16 Best Restaurants in Raymond, NH

Paul MacKoul

Aug 19, 2023 • 18 min read

In the humble town of Raymond, New Hampshire, where I've spent countless sunrises and sunsets, there is a culinary scene just waiting to be discovered.

It's not uncommon to find me reveling in the sublime tastes and textures offered by the local eateries.

Experiencing the local cuisine in Raymond is like a comforting journey home, where each bite is not just satiating but also nostalgic, taking me back to fond memories of cherished moments.

This charming small town, nestled between sparkling rivers and verdant forests, has managed to master the perfect blend of rustic charm and gourmet excellence.

So, let me take you on a gastronomic journey through the best restaurant in Raymond, New Hampshire, as we explore the hidden gems and local favorites that make this town's culinary scene truly unique.

🌟

About this article: This article was written by a local contributor based on their own experiences and those around them. While this list showcases some remarkable restaurants, it's important to note that this is an opinion piece, and there are many other exceptional dining establishments that are not featured here.
Our aim is not just to guide you to popular eateries but to encourage you to venture out and experience the city's diverse culinary landscape for yourself

Tuckaway Tavern and Butchery

I will never forget the first time I set foot inside the Tuckaway Tavern and Butchery.

A friend had raved about this rustic bar & grill, and I decided to see what the buzz was about.

Right off the bat, I was intrigued by their website, which boasted of updated pub grub, craft beers, and a gourmet meat & food market.

Walking in, it was crowded.

But the bustling atmosphere only added to the charm.

I put my name on the waitlist and decided to take a leisurely stroll around the vicinity while waiting for my table.

After all, good things come to those who wait, right?

Finally seated, the noise level was high, but that's to be expected when you're in a place that's loved by so many.

The aroma of sizzling meat wafting through the air was enough to make my mouth water.

The menu was vast, and the portion sizes were beyond generous.

Trust me, the Mac and cheese could easily feed a family of four.

The steak tips and dirty birds (chicken wings) were the stars of the evening.

The meat was so tender, so full of flavor; it was like tasting heaven with each bite.

And the biscuits!

They were a delightful surprise - fluffy and warm, as I like them.

And here's a tip: don't bother saving space for dessert because you'll barely be able to finish your main course.

Not that I'm complaining - I gladly took the leftovers home for a hearty next-day lunch.

In the end, it's not just about the food at Tuckaway Tavern and Butchery.

It's what keeps me coming back time and again.

Pizza By George

If you're craving a piece of heaven on earth, search no further.

I stumbled upon this culinary treasure known as Pizza By George, and it was love at first bite.

The moment I stepped foot into the Pizza By George in New Hampshire, I was greeted with the enticing aroma of bubbling cheese, sizzling meat, and that unmistakable scent of freshly-baked dough.

The ambiance was quintessential of a classic pizza place - bright, simple, and adorned just enough to let the food take center stage.

Now let's talk about the star of the show - the pizza.

For the record, this isn't just any pizza; it's a gastronomic experience.

The crust is perfectly thin yet sturdy enough to hold generous amounts of rich, gooey cheese and a myriad of toppings.

The flavors were bold, and every bite was packed with deliciousness.

And the best part?

They don't skimp on the portions.

A slice from Pizza By George is a meal in itself, making it worth every penny.

While the pizza is undoubtedly the showstopper, I must mention the other gems on their menu.

I once tried their steak and cheese sub, and oh boy, was I in for a treat!

China One

One bite at China One, and it's like being transported straight to the heart of Beijing.

Nestled in the heart of New Hampshire, this little gem serves up some of the most authentic and delightful Chinese cuisine I've ever tasted.

The chicken fingers here are legendary - the breading, thin and crispy, accentuates the meat within, and the accompanying duck sauce is perfectly balanced to complement the chicken.

It's a textural and flavor-filled symphony I haven't found anywhere else.

However, the interior could use a bit of sprucing up.

It's a bit run down, and pest control is certainly a need.

Now, you might be wondering about their Hot and Sour soup, a Chinese staple.

Well, let's say it might not be for everyone.

Personally, I found the sweetness from the carrots a bit offputting in the otherwise bold and tangy soup.

But aside from that small hiccup, it's hard to deny the overall quality of the food here.

It's quickly prepared and served steaming hot.

And the folks running the place?

They're some of the friendliest and most welcoming people you'll ever meet.

Plus, they make sure the place is spotless.

Gordos Burritos and Tacos

Every now and then, when the craving for Mexican food hits, I swing by Gordos Burritos and Tacos.

It's the perfect place to grab a quick bite in an uber-casual setting.

