20 Best Restaurants in Pauls Valley, OK

20 Best Restaurants in Pauls Valley, OK

Living in Pauls Valley, I can assure you that this city in Oklahoma boasts a hearty culinary scene that would impress any food lover.

Here, the nostalgic charm of hometown diners meets the adventurous spirit of global cuisine, offering an eclectic blend of flavors and dishes.

From morning coffee stops to late-night ice cream cravings, there's a profusion of locally owned eateries that have perfected their offerings.

My personal journey through Pauls Valley's palate-pleasing scene has taken me to numerous eateries, each one with a unique story to tell through their food.

This compelling fusion of taste and culture is what this humble city's gastronomic landscape is all about.

So, whether you're a curious out-of-towner or a seasoned local, join me as I take you on a delectable tour of the best restaurants in Pauls Valley, Oklahoma.

About this article: This article was written by a local contributor based on their own experiences and those around them. While this list showcases some remarkable restaurants, it's important to note that this is an opinion piece, and there are many other exceptional dining establishments that are not featured here.
Our aim is not just to guide you to popular eateries but to encourage you to venture out and experience the city's diverse culinary landscape for yourself

Community Cafe

I still remember the first time I stepped foot into the Community Cafe.

My heart was warmly greeted by the smell of home cooked food wafting through the air.

The entire place had a charming, homely ambiance that made me feel instantly at ease.

My partner and I decided to venture into the menu.

It was an experience in itself, with each dish sounding more appetizing than the last.

I opted for a classic breakfast dish, complete with ham and toast, while my partner couldn't resist trying the 'Outhouse Omelet'.

Despite the name, the omelet was truly a culinary masterpiece, bursting with flavors that left us both in awe.

The freshness of the ingredients was evident in every bite.

It was clear that this wasn't your typical store-bought fare.

The passion and dedication that went into creating these meals was tangible, resulting in food that tasted as incredible as it looked.

The total cost of our meal was a mere $26, a surprising delight considering the high-quality fare.

We were also pleasantly surprised by the excellent customer service.

Community Cafe · 37309 OK-19, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★★ · Restaurant

El TAKON Madres

I remember the day I discovered  El TAKON Madres.

Searching for a culinary adventure, I wandered into the heart of Paul's Valley.

The menu is a love letter to traditional Mexican cuisine, with street-style tacos stealing the show.

The barbacoa street tacos are a revelation – a mélange of flavors that instantly transport you to the bustling streets of Mexico.

The street corn, an unexpected star, is a must-try too.

For those who crave more heat, their fiery red sauce adds the perfect kick.

However, it's not just the flavors that make this place special.

They have mastered the fine art of hospitality, ensuring that every customer's experience is a memorable one.

Even the most discerning palate occasionally finds a dish that could do with a bit more seasoning.

For me, it was the sizable chicken burrito, which I found slightly bland.

But that's the beauty of food, isn't it?

Our tastes and preferences are as diverse as we are.

Luckily, the red sauce came to the rescue, adding the right amount of spice that the burrito needed.

EL TAKON MADRES · 120 E Grant Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★★ · Mexicaans restaurant


There's nothing quite like the taste of authentic Salvadoran cuisine that you can enjoy right here in our city at Norma's.

Their pupusas are an absolute delight!

They've become my all-time favourite dish, with an authentic Salvadoran touch that takes me on a culinary journey with every bite.

I also tried their Salvadoran tamale, which was absolutely delicious.

Complementing the meal was their green salsa, carrying a good flavour and a tiny kick that perfectly ties everything together.

But Norma's doesn't just offer great food - it also provides a warm, welcoming environment.

The seating is comfortable and the service is always top-notch, making you feel right at home.

It's the perfect spot for a cozy family dinner or a fun evening with friends.

Not to mention, Norma’s Catering did a remarkable job catering my daughter’s wedding.

Their responsiveness, professionalism, and attention to detail were unmatched.

Norma’s · 200 W Charles Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★★ · Mexicaans restaurant

Valley Express Food & Burger

Crossing paths with the Valley Express Food & Burger is like finding a hidden gem in the heart of Pauls Valley.

My first impression was that it's incredibly convenient, especially if you need a quick snack on the go or last-minute groceries.

The store seems to have it all, from essential items to a surprising selection of snacks and treats.

But the real magic happens in their deli.

Quite frankly, it's the best one in the valley.

Every burger they serve is a culinary masterpiece, cooked to perfection and always fresh.

Valley Express Food & Burger · 302 E Grant Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★★ · Hamburgerrestaurant

The Grille in Pauls Valley

What better way to satisfy your hunger than on a plate of juicy steak and perfectly cooked salmon?

I've found my culinary haven at The Grille in Pauls Valley.

The place may look small from the outside, but once inside, you'll be amazed by its surprisingly spacious and cozy interior.

I still vividly remember my phenomenal experience there.

