurants in St. George Island, FL

Vanessa Rodriguez

Oct 15, 2022 • 13 min read

Frank Bobe III / shutterstock.com

St. George Island in Franklin County is a barrier island that is 28 miles long and 1 mile at its widest point.

The island is connected to Eastpoint via the four-mile-long St. George Island Bridge, which spans Apalachicola Bay.

Due to its modest size, the island is renowned for its serenity, which is why many residents rent out their houses during spring and summer.

St. George Island provides a wealth of activities for all ages and has some of the quietest, pristine beaches in the Sunshine State.

On this uninhabited island, there are no tall buildings but just a carefree atmosphere, gorgeous coastlines, and untamed wildlife.

It is hardly unexpected that restaurants on St. George Island specialize in quality, locally sourced seafood, given that both Appalachicola Bay and the Gulf of Mexico are nearby.

Below are the best restaurants in St. George Island, Florida!

Blue Parrot Oceanfront Cafe

For an unforgettable vacation, visit Blue Parrot Oceanfront Cafe and enjoy its fresh seafood, beautiful views, and lovely ambiance.

This beachfront eatery on East Gorrie Drive is widely considered one of the best restaurants on St. George Island.

It offers a menu with classic seafood favorites and more adventurous dishes.

In the 1980s, The Blue Parrot was a modest beer and hot dog stand, previously called S.O. Beach.

Blue Parrot Oceanfront Cafe became its name once the new owners, who were ardent Jimmy Buffet fans, took over.

Get a taste of the seafood from the Florida Panhandle water, including the catch of the day, which is prepared using various methods, including grilling, blackening, and frying.

If you're not in the mood for seafood, you can try their certified Black Angus Steak for that melt-in-your-mouth goodness.

Harry A's On The Bay

If you're looking for a place to spend a night of fun, look no further than Harry A's On The Bay on West Bay Shore Drive.

This local favorite offers a great menu with plenty of seafood options, steaks, and burgers.

The restaurant also has an excellent wine list and a full bar to savor a drink or two with your meal.

If you're still unsure what to try, order a Bloody Mary, which is popular among customers.

Harry A's On The Bay has a casual yet chic atmosphere and is the perfect place to watch live performers while enjoying some of the best food on the island.

Ask the bartender for suggestions if you're interested in any of the other delicious selections that the restaurant has to offer.

Feel free to order cola or sweet tea if you're not in the mood for booze.

Paddy's Raw Bar

Surround yourself with the gorgeousness of Apalachicola Bay when you dine at Paddy's Raw Bar on 3rd Street East.

This local seafood restaurant offers some of the best Apalachicola oysters in town.

A visit to Paddy's Raw Bar would not be complete without trying the items on their menus, such as Shrimp & Grits, Monterey Mushroom Burger, shrimp quesadilla, and taco salad.

Their appetizers are mouth-watering, and you can choose from Redneck caviar, Tuna or Crab Dip, and a bowl of Gumbo.

Paddy's Raw Bar is also a great place to enjoy live music and has a full bar if you want a place to bond with your friends.

Live music is also a staple at this place, with performances by local and touring bands.

Beach Pit

With 25 years of business, the Beach Pit is one of the most popular restaurants on St. George Island.

This local burger joint on West Pine Avenue is famous for its delicious burgers, mouth-watering seafood dishes, and savory barbecue.

It has an extensive menu, which includes delectable starters likeJalapeño Poppers, Wings with five flavors, and Steamed Snow Crab Legs.

For sandwiches, you can try the All American Hamburger, Buffalo Burger, BBQ Beef Brisket Sandwich, Fried Grouper Sandwich, and Shrimp Po Boy.

If you're looking for a seafood concoction, you can try the Beach Pit's Blackened Shrimp, Grilled Tuna Steak, Fried Oysters, and Flounder Dinner.

For barbeque lovers, they also have One Meat BBQ Plate, Sampler Plater, and One Meat BBQ Dinner with Ribs.

BJ's Pizza & Subs

BJ's Pizza & Subs was established in 1990 in Pine Street Mini Mall.

It was initially housed in an 800-square-foot place with two tables.

Now perched on Gulf Beach Drive, BJ's Pizza and Subs moved to a bigger venue as their menu and business grew.

The restaurant has delectable pizzas, such as the Shrimp Pesto Pizza.

One of the local favorites you must check out is the buffalo chips pizza, with freshly made dough topped with spicy and grated parmesan cheese and ranch dressing.

Their specialty pizzas are a must-try, such as the cheesy Mexican Pizza or BJ's White Chicken and Bacon for the mozzarella and cheddar cheese.

You can also order beers and wines to chill out and relax with your meal.

Aunt Ebby's Ice Cream

If you are looking forward to a quiet time while enjoying a cup of ice cream, head to Aunt Ebby's Ice Cream on East Gulf Beach Drive.

This local ice cream parlor has been in business for more than 29 years.

Sit by picnic tables on the deck while savoring your ice cream and enjoying the view.

You can also enjoy your sweet and cold treat inside when the weather is too hot.

Aunt Ebby's Ice Cream is known for its wide variety of flavors that satisfy your sweet tooth.

Mango Mike's Sports Bar & Grill

Sports lovers would find their happy place in Mango Mike's Sports Bar on West Pine Avenue.

This local dive bar is known for its relaxed and friendly atmosphere.

Visitors can watch a game on the bar's big-screen TVs while relaxing with a cold beer.

