14 Best Restaurants in Rainsville, AL

Best Restaurants in Rainsville, AL

Living in Rainsville, Alabama, has given me the opportunity to explore a myriad of delicious food options.

From slow-cooked southern barbecue to mouthwatering desserts, our small city is a hidden gem of culinary delights.

So whether you're passing through or planning to stay awhile, prepare your taste buds for a flavorful journey through the best restaurants in Rainsville, Alabama!

About this article: This article was written by a local contributor based on their own experiences and those around them. While this list showcases some remarkable restaurants, it's important to note that this is an opinion piece, and there are many other exceptional dining establishments that are not featured here.
Our aim is not just to guide you to popular eateries but to encourage you to venture out and experience the city's diverse culinary landscape for yourself

50 Taters #2

Have you ever found yourself craving authentic Southern cuisine?

Look no further than 50 Taters #2 in our lovely city.

This charming establishment always seems to draw a crowd - a testament to its popularity amongst us locals.

There's no denying that the place can be busy, and the wait for food can sometimes be a bit long.

But good things take time, right?

Their extensive menu boasts a variety of hearty dishes.

However, one dish that truly stands out is the Daily Special of shrimp skewers.

The shrimp are seasoned to perfection and cooked just right; you won't even need any cocktail sauce.

And you get two sides to accompany your shrimp, all for a mere $11.10.

It's hard to beat that value anywhere else in the city.

50 Taters #2 · 770 Main St E, Rainsville, AL 35986, United States
★★★★★ · American restaurant

Toki Sushi Steakhouse

It was a typical Saturday afternoon when I decided to break away from my daily routine and treat myself to some delicious Asian cuisine.

I headed straight for Toki Sushi Steakhouse, one of the best sushi and hibachi places around.

As soon as I walked in, I was met with the warm, inviting ambiance that Toki is known for and service that is always friendly and efficient.

I ordered the Sushi Deluxe, and let me tell you; it was a decadent feast!

The rice was perfectly cooked, and the sushi vinegar brought out the right mix of flavors.

To top it all, the raw fish tasted so fresh; it felt like they'd just been caught.

His excellent service and genuine warmth made the meal even more enjoyable.

Despite the slight increase in prices—something they've had to do because of the pandemic, as mentioned on the entrance door—Toki Sushi Steakhouse remains a place where quality and value come together.

The sheer amount of high-quality sushi you get for the price is amazing, making every visit a delightful bargain.

Toki Sushi Steakhouse · 648 Main St W, Rainsville, AL 35986, United States
★★★★★ · Japanese restaurant

Kelly's Kitchen

There are many reasons why my friends and I have made Kelly's Kitchen our regular hangout spot.

The food, for starters, is nothing short of delicious.

It's the kind of home-style fare that makes you feel like you're digging into a fine Sunday dinner, regardless of what day of the week it might be.

Not to mention, the service is always top-notch.

I can't recall a time when I had to bother asking for a refill on my coffee.

And, oh, the peanut butter pie!

There's something about that delicious dessert that keeps calling me back for more.

It's a must-try if you ever find yourself in the area.

Kelly's Kitchen is also a wonderful place for group gatherings.

No gathering seems too large for them.

I've been part of many large groups that have been accommodated with ease and efficiency.

Its warm and welcoming atmosphere is also part of the charm.

I love seeing fellow locals, especially the older gentlemen, seated at a long table, deep in conversations, their laughter filling the air.

It reminds me of simpler times, echoing the camaraderie my father used to share with his group of friends.

Kelly’s Kitchen · 120 Main St W, Rainsville, AL 35986, United States
★★★★★ · American restaurant

Topher's Wings

Every once in a while, you stumble upon a place that touches your heart, and for me, that place is Topher's Wings.

It's not just about the food, but it's also about the memories created and the bonds formed within its walls.

My journey at Topher's started when I worked there.

Even though I had to leave the job due to personal reasons, my love for the place has not wavered.

The food at Topher's Wings is an absolute delight.

If you're a fan of wings, and I mean, who isn't, then this place is a must-visit.

