15 Best Restaurants in Perth Amboy, NJ

Best Restaurants in Perth Amboy, NJ

In this article, we'll embark on a culinary journey, exploring the hidden gastronomic gems.

Get ready to discover some of the best restaurants that Perth Amboy has to offer.

How this article was written: Our team first analyzed the scores and feedback across major platforms like Google Maps, Yelp, and Trip Advisor, considering not only the ratings but also the consistency of positive feedback. Following this, we conducted interviews with over 30 local residents who have been to these restaurants to gather authentic, first-hand experiences. You can read more about our research process here.

While this list showcases some remarkable restaurants, it's important to note there are many other exceptional dining establishments in Perth Amboy that are not featured here. Our aim is not just to guide you to popular eateries but to encourage you to venture out and experience the city's diverse culinary landscape for yourself.

Quick Stop Deli

You know, some places in town seem to fit into your routine seamlessly, becoming an essential part of your life.

Quick Stop Deli is like that for me.

It's this unassuming spot that carries a certain charm, the kind that keeps pulling me back.

Sounds cheesy, I know, but let me walk you through why it has such a special place in my routine.

Visiting Quick Stop Deli twice a week has been my ritual for years.

Every time I walk in, it's like being greeted by old friends.

The staff is amiable, always welcoming me with warm smiles.

In a world that runs on fast-paced interactions, this small gesture of camaraderie truly makes a difference.

But what fuels my love for this place is the food; freshness is a non-negotiable here.

Whether it's their new Asiago bagel or the Taylor ham egg and cheese on a roll, each bite is delicious.

Speaking of which, their breakfast is something I'd recommend without a second thought.

You'd think that a quick meal might be heavy or greasy, but it's quite the opposite here.

The eggs are cooked to perfection, the rolls are always fresh, and let's not get started on the coffee - even in the afternoon, it's warm, strong, and fresh.

What's not to love about a spotless deli with its own parking space right in the perfect location?

I'm eagerly looking forward to trying some of their more notorious sandwiches soon.

A place like Quick Stop Deli, with its excellent food, friendly staff, and clean premises, makes me love my city even more.

Quick Stop Deli · 814 Amboy Ave, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
★★★★★ · Deli

Margarita's Deli

Every visit to Margarita's Deli feels like a mini-vacation.

The warm and professional staff greets me when I enter the door, and I'm welcomed into a clean and aesthetically pleasing environment.

You can feel the energy in the air, a testament to the hard work they've put into turning this place around after a change in ownership in late 2019.

Starting my day with their breakfast sandwiches is a sublime experience.

The charm of eating a sandwich with real home fries, peppers, onions, and spices is unmatched against the backdrop of a well-maintained and cozy dining area.

Their commitment to quality is evident from their fresh juices and fruit smoothies; a drink from their exceptional juice bar is a must-try.

Finding a place that fosters such a positive atmosphere while turning out delicious food is rare.

Their business hours are incredibly convenient; they are open from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m., perfect for my early bird lifestyle.

The fact that they now accept credit cards with a $10 minimum order is another plus, adding to the convenience factor.

Visiting Margarita's Deli isn't just about grabbing a quick bite but immersing yourself in a delightful culinary experience.

This deli has carved a special place in the city, and each visit solidifies my decision to come back and try more of their delectable menu items.

Margarita’s Deli · 591 New Brunswick Ave, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
★★★★★ · Deli

Andares Bistro Restaurant

"Isn't food the best way to dive into a culture?" I often ponder while exploring the local eateries of my town.

I stumbled upon a hidden gem, Andares Bistro Restaurant, on one such escapade.

Nestled in our city, this quaint bistro has quickly become one of my favorite spots to savor authentic Spanish dishes and fast food favorites.

From the first visit, the warmth of the staff and the homely ambiance stole my heart.

I ordered Chicken Soup and Mofongo with Chicharrón during my first meal.

Each spoonful was a burst of flavors, perfectly seasoned, making me yearn for more.

The memory of that delightful meal still lingers, making me return to Andares repeatedly.

But it's not just about Spanish dishes! They also serve some of the best fast food in town.

The fried chicken is unlike any I’ve tasted before, and their burger is, hands down, my personal favorite.

The variety on the menu is impressive, catering to different tastes and preferences.

A unique addition at Andares Bistro is their freshly made fruit juice.

You can have it either on the rocks or frozen.

The freshness and the natural sweetness of the fruits heighten the dining experience, making it more enjoyable.

And the cherry on top? The prices are reasonable, and the service is fantastic.

When I was in a hurry, I ordered Chimis and Empanadas, which were served quickly.

Everything was delicious, and the staff was so kind and efficient.

