19 Best Restaurants in Michigan City, IN

This article was written by local contributor Tommy West & edited by the Travel Lens team.

Best Restaurants in Michigan City, IN

As someone who has lived in Michigan City, Indiana, for many years, I can confidently say that this charming lakeside town has a vibrant dining scene that caters to a variety of tastes and preferences.

Over the years, I've had the pleasure of exploring and enjoying a wide range of cuisines and flavors that this city has to offer.

From cozy bistros to bustling breweries, Michigan City boasts an impressive selection of restaurants that showcase unique culinary delights.

So, whether you are a local or just passing through, allow me to give you a glimpse into some of the best restaurants in Michigan City, Indiana.

Let's dive in!

Chickpea

One of my favorite spots to grab a quick and delicious meal in the area is Chickpea, which is conveniently located near the Lighthouse Outlet Mall and Washington Beach Park here.

Their menu offers a variety of halal Middle Eastern dishes, with a hint of Jamaican flavor soon to be added.

As a vegetarian, I appreciate their selection of options like grape leaves, hummus, and falafel.

The fusion between authentic Middle Eastern classics and veggie/rice bowls is a delightful change from the usual fare in town.

On my last visit, I tried the Falafel bowl and was impressed by the generous portion sizes and reasonable prices.

The orange blossom lemonade was a refreshing beverage that I couldn't get enough of – it was perfectly sweetened, tangy, and aromatic.

One thing that really stands out at Chickpea is the friendly service.

The cozy environment, with both indoor and outdoor seating options, makes it a great place to catch up with friends or enjoy a meal with family.

Chickpea · 225 W 5th St, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · Mediterranean restaurant

Saigon City Bar & Grill

The other day, my friends and I decided to try out Saigon City Bar & Grill for dinner.

Right from the start, we were hooked by the ginger garlic peanuts they served as an appetizer.

I loved them so much that I bought a deli container to take home!

One of my friends ordered the beef pho, while I went for the house special pad Thai noodles.

He was very welcoming and eager to talk about the restaurant, which made us feel right at home.

The authentic Vietnamese food was simply delicious, and we couldn't help but notice the clear taste of their water – definitely something rare these days!

Apart from the amazing food and refreshing water, the service at Saigon City Bar & Grill was top-notch.

The portions were quite generous.

SAIGON CITY BAR & GRILL · 615 IN-212, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Scartozzi's Trattoria

Ever since I moved to the neighborhood, I've been on the lookout for the best Italian food, and I am so glad I found Scartozzi's Trattoria.

Their website gives a glimpse of their classic Italian entrees, soups, and salads, but it's not until you try their food that you truly understand how amazing it is.

One evening, after a long day at work, I decided to order some take-out from Scartozzi's, and it proved to be a wonderful decision.

The stuffed shells I had reminded me of the ones my Italian grandma used to make, and it brought a comforting feeling of nostalgia.

The customer service was exceptional as well, making me feel right at home.

Another time, I went in with some friends and opted for seating inside the cozy trattoria.

We had a variety of dishes, from pasta to salad, and everything tasted incredibly fresh and made with love.

It was truly the best Italian meal I've had in years, and the value was unbeatable for the quality of the food.

Scartozzi’s Trattoria · 822 N Karwick Rd, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Panini Panini

One of my favorite spots to grab a delicious and unique meal in town is Panini Panini.

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere.

The menu, displayed on multiple chalkboards, offers a variety of tasty options that make it hard to choose just one item.

I settled for the grilled scallop with prosciutto and feta with pear sandwich, which was excellent.

The side salad that came with my meal was also a pleasant surprise, featuring a delightful mustard vinaigrette dressing as the perfect complement to the mixed greens.

While I was enjoying my meal, I couldn't help but notice a fellow patron's order - The Nordic salad, which looked absolutely amazing.

It's definitely on my list to try the next time I visit.

Panini Panini · 1720 Franklin St, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Hokkaido Sushi Restaurant

One of my favorite places to dine in town is Hokkaido Sushi Restaurant.

I remember my first visit there a couple of years ago, and since then, I've been a regular.

The sushi at Hokkaido Sushi is incredibly fresh, and the selection is always diverse.