Their ordering process is straightforward - place your order at the counter, and they'll swiftly deliver it to your table.

This place is a fiesta of flavors, with tasty food that's very reasonably priced.

Though their menu can be a tad confusing at first, you can pretty much customize your order to your liking, whether it's a taco, burrito, or quesadilla.

Now, if you're a hot sauce enthusiast like me, Gordos is paradise!

Imagine sampling from hundreds of bottles of hot sauce scattered everywhere.

It's a spicy playground and adds a fun twist to your dining experience.

As for the authenticity of their Mexican fare, it's not exactly traditional.

But that doesn't take away from the enjoyment of the food.

I've tried their quesadillas, burritos, and nachos, and they were pretty good.

Although the toppings on the nachos ended up at the bottom, which was a bit messy, and they didn't have plates available at the time.

Supreme House of Pizza and Teddy's Lounge

Let me take you on a little journey; nestled amid the bustling town is a place that holds dear to my heart - the Supreme House of Pizza and Teddy's Lounge.

Nothing could be more inviting on a lazy evening than the aroma of home-cooked meals emanating from this little corner.

The outside of the place might not do justice to what awaits you inside.

But trust me, once you step in, you're in for a treat.

One bite of their lasagna, and you know you're eating something special.

The layers of cheese and pasta cooked to perfection are a testament to the culinary skills at work here.

And let's not forget their cheese steak giro - a dish that's always generous with its portions and never disappoints.

The atmosphere is as warming as their food.

One might question a few negative reviews, but my multiple visits here have proven otherwise.

Perhaps, the only thing that might need addressing is the smell of cigarettes as some visitors have mentioned.

But, as habitués, we've always found our nook away from it, focusing more on the food and company.

To those who haven't yet crossed the threshold of Supreme House of Pizza and Teddy's Lounge, I'd say give it a try.

It's a charming little place where food and hospitality blend to offer a wholesome experience.

Nick's Place

Sometimes, life takes an unplanned turn, and you stumble upon a hidden gem.

That's exactly what happened when I discovered Nick's Place in Raymond.

It wasn't a planned visit, but I'm so glad I found this place.

From the moment I walked in, I felt like I had entered someone's home.

Trust me, the roast beef sandwich is a must-try!

It's massive, fresh, and just the perfect blend of flavors.

The fries are the perfect companion to the sandwich, and let's not forget about their signature dishes.

They certainly add a unique touch to the dining experience.

And the best part?

There's always plenty of parking, and the ambiance is well-lit, making it a fantastic spot for a family dinner or a gathering with friends.

Nick's Place also happens to be a place that keeps its promises.

I remember a day after a long hike; we promised our daughter lobster, and our usual spot was closed.

We decided to try out Nick's Place, which turned out to be a lifesaver.

They were not only quick but incredibly kind, tailoring her plate exactly as she wanted.

The team checked on us many times, which elevated our dining experience.

Did I mention the homemade cookies they offered my kids for dessert?

They were divine!

Everything here is fresh, delicious, and fairly priced.

GMS Pizza

There's nowhere else in town that I'd rather grab a pizza slice from than GMS Pizza.

Its mouthwatering food and cozy atmosphere make it the perfect spot to unwind after a long day.

My personal favorite?

Their jalapeño poppers burst with flavor and heat, perfectly balanced by their refreshing drinks.

The service is top-notch, always quick to deliver that perfect pizza pie to your doorstep.

Trust me, I've had my fair share of pizza joints, but none could top GMS Pizza.

It's the kind of place that’s small and inviting, bathed in warm, dim lighting that sets the mood for a relaxed dine-in experience.

You can chill out and watch some TV, absorbing the overall great atmosphere that GMS Pizza effortlessly possesses.

But let me tell you, that was the day I realized how much I valued the food at GMS Pizza.

It's a gem in our town that every other place can’t compete with.

Long Branch Restaurant

I'll admit it; I'm a regular at the Long Branch Restaurant.

It's a quaint little breakfast joint tucked away in our small town.

As soon as you walk through the door, you’re free to select your own seat—like you're coming home to your own dining room.

The food?

It's good, comforting, and fills your tummy.

I remember the first time I tried their breakfast sandwich—it was just the satisfying kind of okay you need on a slow Sunday morning.

And oh, their potatoes; they might look like they've been boiled and tossed on the grill, but they have this uniquely homey taste that's actually quite alluring once you get used to it.

Now, the atmosphere is an acquired taste—it's a conservative country kitch kind of place.

But it's certainly part of the charm.

And they don’t skimp on servings, either!