If you want to experience the local food scene, I highly recommend visiting Andares Bistro Restaurant.

It's a gastronomic journey you won't regret.

Andares Bistro Restaurant · 109 Smith St, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Don Miguelon

I wish I could bottle up the warmth I felt when I walked into Don Miguelon, a local gem tucked away in my city.

Their customer service is stellar, exhibiting a unique blend of professionalism and friendliness that instantly makes you feel at home.

I remember going there with a friend, with the sole intention of having a coffee.

But oh boy! The way they brewed it to our liking made us feel special.

The place was spick-and-span, and aesthetically pleasing, and the food, well, it's like a symphony of flavors playing in your mouth.

Meanwhile, the beef stew was a culinary masterpiece, and the baked chicken was, to put it mildly, an absolute delight.

The charm of Don Miguelon lies not just in the delicious food they serve but also in how they treat their customers.

It's like being welcomed into a big, happy family.

The taste of the 'asopao de camarones' and 'tostones con chicarrón de puerco' still lingers in my mouth, making me yearn for more.

I can't wait for another visit to this fantastic place.

Don Miguelon · 587 Fayette St, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

La Hacienda Restaurant

Ever have one of those days where all you crave is an authentic Mexican feast?

I experienced that very craving last weekend, and as usual, La Hacienda Restaurant in Perth Amboy didn't disappoint.

The welcoming staff made me feel like I was home from the moment I walked in.

They have this innate ability to make you feel more like a house guest than a customer - a warm and inviting atmosphere that marks a great restaurant.

And let me tell you, the food here is just as remarkable.

The birria tacos are an absolute must-try. Their flavors are so rich and authentic that it's like a little trip to Mexico without leaving New Jersey.

I remember walking in on a quiet Sunday evening after a long week, anticipating my favorite meal.

I was greeted with complimentary nachos.

Yes, you read that right--complimentary nachos.

Those little details make a big difference, the kind of thoughtful service that keeps you coming back.

Everything you order here is served with a reasonable price tag, making it a haven for Mexican cuisine lovers like me who love good food without breaking the bank.

Now, if you're wondering about trying something different - go for the birria burrito.

It's a flavorful rollercoaster ride you won't forget.

Whether you're looking for a casual dinner or a feast with friends, look no further than La Hacienda.

It's a hidden gem that makes the everyday extraordinary.

You won't want to get your Mexican fix anywhere else once you visit.

La Hacienda Restaurant · 178 New Brunswick Ave, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
★★★★★ · Mexican restaurant

Milanos Pizzeria

Let me tell you, there's nothing like finding a restaurant that feels like home, and for me, that's Milanos Pizzeria.

Have you ever been there?

Settled comfortably in our city, it's the place that effortlessly serves up the best pizza in town.

One day, my partner and I were out for a stroll, and we stumbled upon this gem.

The tantalizing aroma of baking pizza lured us in, and we've been regulars ever since.

With their quick service and friendly owners, it's not just the pizza that keeps us coming back, but the warm atmosphere makes us feel like we're part of the family.

Just yesterday, I was in the area and decided to grab their lunch special - two mouth-watering slices of plain pizza coupled with a refreshing can of soda, all for just $5.

My friends' pizza is a pure delight to the senses - the crunch of the crust, the perfect blend of cheese and sauce.

It was so good that I couldn't resist picking up a pizza for my family on my way home today.

So, if you’re looking for a slice of heaven, you know where to go.

Milanos Pizzeria · 687 Florida Grove Rd, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
★★★★★ · Pizza restaurant

Cheo's Kitchen

Do you know that sort of place in town where the word 'delicious' doesn't seem to cut it?

Welcome to my world - the world of Cheo's Kitchen.

Every bite you take here is an experience; every milkshake you slurp is a delight.

Take it from me. The Sapodilla milkshake is an indulgence that hits differently.

It's sweet, creamy, and unlike any other milkshake you've ever tasted.

And don't get me started on the yaroa.

It's a dish that steals your heart from the first bite.

But that's not all.

The Mango natural Juice and chicken Burrito are delicious, leaving you craving more.

Sure, they might be a tad slow on service, but when you taste the food, you'll agree with me—it's well worth the wait.

What got me hooked, though, is their pastelillo.

Imagine beef, cheese, chicken, egg, or pizza stuffed into a big, crispy pastelillo.

You'd think you're getting a small empty empanada for $1.


These pastelillos are big, stuffed, and oh-so-tasty. It's irresistibly good.

I could keep gushing about the food, freshness, atmosphere, and fair pricing.

But I'll let you experience it for yourself.

So, wander over to Cheo's Kitchen next time you find yourself in town.

I'm sure you'll thank me later.

