21 Best Restaurants in Sebring, FL

This article was written by local contributor Jaylen Fleming & edited by the Travel Lens team.

Jaylen Fleming

Jul 2, 2023 • 15 min read

I've lived in Sebring, Florida, for quite some time now, and one of the things I absolutely love about this charming city is the delightful variety of local restaurants.

Over the years, I've had the pleasure of dining at many of them, and I have to say, I'm quite impressed with the culinary scene here in Sebring.

From mouthwatering seafood to comforting Southern dishes, there's truly something for everyone.

In this article, I'm excited to share with you some of my top picks for the best restaurants in Sebring, Florida, that you simply must try!

So, let's dive into the flavors of our beautiful city and explore the culinary gems that are just waiting to be discovered.

Green Leaf Vegan Kitchen

I recently discovered Green Leaf Vegan Kitchen in my neighborhood, and I have to say, it has quickly become one of my favorite spots to grab a bite to eat.

As someone with a sensitive stomach, I am always on the lookout for places that serve delicious food that won't upset my system.

Green Leaf Vegan Kitchen has exceeded my expectations in that regard.

The first time I went, I ordered a pizza and a black bean burger, which were both incredibly flavorful and didn't cause any issues for my stomach.

The ambiance of the place is cozy and inviting, with great energy.

Since then, I have tried the Lasagna and the Supreme Burrito, both of which were amazing and made with fresh ingredients.

It’s honestly some of the best vegan food I’ve had.

Even if you're not vegan, I highly recommend giving Green Leaf Vegan Kitchen a try.

Their delicious plant-based dishes will have you falling in love with vegan food. O

Fairmount Cafe

I recently visited Fairmount Cafe, and I must say, it was a delightful experience!

As soon as you walk in, you can feel the warm and welcoming atmosphere.

The new management is doing a fantastic job, and they are truly wonderful people.

One time, my friends and I arrived just a couple of minutes before closing, but they were kind enough to still take our order even after they had finished cleaning the grills.

The food at Fairmount Cafe is absolutely delicious, and the prices are quite reasonable.

I particularly enjoy their refreshing honey mustard club wrap and the perfectly seasoned home fries.

Their homemade soups are a must-try; I dare say they are the best in Sebring!

They've also recently added breakfast options to the menu, which I'm eager to try soon.

Argana Café

Living close to Argana Café, I've had the pleasure of enjoying their delicious and authentic Moroccan food numerous times.

Each visit has been a delightful experience, and I can't help but feel at home in this cozy spot.

Some of my personal favorites include the lamb tagine, Moroccan supreme pizza, and Moroccan egg rolls.

The lemon coconut cookies are definitely a must-try as well.

And whenever I have friends or family visiting, I make sure to take them to Argana Café so they can experience the incredible flavors and warmth that this little gem has to offer.

Organically Local

I remember when I first moved to Highlands, my partner and I stumbled upon this quaint little restaurant called Organically Local.

At the time, they were a smaller operation, and we weren't able to eat there due to the crowd.

It took us almost four years, but we finally decided to stop by again for lunch the other day, and what an amazing experience it was!

The atmosphere was clean and had a pretty chill vibe, perfect for a day date with my partner.

We were particularly impressed by how accommodating they were to other customers, like going out of their way to retrieve a clean blender for a child with allergies.

That's something that really stood out to me and made me appreciate this establishment even more.

Oscar's Family Restaurant

I have to say, one of my favorite go-to breakfast spots in town has to be Oscar's Family Restaurant.

Just last Saturday, I decided to give it another visit, and I was not disappointed!

There was a 15-20 minute wait, but it was well worth it.

My usual order consists of over medium eggs, hashbrowns, biscuits, and gravy, and of course, a hot coffee poured over ice.

The prices are always affordable, and the serving size satisfies my hunger.

One thing that sets Oscar's apart is their raisin bread, which is so hard to find these days!

Faded Bistro & Beer Garden

One of my favorite places to eat in town has to be Faded Bistro & Beer Garden.

I've been frequenting this spot for quite some time now, and it never disappoints.

The food is always exceptional, with delicious appetizers like their hummus sampler and olives, followed by mouthwatering entrees such as the rack of lamb, fresh catch of the day, and tuna poke.

I love the Sunday brunch menu too, which offers a great selection of dishes to choose from.

What I truly appreciate about Faded Bistro is the atmosphere - it's a fantastic place to meet up with friends and family or even have a business meeting.