I particularly enjoy their specialty rolls, which are not only delicious but also beautifully presented.

Besides sushi, they offer other amazing Japanese dishes as well.

I have to recommend their gyoza and fried rice – the best I've ever had.

During my last visit, I tried their fried soft-shell crab, and it was simply divine!

The portion size was generous, and I savored every single bite.

I also appreciate their selection of beer, wine, and sake, which are reasonably priced and complement the meals perfectly.

The ambiance of Hokkaido Sushi Restaurant is relaxed and intimate, making it the perfect spot for a date night or catching up with friends.

I remember having my first date with my now-fiancé at this restaurant, and we recently returned to celebrate our anniversary – the food and service were just as amazing as our first visit.

Hokkaido Sushi Restaurant · 725 Franklin St, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · Sushi restaurant

Polish Peasant

Just the other day, I was craving some authentic Polish food, and, as usual, I headed to my favorite spot, Polish Peasant.

It's a small, cozy place with a few tables out front and a couple more on the second landing.

The food at Polish Peasant is simply divine.

As someone with Polish heritage, I can attest to its authenticity and perfection.

One of my favorite dishes is the Taste of Poland platter, which has a little bit of everything: stuffed cabbage, pierogi, sausage, and pork cutlet.

Every bite transports me back to my grandma's kitchen and those special holiday meals we used to share.

I also have to rave about the pretzel chicken, which, believe it or not, changed my life.

It's served with double mashed potatoes and extra white cream sauce for dipping, making it an indulgent treat for the taste buds.

And don't even get me started on the homemade soup – the cream of chicken with vegetables is simply out of this world.

Polish Peasant · 231 W 7th St, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · Polish restaurant

Barker Pub

I absolutely love spending my evenings at Barker Pub, it's honestly one of my favorite places to unwind after a long day.

Just last week, my spouse and I decided to grab a late lunch there, and we both ordered their delicious cheeseburger baskets with a cold beer.

The place was bustling with energy, and the patio was the perfect spot to soak up some sun.

Not only is the food at Barker Pub top-notch (give the Bayou Shrimp wrap a try if you're into spicy sauces!), but the service is always friendly and efficient.

We've enjoyed their double cheeseburger and fries special during weekdays, and it's become our go-to meal.

The atmosphere is so welcoming that we've brought everyone from our visiting relatives to our college friends to share a meal or a drink.

Barker Pub · 607 E Barker Ave, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · Bar

Leeds Public House

I recently decided to try out Leeds Public House in my neighborhood, and I'm so glad I did!

The moment I walked in, I was impressed by the modern and classic decor.

I ordered the nachos as an appetizer, and they were absolutely delicious.

The house-made chips had the perfect crunch, and I could taste the love and care put into the dish.

For my entree, I went with Mac and cheese, which was good but not the highlight of my meal.

However, my partner had a steak that was mouthwatering, and I can't wait to try it the next time we visit.

I love the idea of showing appreciation to the hardworking people behind the scenes, and I think more restaurants should adopt this practice.

The atmosphere at Leeds Public House was modern and upbeat, which made for an enjoyable dining experience.

Leeds Public House · 401 Franklin St, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Galveston Steakhouse

I was thrilled when I discovered Galveston Steakhouse.

The saloon-style steakhouse offers delicious mesquite-wood fire-grilled steaks and live blues music.

One evening, my friends and I decided to give this place a try, and it did not disappoint!

We took our time to enjoy the mouthwatering dishes, starting with the onion appetizer and lemon rice soup.

For our main courses, I opted for the ribs, which were nothing short of amazing.

My friends ordered the stuffed chicken and Italian beef sandwich, both of which were tasty.

The portions were so generous that we only managed to eat half and had to take the leftovers home.

One thing that struck me most about Galveston Steakhouse was the nostalgic atmosphere.

The live blues music added a nice touch to our dining experience, making it even more enjoyable.

Galveston Steakhouse · 10 Commerce Square, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · Steak house

Up N Smoke Rib Shack

One of my favorite spots in town has to be Up N Smoke Rib Shack.

I've been there multiple times with friends and family, and it never disappoints.

