20 Best Restaurants in Noblesville, IN
This article was written by local contributor Finlay Webb & edited by the Travel Lens team.
As someone who's lived in Noblesville for years, I've had the pleasure of dining at various restaurants in town.
Over time, I've discovered hidden gems, had memorable meals, and enjoyed countless conversations with fellow residents and visitors alike.
I'm excited to share with you some of my favorite spots to grab a bite in this charming Indiana town.
From classic comfort food to upscale dining, there's something for every palate and occasion in Noblesville.
So, join me on this gastronomic journey as we explore the best restaurants in Noblesville, Indiana!
9th Street Bistro
I can't say enough good things about 9th Street Bistro.
My spouse and I have dined here twice, and both times, we were blown away by the cozy atmosphere, impeccable service, and delicious, globally influenced-dishes.
On our most recent visit, we celebrated my birthday with a reserved table.
The food, as always, was beyond delightful. Every dish we tried was a hit, but the standout was definitely the burrata with orange honey, pistachio, and apricot.
It's a must-try, whether you enjoy it as an appetizer or dessert.
The crab bisque and risotto were also excellent, even if they were a bit different than expected in terms of texture.
One thing to keep in mind is that reservations are a must, as this intimate venue fills up quickly.
Zen Ramen & Sushi
I've been living in the area for quite some time now, and one of my favorite restaurants to frequent is Zen Ramen & Sushi.
I often go there with my partner, friends, or even alone to enjoy some delicious ramen and sushi.
The Miso vegan and chicken-rich ramen are some of our go-to dishes, along with the crab Rangoon as an appetizer.
What I love the most about Zen Ramen & Sushi is that they never fail to deliver flavor and quality.
The ramen options are always fantastic, and I heard they will be adding even more to their menu soon.
As for sushi, the Amazing Roll truly lives up to its name – it's so good that my best friend from Arkansas still dreams about it, even months after trying it for the first time.
The Nesst of Noblesville
I had been hearing a lot of great things about The Nesst of Noblesville and finally decided to give it a try.
Upon entering, I was immediately impressed by the crisp table linens and romantic candlelit ambiance.
I was thrilled to see traditional Balkan foods on the menu, and the cevapi did not disappoint!
The black truffle fries were absolutely amazing, and even my 5-year-old enjoyed the atmosphere of this "fancy" restaurant.
It was half-price bottle day, so we tried their delicious Moscato and found out they offer carryout on the bottles, which was a delightful surprise.
Kotoyama Ramen
Dining at Kotoyama Ramen in Noblesville is one of the finest dining experiences I've had in quite some time.
Upon entering, I was immediately drawn to the lovely decorations and ambiance, making me feel right at home.
We started with two appetizers: chicken wontons and crab jalapenos.
While the chicken wontons were just okay, the crab jalapenos were absolutely delicious.
For our main dishes, I had the vegetable stir fry ramen with added spice, and my partner ordered the #7 hikiniku ramen, adding extra cabbage.
Both of our dishes were flavorful and satisfying, and we couldn't help but order more to take home with us.
Something that really stood out to me at Kotoyama Ramen was their diverse boba selection.
I tried the chocolate brown sugar boba, which was tasty without being overly sweet.
Condado Tacos
My friends and I regularly dine at Condado Tacos, and we're always blown away by the quality of their food and service.
The atmosphere at this taco restaurant is lively and welcoming.
During my last visit, my friends and I had Margarita flights, which were very tasty!
The blackberry, blood orange, and prickly pear margaritas were all amazing, with the prickly pear being my favorite.
We also ordered Beans, Rice, Queso, and Street corn as starters.
The beans were spicy but delicious, and the plain Jane white queso was on point!
The Street Corn wasn't exactly authentic Mexican street corn, but it was still good.
For the main event, we ordered tacos; they are larger in size and not skimpy with the contents.
I had the Blue Dream and The Heater, both of which were mouth-watering.
My friends also enjoyed their tacos, and we all left feeling satisfied and happy.
Condado Tacos offers a unique dining experience, combining authentic Tex-Mex flavors with a modern twist.
Uptown Cafe
I've been living in this neighborhood for years, and I must say, Uptown Cafe has become my go-to spot for breakfast.
This cafe is truly a hidden gem, and I'm always eager to share its delicious offerings with my friends and family!
When I'm craving a hearty breakfast, I always order their Western bowl.
The hash browns are exceptionally crispy, and I can't get enough of the homemade bread and biscuits served with jelly.
The freshness is evident, and my taste buds thank me every time.
You can even watch the cook prepare your meal right in front of you if you sit at the bar.
And if you're a fan of their homemade ketchup, which is thick and packed with flavor, you can buy a bottle to take home!
Slapfish
One of my favorite go-to spots is Slapfish. I've been there multiple times, and it never fails to impress me and satisfy my cravings.
The atmosphere is always so relaxing, and it's perfect for a night out with friends or family.