From their bacon cheese fries that tasted heaven-sent, to the salmon that was cooked to perfection, every dish seemed to tantalize my taste buds.

I must admit, the okra was a bit bland for me, but it wasn't a deal-breaker.

I'm still raving about the juicy steak that was seared to my liking!

The Grille is not just about the food, it's about the people too.

My kids were thrilled to find out that their menu was a free ticket to the local Toy and Action Figure Museum.

An eaterie with such delightful surprises is hard to come by these days.

It's also worth mentioning that their prices are fair, considering the generous portion sizes.

The Grille · 2602 W Grant Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Punkin's Bar-B-Que & Catfish

If there's one thing I've learned in my many years living here, it's that you haven't truly experienced Paul's Valley until you've dined at Punkin's Bar-B-Que & Catfish.

Upon entering, you're greeted by a welcoming, diner-like atmosphere that immediately puts you at ease.

During my many visits, I often gravitate towards the two-meat BBQ dinner which offers a generous serving of pulled pork and chopped brisket, accompanied by hand-cut French fries, fried okra and a slice of Texas toast.

The pulled pork is always the highlight of my plate, enthralling my taste buds with its flavors and tenderness.

If I were to nitpick, I'd say the chopped brisket could use a bit of improvement, as it sometimes leans on the greasier, mushier side.

But it doesn't spoil the overall experience, especially when paired with their thin, crispy fries that never fail to surprise me with their deliciousness.

Now, if you're feeling adventurous, their BBQ sandwich with house fried chips is another crowd pleaser.

The chopped brisket plays a starring role in this ensemble, adding a robust flavor that pairs wonderfully with the crispiness of the chips.

What sets Punkin's apart, however, is their flavorful sauces that perfectly complement the meats without overpowering them.

To elevate your meal further, they provide a relish bar with peppers, onions, and pickles.

Word to the wise: they only offer a small saucer-type plate for these condiments, and an extra plate will cost you $1.95.

But if you're anything like me, you'll pile it high and make every penny count.

And for the sweet tooth in all of us, they also have a variety of desserts on hand, including pies and cobblers.

Sadly, I've yet to try them, but it's high on my list for my next visit!

Punkin’s Bar-B-Que & Catfish · 1911 W Grant Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★☆ · Barbecuerestaurant

Mimi's Restaurant

The smell of sizzling bacon, the sight of perfectly cooked eggs, and the sound of cheerful chatter that greets you as you step into Mimi's Restaurant is enough to make your morning.

Nestled in the heart of downtown Paul's Valley, Mimi's feels like home.

The best way to start your day here has to be with Mimi's hearty breakfast.

Picture this: two eggs cooked over medium, four strips of crispy bacon, a generous serving of hash browns, and a couple of toasts, all prepared to perfection.

Just as you think you've had the best of it, a short stack of pancakes arrives at your table, a fitting sweet ending to your morning feast.

And trust me, the pancakes are a dessert you don't want to miss out on!

But the breakfast isn't the only thing that sets Mimi's apart.

Located just three miles east of I-35, Mimi's is one of the treasures of Pauls Valley that deserves to be discovered and cherished.

Fancy some comfort food for lunch?

Mimi's homemade biscuits and gravy with scrambled eggs is a local favorite.

However, you might want to get there early, as their biscuits are so popular they often run out!

And if you're a fan of chicken, like my mom, you'll love their chicken dishes, especially the salad with chicken.

So next time you're craving some good old comfort food or looking for a cozy place to enjoy a fulfilling breakfast or lunch, look no further.

Mimi’s Restaurant · 117 W Paul Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★☆ · Amerikaans restaurant

Green Tea Buffet

Who knew that a tiny place in our very own city would be a culinary heaven?

Ever since I discovered Green Tea Buffet, it has been a love affair with their food that we, as a family, look forward to every month.

The food is simply scrumptious.

There's a variety that caters to even the fussiest eater.

From the perfectly fried spring rolls to the succulent pork ribs, everything is a delight.

And if you're someone with a sweet tooth, they've got you covered as well with their desserts.

The quality is always top-notch, never had a bad day.

What makes Green Tea Buffet even more inviting is the warm and friendly management team.

They're always enthusiastic, ensuring we have the best dining experience.

They are attentive, hospitable, and make you feel at home.

But it's not just about the food.

It's the ambience, the energy that makes dining at Green Tea Buffet more than just a meal.

Green Tea Buffet · 2000 Grant Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★☆ · Restaurant

Bob’s Pig Shop

There's this place in city, Bob's Pig Shop, that's been around for as long as I can remember.

You know, one of those local joints that give the city its charm.

My go-to order?

The bbq brisket sandwich.

I've tried BBQ sandwiches at more places than I can count, but there's just something about Bob's that keeps me coming back.

The beans and brisket have a flavor that's just the right balance of smoky and sweet.

And let's not forget about the decor.

Surrounded by rustic, eclectic pieces, it's like stepping back in time to a simpler era.