The 10-piece traditional wings with hot and Jamaican jerk flavors have been my all-time favorites.

The combination of a little heat and a little sweetness will surely tantalize your taste buds.

And let's not forget the potato salad; it's just the perfect side dish.

Topher’s Wings · 72 Roy Sanderson Ave, Rainsville, AL 35986, United States
★★★★★ · Chicken wings restaurant

Katy's Katfish

Once you've tasted the mouthwatering dishes at Katy's Katfish, you'll understand why I have to talk about it.

The food is divine, and the service, impeccable.

The moment you place your order, your meal arrives within minutes, hot, fresh, and oh-so-delicious.

The catfish fillets, in particular, are a true testament to Southern cuisine.

The breading and seasonings strike the perfect balance, and the fish itself is cooked to perfection.

The accompanying sides, though simple, add a hearty touch to the meal.

All they need is a sprinkle of salt and pepper to bring out their natural flavors.

In addition to the catfish, I dare you not to drool over the Chicken livers and Hamburger Steak served with baked beans, coleslaw, and mashed potatoes.

Every bite is a full-bodied experience of Southern comfort food at its best.

However, I must mention that Katy's Katfish is probably due for a bit of a makeover.

The seating could use some re-upholstering, and the prices are a tad high, considering it's a simple lunch affair.

Katy’s Katfish · 1382 Main St E, Rainsville, AL 35986, United States
★★★★☆ · Seafood restaurant

Toros Cantina And Grill Rainsville

An evening at Toros Cantina And Grill is like taking a mini vacation to Mexico without leaving home.

It's not just a mere dinner; it's an experience.

From the moment you walk in, you feel the warmth of Mexican hospitality.

The ambiance is vibrant and friendly, and if you're lucky, you might even get to hear a serenade on a loved one's birthday!

Under the open sky on the patio, I often find myself surrounded by family, sharing stories and laughter over a delicious fare.

The Toros sampler is a must-have appetizer; it's our traditional way to kick off our meal.

Add a few drinks, including their unique Italian margarita, and the evening starts on a high note.

The extensive menu caters to everyone's palate.

They do the best Flautas and a chicken chimichanga that's hard to resist.

The steak and shrimp platter is a divine combination, and the carnitas are an explosion of flavors.

The poblanos with a side of Mexican sausage, though not listed on the menu, is a testament to their flexibility in catering to the customers' desires.

Each dish is cooked to perfection and seasoned just right; it's hard to choose a favorite.

Desserts are not to be overlooked either.

Flan, churros, or xango with ice cream, or just a simple bowl of ice cream, they've got it all.

Options go beyond vanilla; I highly recommend the moose tracks and mint chocolate chip.

The Pina Loca always brings a smile to my partner's face, and that in itself is a delight.

Toros Cantina And Grill Rainsville · 462 Main St E, Rainsville, AL 35986, United States
★★★★☆ · Mexican restaurant

Other Restaurants Nearby

Little River Burgers & Brews

Ever had that one burger that makes you pause for a moment and simply appreciate the explosion of flavors in your mouth?

Well, I have, and I found that at Little River Burgers & Brews.

This place is a veritable treasure tucked away in our modest city.

Their food will make your taste buds dance, particularly their seasoned fries.

It's something you wouldn't want to miss!

Situated conveniently on the corner, the burger joint is always a buzz with locals looking for a great meal.

You can sense the welcoming atmosphere the minute you step foot inside.

They don't only serve fantastic food but also accommodate furry friends.

I remember during one hot day, they didn't wait for me to ask but immediately brought out ice water for my dog.

A warm touch that I'll never forget.

I still remember the day I ordered their special mushroom burger.

It was a behemoth of a dish packed with flavors that did a tango on my tongue.

My partner, on the other hand, swears by their chicken nachos, although he does wish they had a bit more spice.

One notable aspect of Little River Burgers & Brews is their attentive service.

We usually take a seat at the bar and never once have our drinks run dry.

Little River Burgers & Brews · 203 Gault Ave S, Fort Payne, AL 35967, United States
★★★★★ · American restaurant

Sally’s Smokin Butt BBQ

Whenever I have a hankering for authentic, smoky BBQ, I always turn to Sally's Smokin Butt BBQ.