The last time I visited Slapfish with a group of friends, we left our kids with their dads and had an amazing time enjoying great food and company for a few hours.
The power bowls are huge, and the dip is simply fantastic.
I remember ordering the fish and chips, which had generous portions and tasted amazing.
My friends have also praised the Shrimp Burrito and the Lobster Grinder, and we all agree that the lobster tots taste like an upgraded crab cake.
We also tried the taquitos with their superb sauce, and the fries covered in clam chowder, bacon, cheese, and chives.
Livery - Noblesville
I recently had the pleasure of visiting Livery - Noblesville for the first time.
My friends and I decided to check it out on a whim, and it quickly became one of our new favorite spots in town!
I started off with the Carriage House Margarita, which was a delightful mix of flavors with the added touch of brandy.
For our appetizer, we shared the ceviche, featuring a unique take on the traditional dish with shrimp – it was both complimentary and delicious.
For our main courses, I opted for the Red Drum, while my mom chose the Pork Belly Tacos.
Both dishes were bursting with fresh and exciting flavors that truly pleased our palates.
To finish off our wonderful meal, we couldn't resist indulging in some churros - absolutely scrumptious!
Best Bet Breakfast & Lunch
I recently visited Best Bet Breakfast & Lunch in Noblesville, and I must say, it truly lives up to its name!
This diner provides classic American fare in a petite, poker-themed space with a casual vibe.
The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, and the friendly service made me feel right at home.
The breakfast menu was impressive, with a variety of dishes to choose from.
I decided to go for the corned beef with my breakfast, and boy, am I glad I did!
The corned beef was of better quality than most other places I've tried.
It was tender and delicious, making for a memorable breakfast experience.
Another dish that caught my eye was the Maria Stack - a mouth-watering combination of chorizo, peppers, onions, and pepper jack cheese over scrambled eggs and fried potatoes.
I've heard great things about it from fellow diners, and I can't wait to try it on my next visit.
Rosie's Place
Located in downtown Noblesville on the main strip, Rosie's Place is a smart cafe that offers delightful baked goods and delicious breakfast and lunch dishes made from seasonal ingredients.
On one particular Saturday morning, I went there alone and took a seat in their small bar area, looking forward to a peaceful breakfast.
However, the experience I had at Rosie's was beyond anything I could have imagined.
The warm energy in the atmosphere, combined with the sincere kindness of the staff, made every minute there a total joy.
Aspen Creek Grill
As someone who lives nearby, I can't help but rave about the exceptional dining experience at Aspen Creek Grill.
The rustic mountain-lodge theme creates a warm and cozy atmosphere, perfect for a delightful dinner with family or friends.
My recent visit was nothing short of amazing. I opted for the jambalaya, while my husband chose the salmon.
What really impressed us was the fact that the sides were prepared from scratch, and the serving size was quite generous.
And let's not forget about the drinks! The kids enjoyed flavored lemonades while my husband and I tried some of the delicious cocktails.
We even treated ourselves to a mouthwatering dessert to end the evening on a sweet note.
Ford's Garage Noblesville
Ford's Garage Noblesville is an American restaurant known for its unique atmosphere and amazing food.
When I first walked in, I was immediately impressed by the decor.
From the antique car theme to the tire sinks in the bathroom, I couldn't get enough of the attention to detail.
I decided to go with the Henry Chicken, which was absolutely delicious, especially with the lemon Chardonnay butter sauce, sun-dried tomatoes, basil, and goat cheese.
The burger options also looked fantastic, and I heard great things about them from fellow diners.
Grindstone Public House
I recently dined at Grindstone Public House. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by a spacious and comfortable atmosphere with a touch of homestyle charm.
One of the highlights of my meal had to be the stuffed mushrooms – they were absolutely phenomenal!
I also tried the fried green tomatoes and the 14oz ribeye, which were pretty good as well.
The portions were generous, and the prices were quite reasonable, which is always a plus when trying out a new restaurant.
Texy Mexy
I've had the pleasure of dining at Texy Mexy a few times now. On my first visit, I was immediately drawn in by the wide selection of tacos they had on offer.
My friends and I each chose a different variety, and every single one of us was thoroughly satisfied.
What really stands out for me, though, is the freshness of the ingredients they use.
The guacamole is made to perfection, and the salsa is simply the best in town.
As a local, I can attest that it truly lives up to its reputation.
The free chips and salsa offered at the start of the meal only add to the overall dining experience.
My family and I have been back a few more times since our first visit, and we've ventured out to try other dishes as well, like their shrimp taco and enchiladas.
I must say, the shrimp taco is now a personal favorite of mine.
The enchiladas, when available, are also outstanding, with a thick and flavorful corn wrap and well-seasoned protein.
Another plus for me is the warm and friendly atmosphere at Texy Mexy.
Other Restaurants Nearby
Petos (Carmel)
Every time I crave some delicious Greek food, Petos Authentic Greek Cuisine never disappoints!