Cheo’s Kitchen · 129 Fayette St, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
★★★★★ · Latin American restaurant

Paone Pizzeria Restaurant

Something about the aroma of freshly baked dough and melting cheese pulls you in.

For me, that's the allure of Paone Pizzeria Restaurant, nestled in our city.

If you're looking for a place where the pizza slices are almost as large as your face, and the taste makes you feel like you're in a quaint town in Italy, this is the spot for you.

But let me tell you, the size and taste aren't the only things this pizzeria has to offer.

Paone Pizzeria Restaurant is a place you shouldn't miss out on.

Every visit to this pizza joint feels like a mini vacation to Italy.

It's a slice of heaven right in our city.

Paone Pizzeria Restaurant · 555 Amboy Ave, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
★★★★★ · Pizza restaurant

Torres Cafe and Catering

There's a hidden culinary gem on our doorstep that you might not have discovered yet if you haven't been scouring TikTok.

Torres Cafe and Catering, a Puerto Rican eatery in the heart of Perth Amboy, is an absolute delight for foodies like me.

The first time I set foot in Torres Cafe, I was drawn in by the enticing aroma wafting through the air.

Isn't it wonderful when you can tell how good the food will be just by the smell?

I decided to give the pernil and rice a go, and saying it was incredible would be an understatement.

The place has a great vibe too.

The atmosphere is warm and inviting, just like you would expect from a family-owned establishment.

Plus, the prices won't break the bank, making it a win-win situation.

The real crowd-puller, though, is their incredible Puerto Rican fare.

If you're in Perth Amboy, Torres Cafe should be on your must-visit list for delectable picaderas and other Puerto Rican dishes.

The flavors are bold and well-seasoned, a testament to the authenticity of their food.

If you plan to visit during lunch, be prepared for a line.

However, don't let that deter you.

The line moves quickly, and the food is always served piping hot.

On one occasion, I was so impressed with my meal I ordered extra to take home.

Next time you're looking for a place to eat in Perth Amboy, don't just drive by Torres Cafe and Catering.

Stop in, grab a bite, and prepare to be wowed.

Torres Cafe and Catering · 431 High St, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
★★★★★ · Puerto Rican restaurant

Nereida’s Restaurant

There's nothing like discovering a hidden gem in your city.

One such secret culinary treasure is Nereida’s Restaurant.

It's been my go-to place for authentic Caribbean food for years.

I'll tell you a secret: you need to know Spanish and Caribbean cuisine as there is no menu.

But isn't that half the fun?

Though unassuming from the outside, the place is known for its fresh, flavorful dishes.

Nothing beats their chicharrones con yuca.

It's the best in town, hands down.

The chicharron is a work of art - the pork is perfectly cooked to a crisp yet retains its tender juiciness.

My family and I savor the contrast of textures, flavor, and crunch with tortillas and spicy salsa.

And the chicharron tacos are an absolute must-try!

Over time, Nereida's has gotten busier, attracting more than just the locals.

I guess the secret is out, but that's okay.

More people should experience this remarkable place because it's worth it.

So, if you're in the mood for authentic, hearty Caribbean cuisine, you know where to go.

Nereida’s Restaurant · 177 Patterson St, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
★★★★★ · Latin American restaurant

Casa De Cabo

Something about the familiar taste of homemade Dominican food warms my heart.

I was lucky to find this comfort at Casa De Cabo, a local restaurant that serves delightful Dominican cuisine.

The service is impeccable.

It was a place where I could feel the warmth of my homeland in every bite.

I would recommend this place to anyone looking for a taste of excellent Dominican food served with a side of great customer service.

Even now, I'm already looking forward to my next visit.

Casa De Cabo · 319 Goodwin St, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Jennifer Lounge Restaurant

It was late Saturday night when I found myself craving authentic Spanish cuisine.

A friend had recommended Jennifer Lounge Restaurant in the heart of our town.

I decided to try it, and boy, was it worth it!

The chicken was seasoned beautifully - juicy, succulent, and flavorful - while the rice was perfectly cooked, and the tostones were crispy how I liked them.

Plus, the portions were more than generous.

And when I say generous, you'll be eating leftovers for breakfast!

In a nutshell, Jennifer Lounge Restaurant is a hidden gem in our town.

Whether you're a fan of Spanish cuisine or looking for something different to tickle your taste buds, I highly recommend trying this place.

And if you're worried about the wait, trust me, every minute is worth it when you take that first bite.

Jennifer Lounge Restaurant · 555 Penn St, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
★★★★★ · Bar & grill

Other Restaurants Nearby

Surrender Cafe (Woodbridge Township)

Sometimes, you don't need a plane ticket to experience the vibrant flavors of Puerto Rico.