The bar also has a menu of crowd favorites such as burgers, gator balls, potato wedges, wings, St. Louis Style Ribs, and hamburgers.

Oysters are one of the house specialties and are a must-try when visiting Mango Mike's Sports Bar.

Flavors of oysters include smoked barbecue, rockafella, buffalo, Mexican, and Italian.

Weber's Little Donut Shop

Kids and kids-at-heart will surely enjoy Weber's Little Donut Shop.

The shop is located on West Gorrie Drive, a popular stop for locals and tourists.

Weber's Little Donut Shop started its business baking small batches of donuts made fresh daily for their customers.

The shop takes pride in its old-fashioned donuts made with the freshest and finest ingredients.

Flavors include cinnamon, cream, and chocolate, with cute sprinkles, such as dinosaurs and unicorns.

The shop also caters to your pets, so you can treat your dog to a cupcake!

The Food Truck

The Food Truck has become a go-to spot for delicious food and hilarious humor since relocating to the island from the Nashville region in March 2019.

It offers everybody's favorites, such as burgers, fries, hotdogs, and soups.

The Food Truck's menu changes daily, so you can always try something new when you visit.

Some popular dishes are Mac Attack, Chicken Bacon Swiss Sandwich, and Black Bean Veggie Burger.

You can find The Food Truck on West Gorrie Drive.

Subway

For casual dining, you can drop by Subway, a popular fast-food chain that offers submarine sandwiches and salads.

The sandwich shop is located on East Gulf Beach Drive, where you can get fast and filling food when you are on the go.

Subway uses the freshest ingredients to prepare their sandwiches.

Featured in St. George Island's Subway are All American Club, The Monster, and the Supreme Meats.

You can also enjoy a foot-long sandwich and choose from a wide variety of fillings such as roast beef, chicken, tuna, and turkey.

Other Restaurants Nearby

If you still have a few days to spare, you can go through the nearby places for more restaurants to visit.

Red Pirate Family Grill & Oyster Bar

Located in Eastpoint, Red Pirate Family Grill & Oyster Bar is just 10 minutes from St. George Island.

One of the most renowned restaurants in the area, Red Pirate Family Grill & Oyster Bar is the gateway to St. George Island, with its location at the edge of the bridge to the famed island.

To witness how the staff opens an oyster, you can choose a table where they are doing the shucking of fresh oysters.

For those who can't go far away from their pets, you can choose the Captain Quarters, the area where you can sit with your pets.

You can stay on the Wheel House and breathe in the fresh air while eating your burger or fish.

While resting, you can play with a putt-putt course, and the kids can explore the surroundings.

The Owl Cafe

The Owl Cafe is located in the center of Apalachicola and provides a distinctive eating experience in the River City.

Their fantastic starters, delectable entrées, and unique sweets are prepared by attentive staff.

Eighteen minutes from St. George Island, The Owl Cafe offers menu changes daily, including unique imported dishes and delicious seafood caught near the island.

The impressive wine list offers the ideal pairing for each dish and is as full of personality as Apalachicola.

Lunch is served every Tuesday to Saturday, when you can have your fill of fried oysters, cab cakes, Duck Confit Fries, and Chicken Salad Club.

For desserts, check out their baked caramel custard, pecan pie tartlette, and key lime cheesecake.

The Station Raw Bar

The Station Raw Bar's unique charm comes from the fact that it's a former gas station that was converted into a full-service restaurant and bar.

It's known for its fresh oysters, which they get from their nearby private dock.

The Station Raw Bar quickly became a neighborhood favorite because of its pleasant service delivery and luscious food.

Your favorite sandwiches, gourmet or fried oysters, and shrimp may be found here.

You can also enjoy your meal by pairing it with beer or wine from their full-service Bar.

Half Shell Dockside

On Market Street, Apalachicola's Half Shell Dockside offers mouth-watering lunch selections at reasonable prices.

Just 20 minutes from St. George Island, you can catch the maritime activities while taking in the stunning scenery, unusual drinks, friendly gestures, and authentic southern welcome.

If a leisurely dinner is on the agenda, take a seat on the outdoor deck to take in the stunning sunset over the Apalachicola River.

Oysters on the half shell are the restaurant's specialty, but they provide a range of dishes so that everyone may find something they enjoy.

At Half Shell Dockside, something entertaining and exciting is always going on, like bingo, trivia, and live music the rest of the week.

El Jalisco Mexican Restaurant

One of the best Mexican food in Eastpoint can be found at El Jalisco Mexican Restaurant, 10 minutes from St. George Island.

The restaurant's owner, Jesus Carranza, and his family have been honing their technique for more than a decade to deliver fresh, authentic Mexican food to Eastpoint and Northern Florida.

At El Jalisco Mexican Restaurant, you can try some of the best fajitas like Master Parrillada, Cancun's Fajitas, Fajitas Tapatias, and El Jalisco Fajitas.

Try the delicious fried ice cream, one of the most popular items on the menu.

El Jalisco Mexican Restaurant also offers tacos, burritos, chimichangas, quesadillas, nachos, and carnitas.

The combination of great food, affordable prices, and excellent service has made El Jalisco Mexican Restaurant a well-loved place among locals and visitors.

Final Thoughts

These are only some of the best restaurants in St. George Island, Florida.

You'll have to explore and find your favorite spots to get an authentic taste of the island.

With so many great options, you're sure to have a delicious experience no matter where you go.

💌

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.

✍️

Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.