From warm pita bread and flavorful Gyros to heavenly shawarma, Petos offers a wonderful variety of Greek staples that keep me coming back for more.
One of my personal favorites is their TIROKAFTERI, which is a must-try for anyone who's visiting this place for the first time.
The delightful aroma of the warm pita bread always makes me feel right at home, and their succulent, well-seasoned lamb never fails to amaze my taste buds.
Yats Fishers (Fishers)
Yats Fishers is a restaurant that specializes in New Orleans cuisine. I went with a friend, and we were greeted with a laid-back, counter-serve environment and Mardi Gras-themed decor.
We decided to order a variety of dishes to share, including Chili Cheese Etouffee with Crawfish, Spinach and Mushroom Etouffee, and Chicken Macque Choux.
The food arrived quickly, and I must admit, the portion sizes were a bit smaller than I expected for the price.
However, the flavors were authentic and delicious.
We also indulged in some peanut butter pie and toffee crunch cookies for dessert, which were a delightful way to end our meal.
While I understand the complaints about the price and portion sizes, I believe it's still worth a visit for those craving some good creole grub.
Burritos & Beer Restaurant (Fishers)
I've been living in this neighborhood for a few years now, and one place that I consistently visit is Burritos & Beer Restaurant.
It's a low-key Mexican restaurant that has become my go-to spot whenever I'm in the mood for something delicious, affordable, and filling.
The moment I tried it for the first time, I knew I wouldn't be able to resist coming back for more.
The food they serve is authentic and incredibly tasty.
I've tried a variety of their dishes, but my personal favorite has to be their burritos.
They're generously packed with filling, and the flavors are always spot-on.
I also love their tacos and quesadillas, which offer numerous combinations of ingredients to suit your taste buds.
Plus, the prices are very reasonable, making it an ideal restaurant for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner with friends.
Big Hoffa's Smokehouse (Westfield)
Let me tell you about my recent experience at Big Hoffa's Smokehouse, a barbecue restaurant that has quickly become one of my favorite local spots.
The first time I walked in, I was pleasantly surprised by the unique pirate-themed setting, complete with themed menu items and decor.
It's not something you'd expect from a BBQ place, but it adds a fun and memorable touch to the dining experience.
I ordered The Captain, which was good, but I'm excited to try something different on my next visit.
The meat was flavorful and cooked perfectly, and their sauce is honestly some of the best I've ever had.
We also tried the fries, which were crispy and perfect, the mouth-watering rolls, and the creamy mac and cheese.
We also couldn't resist getting the peach cobbler, which was off the hook!
Erika's Place (Cicero)
A family restaurant located just west of SR19 on Jackson St., Erika's Plac offers a cozy atmosphere and delicious food that goes beyond just filling your stomach.
Last week, I went there with a couple of friends for lunch and, as usual, we had a fantastic experience.
My friends, who were visiting from out of state, were blown away by the quality of the food.
As per a recommendation, one friend ordered the breaded tenderloin sandwich, which she absolutely loved.
I opted for the grilled version, and it was just as mouthwatering.
What I love about Erika's Place is that everything is made fresh and with care, making you feel like you're eating a home-cooked meal.
We also shared an appetizer platter, which was so satisfying that we ended up taking our main dishes home to enjoy later.
The reasonable prices are another reason why I keep coming back to Erika's Place.
10 West Restaurant & Bar (Cicero)
Just last week, I had another fabulous dinner at 10 West, my all-time favorite restaurant in Indiana.
I must say, their eclectic American fare never disappoints.
I started with their crab-stuffed mushrooms as an appetizer, which were incredibly rich and delicious.
For my main course, I decided to go with their Wednesday special and ordered the Filet, which was cooked to perfection.
My friend tried their blackened chicken pasta, and I couldn't resist stealing a few bites - it was amazing!
One thing I love about 10 West is its unique and delicious drink menu.
I tried one of their new cocktail specials, and it was the perfect accompaniment to my meal.
The atmosphere is always inviting, with rustic-chic decor that adds to the overall dining experience.
I couldn't resist ordering dessert, so I shared a slice of birthday cake with my dining companion.
Final Thoughts
My culinary adventures in Noblesville have been nothing short of spectacular.
From the diverse range of flavors at 9th Street Bistro to the mouth-watering sushi at Zen Ramen & Sushi, there's truly something for everyone in this charming Midwestern town.
So, if you're ever in the area, I highly recommend taking the time to explore the incredible array of dining options that Noblesville has to offer.
Recent posts
10 Incredible Breakfast Spots in New Orleans You Need to Try
12 Incredible Restaurants in Lancaster PA, You Need to Try
12 Incredible Restaurants in Asheville, NC You Need to Try
22 Best Things to Do in Old Town Alexandria, VA
25 Best Things to Do in Westport, CT
20 Best Things to Do in Westport, MA
16 Best Things to Do in Woonsocket, RI
26 Best Things to Do in Huntsville, AL
30 Best Things to Do in Altoona, PA
28 Best Things to Do in San Angelo, TX