All you need is a trip to Surrender Cafe, a bright and inviting spot in the city's heart, serving some of the most delicious Puerto Rican dishes you'll ever taste.

My friends and I happened to be in the city one afternoon and decided to grab a bite.

As Puerto Rican women, we craved some familiar flavors, and Surrender Cafe didn't disappoint.

We started with appetizers - sorullitos and order of alcapurrias, a traditional fried dish that brought back memories of my grandma's kitchen.

The dip that came with it was beyond amazing. My boyfriend, usually a picky eater, couldn't get enough of it!

However, the star of the day was the pernil with rice and beans that I had for my main course.

The pork was cooked to perfection, tender and flavorful, while the rice and beans complimented the dish perfectly, and the side salad with a cilantro dressing was the cherry on top.

Every mouthful was a taste of Puerto Rico, a celebration of Latin flavors.

Surrender Cafe is more than just a restaurant. It's a culinary experience.

The inviting ambiance and the delicious food make it a regular dinner spot for us.

I encourage everyone in town to try it – you won't be disappointed!

Surrender Cafe · 691 Amboy Ave, Woodbridge Township, NJ 07095, United States
★★★★★ · Puerto Rican restaurant

Reggiano's Brick Oven Pizza (Staten Island)

Dine at Reggiano's Brick Oven Pizza.

There's a magic about this place that only locals genuinely understand.

Nestled on Staten Island's corners, it's where Italian classics, heroes, and wood-fired pizzas come alive.

My first encounter with Reggiano's was during a casual Friday evening stroll.

The inviting aroma of wood-fired pizza wafted through the air, guiding me straight to their cozy patio.

I've been a regular ever since.

Their menu is a treasure trove of classic Italian dishes, tantalizing the taste buds and leaving you craving more.

Among their bestsellers, the steak in mushroom and onions is an absolute delight.

The Father's Day package number 2 has also become a family favorite, especially when paired with a half Chicken Parm and a half tray of their ribs.

And let's not forget their shrimp parmesan - it's an absolute treat for seafood lovers like me.

But what sets Reggiano's apart is the red sauce.

It's hard to describe, but it's like they've bottled up the essence of Italy in it - rich, robust, and bursting with flavors.

Paired with their light and crispy calamari, it's a symphony of taste that transports you straight to the heart of Rome.

Even their hot wings, which could do with a bit more kick, become a culinary delight when dunked in this heavenly sauce.

Drop by Reggiano's Brick Oven Pizza the next time you're in the city and had a long day.

It's more than just a restaurant; it's a warm hug, a comforting pat on the back, a taste of home.

Reggiano’s Brick Oven Pizza · 7339 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10307, United States
★★★★★ · Pizza restaurant

Dani's Italian Bistro (Staten Island)

Believe me when I say there's nothing quite as memorable as a night out at Dani's Italian Bistro.

This intimate, family-owned gem nestled in the heart of Staten Island is where you'll find authentic Italian cuisine crafted with the kind of love and meticulous attention only a chef-owner can provide.

The moment you step foot in Dani's, you’re greeted by the warm, intimate atmosphere that makes it an ideal spot for a romantic date or an exceptional Italian meal.

I remember starting with the Mozzarella en Carrozza appetizer - lightly breaded, fried mozzarella with a good sauce. I found myself scraping up every last bit of it.

One of the standout dishes I've had the pleasure of devouring was one of their dinner specials - striped bass served over a broccoli rabe risotto, all drenched in an irresistible marinara sauce.

Let me tell you, the fish was cooked to perfection, and the portion size was generous.

Every bite was a delightful fusion of flavors, a testament to the chef's skills and dedication.

Their dessert offerings are not to be missed either.

Their house-made apple crumb cheesecake is the stuff of dreams - a perfect ending to a delightful meal.

To top it all off, the prices are surprisingly affordable.

Would you believe that the sumptuous striped bass was a mere $29?

I also noticed a great selection of filet mignons priced at just $31, which I plan on trying during my next visit.

The service at Dani's is excellent, with attentive, down-to-earth staff and warm, welcoming owners that make you feel right at home.

So, if you're in the area and looking for a quiet place to enjoy quality food and exceptional service, book a table at Dani's Italian Bistro.

Trust me. It's worth it.

Dani’s Italian Bistro · 7331 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10307, United States
★★★★★ · Italian restaurant

Final Thoughts

Living in Perth Amboy, NJ, has allowed me to explore an array of culinary delights.

Each of these eateries has its charm, contributing to the rich dining scene we are proud of in Perth Amboy.

I'm sure that, as I continue to explore, I'll keep finding new favorites and unexpected culinary gems.

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.