20 Best Restaurants in Southampton, NY

Best Restaurants in Southampton, NY
littlenySTOCK / shutterstock.com

Ah, Southampton - a picturesque and charming town nestled in Long Island's famed Hamptons.

Known for its pristine beaches and luxurious summer homes, this tiny yet sophisticated town also boasts an incredible dining scene.

As someone who has lived here for years, I have had the pleasure of exploring the culinary delights that Southampton has to offer.

From casual beachside cafes to chic and elegant dining establishments, there is a restaurant here to satisfy every palate and craving.

Join me as I take you on a journey through my personal selection of the 18 best restaurants in Southampton, New York.

Be prepared to embark on a gastronomic adventure that showcases a diverse array of cuisines, atmospheres, and flavors.

Whether you're visiting Southampton for the first time or have been a fellow resident for years, I am confident that this list will inspire you to discover new culinary favorites in our beautiful town.

So grab your appetite, and let's begin our culinary exploration of Southampton's finest dining establishments.

The Plaza Café

Scallops at The Plaza Café
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/the-plaza-caf%C3%A9-southampton

I recently decided to treat myself to a fancy night out and chose The Plaza Café for the occasion.

The ambiance was simple, peaceful, and luxurious, which made the dining experience even more enjoyable.

One of the things that stood out to me was their first-class seafood innovations.

I decided to order the pan-seared scallops, and they were cooked to perfection.

The dish was packed with flavor, and the presentation was beautiful.

For my drink, I opted for a glass of local wine from their unique selection.

It paired perfectly with my meal and enhanced the flavors of the dish.

Throughout the evening, the service was impeccable.

The whole experience felt personalized and special, leaving me eager to return in the future.

Enchanté Bistro

One of my favorite places to enjoy a delightful French dining experience in town is Enchanté Bistro.

Not only is the atmosphere inviting, but the genuine French cuisine is also simply irresistible.

Upon entering the bistro, I was immediately charmed by the elegant and cozy interior.

The soft lighting and vintage French decor transported me straight to France.

For starters, I indulged in their Escargots à la Bourguignonne, which were cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor.

The main course was equally impressive - I had the Canard à l'Orange, a classic French dish featuring a beautifully roasted duck served with a zesty orange sauce.

It was cooked just right, and the flavors were well-balanced, making it a definite standout dish.

To accompany my meal, the knowledgeable server suggested a fantastic wine that perfectly paired with the duck.

The wine list at Enchanté Bistro is extensive, offering a great selection of both local and French wines.

To conclude my delightful evening, I savored their decadent Crème Brûlée for dessert.

It had a perfectly caramelized sugar top, which added a satisfying crunch to the velvety custard underneath.

Slice of the Hamptons

I absolutely love spending my weekends relaxing at Slice of the Hamptons.

This past weekend, I had the pleasure of visiting this beautiful spot with a few friends, and we had such an amazing time.

The atmosphere was incredibly cozy and welcoming, reminiscent of a beach house.

Their menu had a great variety of options, and the food was simply delicious.

We started off with the Truffle Fries as an appetizer, and they were the best I've ever had.

Next, we tried the Lobster Roll with a side of coleslaw, which was incredibly fresh and perfectly seasoned.

My friends and I couldn't resist their mouthwatering wood-fired pizza.

We decided on the Margherita, and it was an excellent choice: the crust was crispy, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

Besides the food, there's no denying that the service at Slice of the Hamptons is exceptional.

The best part of my experience at Slice of the Hamptons had to be the breathtaking view of the bay.

Main Prospect

Arepa at Main Prospect
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/main-prospect-southampton

The menu at Main Prospect offers a variety of delicious food options.

I can't get enough of their mouthwatering appetizers like the loaded nachos and duck arepa.

I'm also a huge fan of their entrees; the grilled ribeye steak is cooked to perfection, and their pasta dishes are always so flavorful.

One of my friends swears by their fish tacos, claiming they're the best he's ever had!

Another highlight of Main Prospect is its fantastic drink selection.

They have a diverse array of craft beers on tap, and their signature cocktails are always a hit.

I've tried several of their cocktails, and I must say, the passionfruit mojito is to die for!

Main Prospect also offers live entertainment, which truly enhances the overall experience.

Sant Ambroeus

Pasta at Sant Ambroeus
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/sant-ambroeus-southampton-southampton-2

I had an incredible dining experience at Sant Ambroeus, an Italian eatery that I can't recommend enough.

The restaurant's elegant and refined atmosphere made for a delightful evening with friends, as we enjoyed some of the best Italian dishes I've had in a long time.

Upon arriving, I immediately noticed the airy and spacious setting, which was perfect for intimate conversations over dinner.

Their espresso was hands down one of the best I've ever tasted, and the gelati were simply irresistible.