This charming little hotspot in Fort Payne may not look like much from the outside, but as with all good BBQ joints, it’s the mouthwatering food that counts.

My go-to order?

Sally’s Combo Plate with Ribs and Brisket.

The ribs, with their delectable smoky flavor, have always been a hit, but the brisket is my personal favorite.

Perfectly tender and seasoned, it’s a must-try for any meat lover.

The combo plate also comes with a side of Cole slaw and unique, sliced fried, baked potatoes, a delightful twist on the traditional side dish.

Of course, it’s not all about the food.

Sally’s Smokin Butt BBQ is a cozy, welcoming establishment.

It’s like stepping back in time, complete with a single restroom located outback that is always spotless.

After a long day, nothing beats the comforting taste of Sally’s BBQ.

My partner often opts for pulled pork, which is equally tantalizing.

We usually wrap up our meal with their famous banana pudding or a slice of lemon meringue pie, which never fails to impress.

Sally’s Smokin Butt BBQ · 2904 Gault Ave S, Fort Payne, AL 35967, United States
★★★★★ · Barbecue restaurant

Mi Ranchito

Every once in a while, in between the hustle and bustle of Northeast Alabama life, I find myself drawn to the warmth and comfort of Mi Ranchito.

It's not just a restaurant; it's an experience.

The moment I step in, I feel like I'm welcomed into a big, boisterous Mexican family.

Aydee, the heart and soul behind all the delicious dishes, along with her team, has a knack for pouring love into every bite.

Whether you're craving something traditional like Menudo, or just a good old taco, you can always count on top-notch quality at Mi Ranchito.

Not to mention, everything is homemade - right down to the tortilla chips.

The authenticity of the food makes this place stand out among all the Mexican restaurants in the area.

But what's a good meal without good service?

Mi Ranchito checks that box too.

Mi Ranchito · 1815 Gault Ave N, Fort Payne, AL 35967, United States
★★★★★ · Mexican restaurant

Roadside 'Que

When it comes to a place that truly hits the spot after a long day, nothing compares to the homely charm and mouthwatering flavors of Roadside 'Que.

It's almost as if you can smell the tantalizing aroma of the barbecue the moment you step foot in Fort Payne.

This cozy little gem offers a menu that's filled with a variety of traditional BBQ dishes and some unique side options to boot.

The first bite of their German potato salad is a revelation - an interesting blend of flavors that I hadn't experienced before.

Now, it's become a regular part of my order, right alongside their delicious brussels sprouts.

Their method of slicing, then chopping the brisket was new to me, and while initially skeptical, I must admit it only adds to the delightful taste experience.

The brisket sandwich with a side and a drink, lovingly prepared by the friendly guy behind the counter, is a must-try.

Their Alabama white sauce is my go-to choice that adds an extra zing to the already delectable brisket.

But what really steals the show is their Mac and cheese.

It's hands-down one of the finest versions I've tasted in the city.

But the charm of Roadside 'Que is not just in the food.

It's a small operation, giving off a family-friendly vibe that makes you feel right at home.

On any given day, you'll find patrons of all ages relaxing, indulging in board games, coloring, or even a round of ping pong or foosball.

Roadside ’Que · 607 Gault Ave N suite a, Fort Payne, AL 35967, United States
★★★★★ · Barbecue restaurant

Vintage 1889

You know that feeling when you stumble upon a hidden gem in your very own neighborhood?

That's what it feels like every time you walk into Vintage 1889.

This place is where history meets culinary delight, where the rustic charm of an old sock factory coalesces with the buzz of a bustling dining hall.

The moment you step in, you're transported back to the bygone era of the 1800s.

The old-world charm of the place is simply captivating.

My favorite time to visit is during lunch.

The place is alive with a hum of conversations and clinking cutlery, but it's not too crowded, giving you a chance to soak in the ambiance.

The old machines, still with threads in them, stand as a testimony to the history of the place, and it's fascinating to explore them.

The menu is an adventurous mix of traditional and innovative dishes.