If you can, I highly recommend making a reservation to sit outside in their lovely garden.

The Gator Shack

One of my favorite spots to eat in town has to be The Gator Shack.

As a resident, I can confidently say that this place never disappoints.

The lightly breaded mushrooms are a great appetizer to start with, but the real stars of the show are their seafood dishes.

I remember one time I went with a group of friends, and we ordered the seafood platter with the fried gator, grilled shrimp, and grilled fish filet.

I was amazed at how quickly our food arrived despite the place being packed, and the taste was something I still crave today.

Sandys Cafe 98

Just the other day, I decided to try out Sandys Cafe 98 for breakfast.

I've heard mixed reviews about the place, but as a lover of quaint, old-time diners, I just had to give it a shot.

I must say, my experience was delightful!

I ordered the pancake with blueberries and sugar-free syrup, while my partner went for the egg whites with veggies, hash browns, and rye bread toast.

The food was delicious, and the service was quite good.

The old-time diner atmosphere added a touch of nostalgia, which made the dining experience even more enjoyable.

Sophie's Cafe

Sophie's Cafe is one of my favorite spots to grab a bite. This Cuban place has got flavors and an atmosphere that you just can't miss.

You can visit their website to check out their menu and specials.

Their sandwiches were a hit!

One of my favorite things to order at Sophie's is their flan - it's just so yummy!

Though, I must admit, their white rice with a black bean side dish is the bomb.

Ranchero Cafe Restaurant

Ranchero Cafe Restaurant has become my go-to spot for authentic Mexican cuisine.

Here's the exact location if you're interested in trying it out.

Every time I visit, the food is consistently delicious.

I can't get enough of their tamales served with green sauce – it's simply the bomb!

The Torres family, who runs the place, truly knows how to create the most mouthwatering Mexican dishes.

The atmosphere is always friendly, making it a perfect place to gather with friends or family.

Dee's Place

I absolutely love going to Dee's Place for breakfast.

The atmosphere is warm and cozy, and it really reminds me of visiting my aunt's house on a country farm when I was a kid.

They serve a great selection of classic American breakfast dishes like bacon omelets, waffles, and biscuits and gravy.

Their portion sizes are generous, and the food is always fresh and delicious.

One of my favorite things about Dee's Place is the regular gospel music they have playing.

It adds to the comfortable, homey atmosphere, making it a great place to relax and enjoy a meal.

Broken Egg Diner

I recently celebrated my birthday with a few friends over breakfast at Broken Egg Diner, and I must say, it was an experience to remember.

I ordered eggs over easy, which were cooked perfectly, and the biscuits & gravy were simply to die for.

Not only is the food great, but the atmosphere is fantastic.

My dad, who has dementia, and I often dine here, and they always treat him with respect and patience.

It's something I truly appreciate, and it makes me feel like a valued member of the community.

Tony's II Pizzeria

I have to tell you ever since I discovered Tony's II Pizzeria a few years back, my love for pizza has reached new heights.

I can't help but indulge in their amazing 18-inch pizzas pretty often.

And you know what?

I'm proud to recommend this place to anyone who's looking for a mouthwatering pizza experience.

Being a local in the area, I've had the chance to try several different pizzas from their menu, and each time, I'm left impressed.

Galati's Family Restaurant

I recently had the pleasure of spending an evening at Galati's Family Restaurant, and I must say, it was truly a delightful experience.

But let's talk about the real star of the show: the food. I ordered the Galati's Special pizza, and I can confidently say that it was the best pizza I've ever had in my life.

The sauce and sausage are made in-house, and the quality of the ingredients is evident in every bite.

The flavors were simply mouthwatering, and I found myself savoring every last morsel.

Aside from the pizza, I also tried their hand-battered mushrooms and onion rings, which were absolutely delicious.

The mushrooms were so tender and flavorful they practically melted in my mouth.

Havana Restaurant & Bakery Corp

I have been going to Havana Restaurant & Bakery Corp for quite some time now, and I must say, it's one of my favorite spots to grab a delicious Cuban meal in the area.

Their breakfast menu offers a variety of American Cafe options, but what really stands out is their amazing Cuban coffee and toast.

On top of the great food, their bakery is to die for - I always make sure to pick up some baked goods to go whenever I visit.

I've never had any issues with the service during my numerous visits, and I'm always impressed by how they go out of their way to ensure my time there is enjoyable.