My friends and I couldn't resist trying their panini as well, which were nothing short of perfection.

The highlight of the evening was definitely the incredible selection of dishes on the menu.

Each plate was carefully crafted and presented beautifully, making it a feast both for the eyes and the palate.

I was particularly impressed with the pasta dish I ordered, which was cooked to perfection and seasoned just right.

My friends raved about their dishes as well, making it a unanimous agreement that Sant Ambroeus knows how to impress with their culinary skills.

Saaz Indian Restaurant

Samosa at Saaz Indian Restaurant
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/saaz-indian-cuisine-southampton-2

Last Friday, I decided to treat myself and some friends to a delicious Indian dinner at Saaz, a casual dining spot in our neighborhood.

The place offers traditional Indian plates, smoothies, and cocktails, which sounded perfect for our night out.

As soon as we entered the restaurant, we were impressed by the cozy and basic space, making us feel right at home.

We started with some refreshing smoothies and cocktails while browsing through their extensive menu.

We couldn't resist trying their Paneer Tikka, which turned out to be a delightful choice.

The paneer was so soft and flavorful, accompanied by a perfectly spiced sauce that left us craving more.

The Biryani was another hit among our group, as the rice was cooked just right, and the blend of spices was spot-on.

The meat samosas were crispy on the outside and had just the right amount of filling.

One of the highlights of the night was their Tandoori Chicken, which was incredibly tender and packed with flavor.

The aromatic smell of the dish had our mouths watering before we even took a bite.

Showwin Japanese Cuisine

Rolls at Showwin Japanese Cuisine
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/showwin-japanese-cuisine-southampton

One of my favorite places to grab a meal in Southampton is Showwin Japanese Cuisine.

Their menu offers an incredible variety of delicious and authentic dishes that never fail to impress.

The first thing that strikes me every time I walk into Showwin is the warm and inviting atmosphere.

I've had the pleasure of trying many of their offerings, and I'm yet to be disappointed.

Their sushi rolls are always fresh, beautifully presented, and bursting with flavor.

I particularly enjoy the spicy tuna roll - it has just the right amount of kick without being overwhelming.

The tempura dishes are also amazing.

Aside from sushi, Showwin Japanese Cuisine also offers a variety of other options, such as ramen and teriyaki dishes.

I had the chance to try their chicken teriyaki, and it was phenomenal.

The chicken was tender and juicy, and the sauce had a perfect balance of sweetness and savory flavors.

Another great aspect of Showwin is that they offer a daily lunch special, making it an affordable and delicious option for a midday meal.

I've tried their bento box lunch special, which comes with a choice of two items, rice, salad, and miso soup.

It's an amazing deal that I would highly recommend.

Claude's Restaurant

Lobster salad at Claude's Restaurant
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/claudes-at-the-southampton-inn-southampton

Last week, I decided to treat myself to dinner at Claude's Restaurant at the Southampton Inn.

I had heard great things about the place, and I was eager to try it out for myself.

From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a delightful experience.

The ambiance was warm and inviting, with tasteful decor and soft lighting that created the perfect atmosphere for a relaxing meal.

I started off with their delicious lobster mango salad, which was perfectly seasoned, and refreshing on the palate.

For my main course, I opted for pan-seared salmon with a side of roasted vegetables.

The salmon was cooked to perfection, with a crisp exterior and a tender, flaky interior.

The vegetables were also perfectly cooked, with a nice blend of flavors and textures that complemented the salmon beautifully.

While the food was undoubtedly amazing, what truly set Claude's Restaurant apart was the live music.

As I enjoyed my meal, I was serenaded by a talented pianist whose soothing melodies added a touch of elegance to the dining experience.

It was the perfect way to unwind after a long day, and I left the restaurant feeling satisfied and rejuvenated.

Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant

Pizza at Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/pellegrinos-pizza-bar-and-restaurant-southampton

One of my favorite spots for a night out with friends and family has to be Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant.

Their menu offers a wide variety of options, from appetizers to pizzas and pasta dishes.

One thing I love about Pellegrino's is that no matter what dish I try, I always end up satisfied with the taste and quality.

I remember one visit when I decided to try their Margherita pizza.

It was a perfect balance of fresh ingredients and flavors, with the basil, tomato, and mozzarella cheese melting together in my mouth.

The crust was thin and crispy, just the way I like it.

I've heard from other patrons that their specialty pizzas, like the Buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken, are also a must-try!

Not in the mood for pizza? Don't worry - Pellegrino's offers a variety of pasta dishes that are just as delicious.

My go-to pasta dish is lasagna, which is always served hot and bubbling with a generous helping of cheese.

The portions are quite generous - I usually have leftovers for the next day.