Not for the faint of heart is 'The Jesse', a unique take on a hamburger that comes with donuts.

Might sound unusual, but once you've had a bite, there's no going back.

It's a sweet and savory delight that leaves you craving for more.

Friday and Saturday nights are when the place really comes alive.

The local band 'The Locals' set the stage on fire with their amazing performances, playing anything from Nirvana to Hank.

It's a great place to socialize, catch up with friends, or sit back and enjoy the music.

Vintage 1889 · 151 8th St NE, Fort Payne, AL 35967, United States
★★★★☆ · Restaurant

Mi Casita

When it comes to authentic Mexican cuisine, no place does it better than Mi Casita Mexican Restaurant.

The moment I walk into the restaurant, the aroma of hot, fresh food whisks me away to the vibrant streets of Mexico.

The place is immaculately clean, both inside and out, making it a pleasant spot for a family meal or a catch-up with friends.

They have a knack for making you feel at ease, even if you're part of a large group.

My friends and I love coming here because they manage to cater to our large group with ease, and the service is always prompt.

We never have to face the predicament of incorrect orders; everything is served just as we ask for it every single time.

What I love about Mi Casita is that the food is a showstopper.

Every bite tugs at my taste buds, and the flavors linger long after the meal is over.

One of my personal favorites is their peach Margaritas.

This refreshing concoction is a must-try, especially during warm summer evenings.

Mi Casita Mexican Restaurant · 3802 Gault Ave N, Fort Payne, AL 35967, United States
★★★★☆ · Mexican restaurant

Osaka Sushi & Steakhouse

Feeling the weight of a long week, a Friday night at the Osaka Sushi & Steakhouse is just the remedy I often crave for.

Tucked away in our city, this intimate spot is the perfect setting for a quiet dinner after a busy day.

Pulling up a chair at Osaka's never requires a wait, a luxury I've come to appreciate as a regular.

The last visit was particularly memorable.

The king crab roll was my choice for the night.

The delicious flavors mingled with just a hint of spice, a combination that left me craving more.

A must-try is the hibachi chicken.

The generous serving is packed with rich flavor that seeps through every bite.

The speedy service ensures that the food arrives hot and fresh, making the dining experience all the more enjoyable.

Osaka sushi & steakhouse · 301 Ruby Tuesday Ln, Fort Payne, AL 35967, United States
★★★★★ · Japanese restaurant

Los Arcos

There's something truly special about finding an authentic Mexican restaurant nestled right in the heart of your city.

You've heard the buzz, now let me share a little secret with you - Los Arcos, near Walmart off Highway 59, is more than just a restaurant; it's an experience.

Step inside, and you are instantly drawn to the intricate artwork that dots the restaurant.

The furniture is adorned with carvings that transport you straight to the streets of Mexico.

The ambiance is warm, inviting, and family-friendly.

It's the perfect backdrop for a meal that's going to satiate your hunger and delight your senses.

My go-to order here is a simple yet flavorful dish that adheres to my gluten allergy.

What sets Los Arcos apart is their attention to detail.

They even offer horchata - a traditional Mexican drink.

It's a testament to their authenticity and a definite treat for the taste buds.

The drinks here are not just good; they're exceptional.

If you're not into Mexican food, worry not!

Los Arcos has got you covered.

Try their beef and cheese dipping stuff with free chips - a unique twist on your regular cheeseburger.

If you're a fan of quesadillas, rejoice – they make some of the best in the city.

Casual tourists, hungry travelers, and locals alike – Los Arcos offers a delicious slice of Mexico right in the middle of our city.

Los Arcos · 3533, 1827 Glenn Blvd SW, Fort Payne, AL 35968, United States
★★★★☆ · Mexican restaurant

Final Thoughts

There's a delightful variety of restaurants in Rainsville, Alabama, to satisfy any palate.

From the juicy, handcrafted burgers at Little River Burgers & Brews to the authentic Mexican dishes at Mi Ranchito and Mi Casita.

Rainsville is a small city with big flavors, each restaurant offering its own unique, delicious experience.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, the dining scene in Rainsville, Alabama, is definitely worth exploring.

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.