The menu offers a wide variety of options, but I have to say that their chicken empanada and Cuban sandwich are simply the best.

Cowpoke's Watering Hole

I have found my ultimate go-to spot for a great night out - Cowpoke's Watering Hole.

This relaxed surf 'n' turf eatery not only features regular live music from local bands in their tiki bar but also serves up some of the most delicious steaks I've ever had!

The vibe at Cowpoke's is casual and family-friendly, making it a perfect place to gather with friends and family.

I remember once going there with a party of 11 on a Saturday night.

We made reservations to make sure we got a spot, and it was well worth it.

The menu can be a bit on the expensive side, but the quality of the food is definitely worth the price.

I have tried many dishes on their menu, but some of my all-time favorites include the gator bites, fried green tomatoes, and the filet Oscar style.

They also offer a refillable salad with a unique Southern ranch dressing that is just delicious!

And don't even get me started on their irresistible garlic bread.

Jimmy's Greek American Grill

I often find myself craving some delicious Greek food, and Jimmy's Greek American Grill never disappoints!

Located conveniently inside the mall, it has become more of a fast-food experience, but the quality of food remains exceptional.

Although I miss the old atmosphere of being served in a standalone building and the use of real plates and utensils, I understand the change to paper and plastic due to its new location.

Despite these changes, the food is always great and tasty. Portions can be a bit smaller sometimes, but that's likely because of the current market conditions.

One of my favorite dishes is their Gyro with grilled pita.

The portions are generous, and the service is excellent.

Bongos Creative Cuisine

I'm always on the lookout for unique and delicious dining experiences.

That's when I stumbled upon Bongos Creative Cuisine on Facebook.

Just the other day, I visited Bongos with my family, and we enjoyed the most incredible meal.

From the Cuban sandwich to the shrimp creole, every dish was bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection.

My sister and brother-in-law tried the beef stir fry and Caribbean pork, and they couldn't stop raving about how fantastic their meals were.

To top it all off, we shared a mouthwatering creme Brule for dessert.

What truly sets Bongos apart, though, is the amazing service.

The cook's love for cooking is evident in every bite, making each visit to this wonderful restaurant worthwhile.

Nutmeg's Cafe

I absolutely adore spending my afternoons at Nutmeg's Cafe.

The Mediterranean wrap is always my go-to, and I usually pair it with their delicious grilled three cheese.

And, of course, I never leave without capping off my meal with a cup of Mocha.

It's such a delight to be able to wind down in this cozy cafe that's just around the corner from my house.

Every time I step into this charming little gem of a place, I feel so at home.

Just recently, I tried their honey peanut butter grilled panini, and it was simply divine.

The homemade cheeseburger soup is the perfect companion for it, and I couldn't resist getting a cupcake pop to finish off my meal.

The flavors just blew my mind!

Dimitri's Restaurant, Pizza Kitchen and Its 5 O'clock Somewhere Bar

I've been a regular at Dimitri's Restaurant, Pizza Kitchen and Its 5 O'clock Somewhere Bar for years, and it never disappoints.

One of my favorite things about this place is the cool, classic setting.

I love their reasonable prices, and the quality of the food is excellent.

For instance, their Greek salad is an absolute must-try!

I love dining here late afternoon.

The warm weather and view of the sunset are perfect complements to the delicious food.

Zack's Pizza & BBQ

Zack's Pizza & BBQ has become my go-to spot for a scrumptious meal.

One of my favorite things to order is their large side salad – it's simple yet delicious with fresh ingredients, homemade croutons, and a generous serving of tasty cheese.

Their pizza is nothing short of amazing – it has the perfect thin and slightly crispy crust, and they even serve it with freshly grated cheese on top.

Last year, they went above and beyond for my birthday by delivering a "happy birthday" pizza to me.

It was such a special and memorable experience, and it's something that no other pizza place has done for me.

Final Thoughts

I have had the pleasure of dining at many of these amazing restaurants in Sebring, and I can personally vouch for the quality and taste that each one offers.

From the exquisite flavors of Argana Café's Moroccan and Caribbean fusion to the delicious vegan dishes at Green Leaf Vegan Kitchen, there's something for every palate in our charming town.

So, the next time you find yourself craving a great meal, don't hesitate to explore these fantastic dining options right here in our lovely community. Bon appétit!

💌

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.

✍️

Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.