Shippy's Pumpernickels

Schnitzel at Shippy's Pumpernickels
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/shippys-pumpernickels-restaurant-east-southampton

One of my favorite places to dine in town is Shippy's Pumpernickels, a long-standing restaurant that offers a fantastic selection of American and German comfort dishes in a homey setting.

Being a local, I've had the chance to visit Shippy's several times, and I'm never disappointed.

Upon entering, the warm and welcoming atmosphere immediately makes you feel at home.

On my last visit, I decided to go for one of their popular German dishes – the Sauerbraten.

The meat was tender and flavorful, and it came with delicious potato pancakes and red cabbage.

Their menu is quite extensive, offering a variety of choices for everyone.

My friend, who joined me on this visit, opted for the Schnitzel, and she couldn't stop raving about how delicious and perfectly cooked it was.

We also loved their homemade pretzels, which were soft and warm – the perfect appetizer to start our meal.

Shippy's Pumpernickels also offers a great selection of beers, featuring both American and German options.

I particularly enjoyed their German beer, which was crisp and refreshing – the perfect companion to my hearty meal.

Luxe Fresh Seafood

I've always been a seafood lover, and living in the area has allowed me to become a regular at Luxe Fresh Seafood.

It's one of the best places to get fresh and delicious seafood in town!

When I first visited Luxe Fresh Seafood, I was immediately impressed by the cleanliness and modern design of the store.

The seafood selection was fabulous - from shrimp and clams to salmon and tuna, there was so much to choose from.

And I could tell that everything was fresh and well-maintained, as I didn't notice any unpleasant smells that can sometimes be associated with fish markets.

One of my favorite things about Luxe Fresh Seafood is its daily specials.

I always make sure to check their website to see what's on offer for the day and plan my meals accordingly.

On one of my trips, I managed to score some amazing scallops that were special, and they turned out to be the most tender and flavorful scallops I've ever cooked.

In addition to its fresh seafood, Luxe Fresh Seafood also offers a variety of sauces, seasonings, and other ingredients needed to create the perfect seafood dish.

This makes it so convenient for me, as I can pick up everything I need in one stop.

Oakland's Restaurant

Oysters at Oakland's Restaurant
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/oaklands-restaurant-and-marina-hampton-bays

One of my favorite places to spend a lovely evening with friends and family is Oakland's Restaurant.

The stunning sunset and water views always make for a memorable dining experience.

The menu at Oakland's is focused on American seafood, and the quality of the dishes is undeniable.

I started with a fresh and vibrant shrimp cocktail as an appetizer and was impressed by the size and taste of the shrimp.

For my main course, I couldn't resist trying the lobster roll, which was generously filled with succulent lobster meat and served with crispy fries.

My friends and I also shared a delicious seafood platter that included crab legs, mussels, clams, and oysters.

Everything tasted incredibly fresh and was cooked to perfection.

Oakland's also offers a great selection of drinks to accompany your meal.

I opted for a refreshing and fruity cocktail while my friends enjoyed some local craft beers.

The open-air bar area is a fantastic spot to relax and take in the views, with the added bonus of live music on select evenings.

Shinnecock Lobster Factory

Lobster roll at Shinnecock Lobster Factory
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/shinnecock-lobster-factory-southampton

I remember the first time I visited Shinnecock Lobster Factory, it was a sunny afternoon, and I was craving some fresh seafood.

The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with a warm, friendly atmosphere that immediately made me feel welcomed.

As a seafood enthusiast, I was excited to try out their menu, and I must say, it exceeded my expectations.

I started off with their clam chowder, which was creamy, rich, and had just the right amount of seasoning.

For my main course, I decided to indulge in their lobster roll - a decision I have never regretted.

The lobster meat was fresh, succulent, and generously portioned.

The roll was toasted to perfection and the combination of flavors left me craving for more.

Of course, I couldn't leave without trying their famous steamers, which were cooked to perfection, boasting a delightful flavor that can only be achieved with the freshest of clams.

The drawn butter served alongside added a subtle richness that elevated the whole experience.

In addition to the exceptional food and service, the ambiance of the restaurant was truly inviting.

Their outdoor seating area allowed me to enjoy my delicious seafood feast while taking in the beautiful views of the surrounding area.

La Hacienda Mexican Grill

Tacos at La Hacienda Mexican Grill
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/la-hacienda-mexican-grill-southampton

Just the other day, I decided to pay a visit to La Hacienda Mexican Grill for breakfast.

This low-key counter-serve offers a fantastic variety of tacos, burritos, and tortas, and their breakfast options are simply mouthwatering.

Upon entering, I was greeted with a warm and welcoming atmosphere.

I went ahead and ordered their breakfast burrito, and it was simply divine!