Portions are generous, which is perfect for those with a hearty appetite.

Louie's Pizza & Italian Grille

As soon as you walk into Louie's Pizza & Italian Grille, the enticing aroma of Italian cuisine hits you, and suddenly, you're transported straight to the rustic alleys of Naples.

The menu might not offer a world of options, but it boasts classic Italian dishes made with utmost perfection.

Their salads, despite having whopping slices of tomatoes that need a little slicin' and dicin', are quite flavorful.

And don't even get me started about when I asked for a salad sans onions and still found a few lurking in.

But hey, nobody's perfect, right?

The very mention of their steak sub makes my mouth water.

It's not your typical chunks of steak, but shredded meat, brimming with flavors.

Their quick service is a pleasant surprise, especially for a small, family-owned business.

It's that authentic "mom & pop" vibe that adds to the charm.

The prices here are pretty reasonable, and you get a bang for your buck.

They're welcoming, always smiling, and ready to assist you with your orders.

Now, if you're a fan of chicken parmesan like me, their sub is a must-try!

It's hands down the best I've ever tasted in the neighborhood.

Louie's Pizza & Italian Grille has a little something for everyone.

Their gluten-free pizza, with the crispiest crust and abundant toppings, is always a hit.

You can even build your own pizza, choosing from an array of delectable ingredients.

It's not just the food, but the whole atmosphere, with their cute decor and prompt service, that makes dining here a delightful experience.

And if you're still in two minds about dropping by, remember, a large pizza here can feed up to three people!

You can't possibly say no to that, can you?

The Cork N' Keg Grill

If there's one thing I've learned living in this town, it's to never judge a place by its exterior.

Take the Cork N' Keg Grill, for example.

Its unassuming exterior can easily be overlooked, but let me tell you - the moment you step inside, you're welcomed with a warm, cozy ambiance that instantly makes you feel at home.

But that's just the beginning of what this humble pub has to offer.

Every visit to The Cork N' Keg Grill is like embarking on an epicurean adventure.

Their American fare is simply mouthwatering.

The double-patty burgers are as juicy as they come, and the mac 'n' cheese is something else.

Creamy, cheesy, and cooked to perfection, it's worth every single calorie.

And if you're like my partner and me, you can share a meal and get the best of both worlds.

But it's not all about the food.

The Cork N' Keg Grill also happens to be a beer lover's paradise.

With a variety of craft beers on tap, there's always something new to try.

Whether you're an ale enthusiast, a lager lover, or a stout aficionado, you're bound to find a brew that tickles your fancy.

Friendly and accommodating, they let us bring our two dogs onto the patio.

They even went the extra mile and brought out water bowls for them - a gesture we greatly appreciated.

Other Restaurants Nearby

Charlie's Italian Pizzeria and Restaurant (Deerfield)

You know that feeling when you walk into a place, and it just feels like home?

That's what it's like stepping foot in Charlie's Italian Pizzeria and Restaurant.

Trust me; there's nothing like having a local eatery that brings a slice of Italy to our humble town.

The atmosphere in Charlie’s is a mix of warm familiarity and Italian flair, enveloped in a fresh newness.

The inviting interior is a huge upgrade from the old establishment, Yanni’s.

Not to mention, their House Special Pizza and Caesar salad are absolutely divine.

Don’t get me started on their top-notch takeout service!

Upon my second visit, I was slightly puzzled by the absence of a side-salad option with a meal.

Not to worry, the broccoli/zucchini mix that I chose instead was a delightful surprise.

Every bite was a testament to the love and care they put into their dishes.

Charlie's grand opening day was an unforgettable experience.

The food was beyond amazing.

The Steak tips were tender, juicy, and packed with flavors.

The Panzenella Salad, with shrimp grilled to perfection, homemade croutons, and pickled red onions drizzled with balsamic glaze, was a spectacle to behold and a delight to taste.

The Buffalo wings and the French bread pizza from the kids' menu were an instant hit with my son.

But it’s not only about the food at Charlie's.

The employees are genuinely friendly, checking on you throughout your meal, always with a smile on their faces.

One can't help but feel the great sense of community and warmth that exudes from every corner of this place.

This is the kind of place that caters to all tastes, even the most discerning palate.

The Taco Pizza and Fried Mushrooms?

Absolutely scrumptious!

They far surpassed any versions I tried at other restaurants.

Olde Post Restaurant (Chester)

Let me tell you about this little slice of breakfast heaven.

It is the Olde Post Restaurant, tucked away like a cherished secret and truly a pearl among breakfast eateries.