The ribs are always tender and smokey, and their side dishes like Mac and Cheese and red beans and rice are just mouthwatering.

I remember one eventful night when we had a large group of people, and the restaurant was quite crowded.

It took a little longer for the food to arrive, but it was well worth the wait.

The quality of the food and the overall experience made it a memorable night.

I also had the opportunity to enjoy their catering services for a friend's party, and I must say, they did an exceptional job.

The food arrived on time, hot and fresh, and everyone at the party couldn't stop raving about how good it was.

Up N Smoke Rib Shack · 517 E Barker Ave, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · Barbecue restaurant

Patrick's Grille

One of the best places I've been to in the area is Patrick's Grille.

I recently went there with my partner for a date night, and we were blown away by the delicious food and fantastic ambiance.

The restaurant has a relaxed, blue-hued interior with beautiful cityscape photos and murals.

As a steak lover, my partner couldn't resist trying the New York strip.

I opted for the halibut special, and I can confidently say it was the best halibut I've ever had.

We were so impressed by our meal that we even ordered dessert, which is something we rarely do.

A few of my other favorite dishes include the lobster bisque, beef tenderloins, shrimp, and the scrumptious mud pie for dessert.

Pair it all with some of their delicious craft beer or bourbon, and you're in for a treat.

The sparkling martinis are also a must-try!

Patrick’s Grille · 4125 Franklin St, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · American restaurant

Ritz Klub Tavern

One of my go-to spots for a casual night out with friends is Ritz Klub Tavern.

This cozy little place offers the perfect combination of tasty bar food and a laid-back atmosphere.

My friends and I love to start off with their lip-smacking onion rings and cheese curds.

Their burgers are some of the best I've had in a long time, and my friends rave about their brats and turkey Reubens as well.

What really sets Ritz Klub Tavern apart is the friendly and attentive service.

And if the weather is nice, we love to enjoy our meals out on their patio.

While Ritz Klub Tavern might be considered a "dive bar" by some, it's far from a hole in the wall.

The welcoming atmosphere and delicious food keep us coming back for more.

Ritz Klub Tavern · 124 W 4th St, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · Bar & grill

Cool Runnings Restaurant & Bar

Last weekend, I decided to try out Cool Runnings Restaurant & Bar, a small Jamaican spot in my neighborhood.

I've been passing by this no-frills eatery for a while now and was always intrigued by the mouthwatering smell of jerk seasoning wafting through the air.

We started off with seasoned plantains and crab rolls, which were the perfect appetizers to kick off our Jamaican culinary adventure.

The plantains were perfectly cooked, and the crab rolls were a delightful mix of flavors.

For the main course, I ordered jerk chicken, and my friend opted for the reggae pasta with shrimp.

The jerk chicken was perfectly charcoal-grilled, and the meat was juicy and tender.

The reggae pasta was equally delicious, with jumbo shrimp, lots of vegetables, and a great flavor overall.

We tried the peach lemonade, which turned out to be the ideal beverage for our meal - it was the perfect balance of sweet and tart.

Cool Runnings Restaurant & Bar · 501 Center St, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · Jamaican restaurant

Fiddlehead Restaurant

I absolutely love going to Fiddlehead Restaurant in my neighborhood.

Their designated fryer for fries is a godsend for people like me!

The wait time can sometimes be a bit long, especially on weekends, but it's worth it.

Their pork chop has become one of my all-time favorites, and I can't help but order it every time I visit.

The shrimp tacos and kettle-style potato chips are also fantastic.

One thing that sets Fiddlehead apart is its service.

They're quick to fix any issues, and they genuinely care about their customers' experience.

Fiddlehead Restaurant · 422 Franklin St, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★★ · New American restaurant

The Brewery Lodge & Supper Club

I can't help but rave about my experiences at The Brewery Lodge & Supper Club.

This adults-only boutique hotel is a hidden gem in Michigan City, Indiana, with its rustic-chic décor and serene atmosphere.

As a frequenter, I can say that it's a fantastic place to unwind after a long week.

The attached brewery and restaurant are a major draw for me.

With a refined menu and top-notch service, I've enjoyed many delicious dinners here.