And then there are the ribs.

Oh, the ribs.

They're fall-off-the-bone tender, and the sauce has a kick that leaves you wanting more.

Fridays are my favorite because that's when they serve the prime rib.

It's always cooked perfectly - tender, juicy, and flavorful.

If you've got room for dessert, do yourself a favor and get the blueberry cobbler.

It's a sweet, fruity delight that's the perfect ending to a hearty meal.

What I appreciate the most, though, is the warm and friendly service.

And the best part?

The prices are reasonable and you definitely get a good bang for your buck.

Bob’s Pig Shop · 829 N Ash St, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★☆ · Restaurant

El Pueblo

One can never predict where the road will lead, and in my case, it led to a charming little eatery named El Pueblo.

Nestled just off the Pauls Valley exit on I-35, it initially seemed like another pin on the map.

However, it turned out to be a dining experience unlike any other.

The simplicity and cleanliness of El Pueblo was a refreshing change.

Although we had to wait a bit for our chips and salsa, the delightfully tangy cheese sauce was well worth the wait.

El Pueblo · 2301 W Grant Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★☆ · Mexicaans restaurant

Riviera Maya Mexican Grill

My tastebuds have been on quite the journey at the Riviera Maya Mexican Grill.

In true Mexican style, the restaurant has an authentic charm to it - the unique table and chair design adding to the overall ambiance.

The customer service here never fails to impress, being both friendly and fast.

When it comes to their food, it’s a bit of a mixed bag.

I've had some great experiences - their cheese enchiladas, for instance, have an unconventional twist to them.

They taste as if they're made with sliced cheese - a flavor profile that certainly stands out, even if it doesn't appeal to everyone.

And while I've heard some folks grumble about canned beans being used, personally, I appreciate the rustic flavors they bring to the table.

Riviera Maya Mexican Grill · 2415 Grant Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★☆ · Mexicaans restaurant

Chong Wah Chinese Restaurant

What a night at the Chong Wah Chinese restaurant!

And not in a good way, I might add.

My craving for Chinese food led me down a path I wish I'd never taken.

If only I had listened to the warnings of my taste buds.

My journey began with a simple dinner combo.

I asked for a mixed soup - egg drop with wonton in it.

A simple request, I thought.

After all, they often go hand-in-hand in a Chinese restaurant.

But to my surprise, the answer was a flat 'no'.

I persisted, asking for pork fried rice to accompany my meal.

Again, the response was a 'no'.

I was willing to pay extra, but it seemed my request fell on deaf ears.

Then came the cashew chicken.

I had high hopes for this dish, but it was nothing short of a disaster!

The crab ragoon was a tragic comedy in itself - nothing but greasy fried empty wontons.

I left feeling more than just disappointed.

I handed over $30 for what was a $26 meal, told them to keep the change, and made a mental note to myself - never again.

I should have known better.

Chong Wah Chinese restaurant · 310 W Paul Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★☆ · Chinees restaurant

Tio's Mexican Restaurant and Cantina

Every once in a while, you come across a place that becomes a staple in your life.

For me, it's Tio's Mexican Restaurant and Cantina in our humble city.

Tio's is more than just a place to get your Mexican cuisine fix, it's a place where community meets good food.

I can't deny that their queso can be a bit hit or miss, sometimes it's a tad runny, but the rest of the menu more than makes up for it.

Personally, I am a fan of the enchiladas, which are generously stuffed and always served hot with a side of their homemade salsa that adds just the right kick.

Yet, I've heard vacationers rave about the delicious food they enjoyed on their way back from Arbuckle Wilderness.

From my experience, the best part about Tio's has always been its service.

It's this consistent dedication to service that makes Tio's a beloved pitstop for families on their day out.

Tio’s Mexican Restaurant and Cantina · OK-19 &, S Indian Meridian Rd, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★☆ · Mexicaans restaurant

Shell on West Grant Avenue

One of the charms of living in the area is the unexpected surprises that you find in the most mundane places.

I am talking about the Shell at 3001 W Grant Avenue.

I am a regular there, filling up my car almost every week.

I was pleasantly surprised to find that they have a small deli and even a Papa John's Pizza.

I'm a pizza lover and their pizzas are at par with any stand-alone Papa John's outlet.

And there's more to this Shell station.

They have a large dirt lot that accommodates about 20 trucks.

So, if you are a trucker, you won't have to worry about parking.

Shell · 3001 W Grant Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075, Verenigde Staten
★★★★☆ · Tankstation

Final Thoughts

There's a lot to savor in our vibrant city of Pauls Valley.

Whether you're in the mood for a hearty American-style breakfast at the Community Cafe or yearning for the mouthwatering barbeque at Punkin's, there's always a place to meet your cravings.

It's been delightful sharing my favorite dining spots with all of you, and I hope that your next meal in Pauls Valley is as fulfilling and enjoyable as mine have always been.

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.