Every bite here never fails to impress, always hitting that sweet spot of perfection.

The size is modest, giving it a cozy vibe, and the wait times are surprisingly low, considering how popular this place has become among us locals.

A standout feature at Olde Post Restaurant is their homemade bread.

Fresh, fluffy, and worth every penny, it's an absolute must-have.

Beyond the bread, the pumpkin pancakes are a delight.

They come slightly crisp but just right, not burnt.

They serve a generous amount of butter, so if you're watching your calories, take note.

The coffee is fantastic, the perfect companion to any breakfast.

The entire space breathes a welcoming atmosphere.

The restaurant is thoughtfully set up, including a small fireplace that adds a lovely touch.

There's also a collection of local handmade goods available, representing the spirit of our community.

In terms of comfort, the seating is really accommodating, so even if you're nursing some aches and pains like I was one morning, you can still enjoy your meal.

G & P Pizzeria (Chester)

It was an ordinary Saturday night until I stumbled upon G & P Pizzeria in Chester.

Now, it's become my go-to spot for a generous serving of delectable cuisine.

In my humble opinion, everything on their menu is nothing short of fantastic, but their pizza?

Oh, their pizza is an edible masterpiece.

Speaking of masterpieces, I can't get enough of their Cobb Salad.

Now, you might be thinking, "A salad? Really?"

But trust me, their Cobb Salad is no ordinary green medley.

Each bite is a perfect blend of crunchy, creamy, tangy, and hearty, making it an absolute must-try!

But what makes G & P Pizzeria a standout for me isn't just the food, it's also the exceptional service.

Almost everyone in town knows Eric and Amanda by name.

Their welcoming smiles and attentive service are the cherries on top of an already perfect dining experience.

Fremont Pizzeria (Fremont)

The magic of a Friday night after a long, tiring week is not complete without a visit to my favorite dining spot, Fremont Pizzeria.

This family-run eatery is more than just a restaurant to me; it's a home away from home.

Their Prime Rib is a delicacy you can't afford to miss, especially on Fridays, as they might run out by Saturday.

I often end up ordering more than I can consume, but they are more than happy to pack a doggie bag for me, turning my Sunday lunch into another delightful affair.

Fremont Pizzeria is a place where even my little one feels welcomed.

Cellos Farmhouse Italian (Candia)

The sound of clinking glasses, light chatter, and the tantalizing aroma of authentic Italian cooking always welcomes me as I step into Cellos Farmhouse Italian.

This place has not only become my go-to for a sumptuous meal after a day on the golf course, but it has also turned into a family favorite, making it an integral part of our culinary routine.

The first thing that hits you when you open the menu is an array of traditional dishes, each sounding more appetizing than the last.

A word of advice - do make a reservation, especially if you're planning to visit during the weekend.

It's a popular spot in town and can get quite busy.

On my last visit, I started off with their escargot, a beautifully presented and delicious appetizer.

However, I did encounter a minor hiccup when our toasted bread was a bit too charred.

The main course was indeed a revelation.

The veal Parmigiano and veal piccatta, so tender and flavorful, were too much to finish in one sitting.

With the promise of leftovers, we concluded our meal, savoring every bit of the experience.

And let's not forget the cocktails and the wine, which were divine.

The wine list might not be extensive, but it does house some really good options.

We paired our dinner with a Cali farmhouse red, which perfectly complemented the flavors of our meal.

Don't miss the weekly deals; they're simply too good to pass up.

The Railpenny Tavern (Epping)

"A night out that feels like home!" that's the perfect way to describe my dining experience at The Railpenny Tavern.

I'll admit, the first impression of the small restaurant may not seem like much, but the atmosphere is warm and cozy - it's like dining at home but better.

The place is tastefully decorated, and the stunning cocktail menu is a bonus on top of their comforting food offerings.

My first encounter was nothing short of magical.

Now, I always look forward to them on all my visits.

The bill might be a bit much for some, but I assure you, it's money well spent.

The Beer Garden that they recently added outdoors is something that I look forward to trying.

It promises an evening of fun with drinks and live music.

Final Thoughts

The culinary landscape of Raymond, New Hampshire, has always been a source of delight.

From the mouth-watering, authentic Italian flavors at Charlie's Italian Pizzeria and Restaurant and Cello's Farmhouse Italian to the heavenly steaks at the Tuckaway Tavern and Butchery, there's something for every palette in this town.

Whether you're a fan of traditional American fare, exotic Asian cuisine, vibrant Mexican dishes, or classic Italian favorites, Raymond never fails to surprise and satisfy.

💌

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.

✍️

Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.