The fresh crab cake appetizer never disappoints, and the glazed pork chop is simply divine.

I'm also a fan of their house-made chocolate mousse for dessert - it's truly a treat for the taste buds!

Aside from the culinary delights, the picturesque grounds and cozy ambiance make The Brewery Lodge a perfect spot for some much-needed relaxation.

I appreciate the boutique hotel aspect of the place, as it provides a retreat-like experience where I can enjoy some peace and quiet without the hustle and bustle of typical hotels.

The Brewery Lodge & Supper Club · 5727 N 600 W, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★☆ · Hotel

Local Option

Local Option has become one of my favorite spots for a great meal and a friendly atmosphere.

One of my go-to dishes here is their award-winning thin-crust pizza - it's simply out of this world.

The crust is perfectly crispy, and the toppings are always fresh and delicious.

Apart from the pizza, their pork tenderloin is also a must-try.

What I love about this place is that most of their menu items are made from scratch, ensuring a fresh and tasty dining experience.

I remember the first time I ordered their stuffed pizza for takeout.

The pizza was a true Chicago-style delight with a thick and heavy crust, loaded with pepperoni, cheese, and a tasty red sauce on top.

Despite the 40-minute wait, it was totally worth it.

However, be prepared for a heavy meal, as just one or two slices will leave you feeling full!

It's worth mentioning that Local Option is a full-blown bar, and you'll need to go inside to pick up your order.

Local Option · 1714 Franklin St, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★☆ · Bar & grill

Bartlett's Fish Camp

One of my favorite places to dine in my city is Bartlett's Fish Camp.

The relaxed harborside setting, delicious seafood, and spectacular views make it a must-visit for anyone in the area.

Every time I visit, I am always impressed by the quality of the seafood.

The oysters are some of the freshest I have ever tasted, and they pair perfectly with the accompanying sauces.

The lobster roll is another favorite of mine, packed with generous chunks of succulent lobster that never disappoints.

One of the highlights of the dining experience at Bartlett's Fish Camp is the stunning view of Lake Michigan.

It's the perfect backdrop for a relaxing meal, whether you're enjoying a romantic dinner or a fun night out with friends.

The large windows allow for an unobstructed view of the water, creating a serene atmosphere that's tough to beat.

Bartlett’s Fish Camp · 12 On the Lake, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★☆ · Restaurant

El Cajete

I can confidently say that El Cajete is one of my go-to spots for authentic Mexican cuisine.

Their website showcases their menu filled with mouth-watering dishes like fajitas and burritos, but it's the in-person experience that really sets this family-run joint apart.

Every time I visit, I'm always greeted with warm tortilla chips and salsa, which compliments the friendly atmosphere perfectly.

The portions are huge, and the quality of the food is always top-notch.

I've tried their wet burrito on a recommendation from a friend and was amazed at how delicious and fresh it tasted.

It was so big that I even had to take half of it home with me!

One thing that really stands out to me about El Cajete is the impeccable service.

It's clear that this restaurant is a labor of love for the family that runs it, and it shows in every aspect of the dining experience.

El Cajete · 3301 Franklin St, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★☆ · Mexican restaurant

El Cantarito MC

Just the other night, I decided to head over to El Cantarito MC for a delicious Mexican meal.

I've heard great things about this place, so I was eager to try it for myself.

I ordered the Chicken Burritos, and my friend opted for the Vegan Fajitas.

The portion size was quite generous for the price we paid, and the taste was simply amazing.

While we were waiting for our food, I couldn't help but notice their extensive margarita menu.

I decided to stick with the Classic Margarita and was pleasantly surprised by both the quantity and quality.

El Cantarito MC · 336 Dunes Plaza, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States
★★★★☆ · Mexican restaurant

Final Thoughts

I cannot emphasize enough how much I adore the diverse and delicious culinary scene in Michigan City.

From mouthwatering sushi at Hokkaido to the irresistible late lunch options at Barker Pub, there is truly something for everyone's taste.

Whether I'm in the mood for a hearty steak dinner at Galveston Steakhouse or a light, fresh salad at Panini Panini, I know I can always rely on the fantastic restaurants in Michigan City to satisfy my cravings.

💌
Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
✍️
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.