The blend of flavors was perfect, and the ingredients were incredibly fresh.

What struck me the most about La Hacienda Mexican Grill was their dedication to high-quality, authentic Mexican cuisine.

It's evident in every dish they serve, and it truly sets them apart from other Mexican eateries I've been to.

The prices were also very reasonable, making this a great spot for anyone looking to enjoy delicious Mexican food without breaking the bank.

While I was there, I couldn't help but notice how many other happy customers were enjoying their meals.

La Hacienda Mexican Grill has undoubtedly earned a loyal following, and I can wholeheartedly say that I am now one of their biggest fans.

Le Chef

Escargot at Le Chef
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/le-chef-southampton

If you're looking for a truly authentic French-continental bistro experience, I highly recommend visiting Le Chef.

Established around 1980, this cozy bistro has been serving delectable lunch and nightly fixed-price menus to its patrons.

I've been visiting this quaint little spot for years, and it never fails to impress me with its delicious food and warm atmosphere.

The menu is carefully curated and always offers a fantastic selection of classic French dishes.

I particularly enjoy their escargot, which is cooked to perfection and served in a delicious garlic butter sauce.

Their coq au vin, a traditional French chicken dish, is another favorite of mine – the rich and flavorful sauce is absolutely divine!

One aspect of Le Chef that I truly appreciate is its commitment to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients.

This not only ensures the highest quality in their dishes but also supports the local community.

Pair your meal with a glass of wine from their extensive selection, and you'll have a dining experience you won't soon forget.

La Parmigiana

Penne alla vodka at La Parmigiana
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/la-parmigiana-italian-restaurant-southampton

One of my favorite go-to spots for a relaxing and delicious meal is La Parmigiana in Southampton.

This casual Italian mainstay has been around since 1972, serving comfort food in family-style portions to the bustling crowds.

The atmosphere is warm, inviting, and perfect for a night out with friends or family.

The menu is extensive, featuring a variety of classic Italian dishes such as pasta, seafood, and meat options.

I decided to start with their mouth-watering garlic bread and a glass of their house red wine to set the tone for the evening.

For my main course, I chose the pasta alla vodka, which was absolutely divine.

The pasta was cooked to perfection, and the sauce had just the right amount of creaminess and tang from the vodka.

My dining companions opted for the chicken parmigiana and the seafood linguine, which were also met with rave reviews.

The portions were generous, allowing us to share and sample each other's dishes, creating a true family-style dining experience.

Melrose East Restaurant and Pizza

Pizza at Melrose East Restaurant and Pizza
https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/melrose-east-restaurant-and-pizza-southampton-3

The other day, I decided to grab a pizza from Melrose East Restaurant and Pizza, and it turned out to be one of my most amazing pizza experiences ever!

The place itself was warm and welcoming, with a pleasant ambiance that sets the mood for a great dining experience.

The menu had a wide variety of options, and after some consideration, I decided to go for their signature pizza.

Let me tell you: it was love at first bite!

The crust was perfectly crispy, and the toppings were generously portioned and full of flavor.

The blend of cheeses they used was just divine, and it all came together in a mouth-watering symphony of taste.

I also couldn't help but notice how clean and well-maintained the restaurant was, which is always a huge plus for me.

The service was not only friendly but also very efficient.

Rotonda Restaurant

My latest culinary venture led me to the illustrious Rotonda Restaurant in Southampton, NY.

This hidden gem emanates an enchanting allure, effortlessly blending luxury and comfort.

It's a true embodiment of home away from home, laced with an air of refined elegance.

Each visit leaves me eagerly anticipating the next, thanks to their tantalizing gastronomic wonders.

Stepping into the Rotonda is an invitation to a culinary journey.

The gourmet selection they offer tantalizes the palate, teasing the senses with a playful dance between traditional and modern flavors.

Freshly made pasta, cooked to perfection, adorned my plate on my recent sojourn, it was a masterstroke, evoking a symphony of flavors.

It is undeniable that only ingredients of top-notch quality find their way to Rotonda's kitchen.

But the real icing on the cake, quite literally, is their gelato.

This indulgent treat is a must, a sin you'd gladly commit, as it rounds off an already exemplary dining experience.

Rotonda's attention to detail extends beyond the menu, seeping into the very presence of their dishes, with each plate narrating a unique tale of culinary artistry.

Final Thoughts

Southampton truly has an incredible array of dining options that cater to every taste and preference.

From the exquisite seafood dishes at The Plaza Café and Luxe Fresh Seafood to the comforting Italian cuisine at La Parmigiana and Le Chef, there is always something to satisfy my cravings.

So next time you find yourself in Southampton, I highly recommend giving one or more of these fantastic eateries a try – I guarantee that your taste buds will thank you!

💌
Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
✍️
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.