17 Best Restaurants in Fishers, IN

This article was written by local contributor Andrew Taylor & edited by the Travel Lens team.

Best Restaurants in Fishers, IN
Ted Alexander Somerville / shutterstock.com

During my time living in Fishers, Indiana, I've had the pleasure of exploring the diverse culinary scene this charming town has to offer.

From mouthwatering barbeque to delectable sushi, there's always something new and exciting to try.

Join me as I take you through some of the best restaurants in Fishers, Indiana, where you're guaranteed to find something to suit your taste buds and leave you craving more!

Ali'i Poke Fishers

One evening, I was craving something light and refreshing for dinner, so I decided to give Ali'i Poke Fishers a try.

Located conveniently close to my home, it was just a short walk away.

As soon as I walked in, I was greeted with a friendly smile and a clean environment.

I was happy to see that they had some specials to choose from, making it easier to decide on a tasty combination.

I appreciated that they didn't charge extra for different toppings, which made it even more enjoyable to customize my bowl.

I ordered a medium-sized bowl, and it was more than enough to satisfy my appetite.

I've heard that a large portion can be shared between two adults, so I'll definitely keep that in mind for future visits.

Ali’i Poke Fishers · 8989 E 116th St, Fishers, IN 46038, United States
★★★★★ · Hawaiian restaurant

Okaya Sushi & Hibachi

I've been on the hunt for the perfect sushi spot in my area, and I've finally found it - Okaya Sushi & Hibachi.

I've been here multiple times, and each visit has been nothing short of amazing.

Their tuna and salmon are always fresh and delicious.

The spicy tuna roll has just the right amount of kick to it, and I appreciate that they don't use any mushy fillers.

The salmon is always top-notch as well.

During my visits, I've tried their two-roll lunch special, and it never disappoints.

Their SOS roll, Japanese lasagna roll, and sunrise roll have all been tasty and well-prepared.

The fried rice is another standout dish, and I can't forget to mention their delightful strawberry peach green tea - it's so refreshing!

It's great to learn that it's family-owned too!

As someone who knows good food, I'm genuinely pleased to be able to enjoy such high-quality sushi, sashimi, and hibachi in my neighborhood.

Okaya Sushi & Hibachi · 11009 Allisonville Rd, Fishers, IN 46038, United States
★★★★★ · Japanese restaurant


One evening, I decided to treat myself to a luxurious dining experience and made a reservation at Peterson's.

I chose an early weekday reservation to avoid the crowd and enjoy a more relaxed atmosphere.

As an appetizer, I ordered the smoked duck fingers, which were a perfect combination of flavors and textures.

For my main course, I went with the ribs – they were cooked to perfection and simply melted in my mouth!

I couldn't help but overhear the praises from a nearby table, where a family was celebrating graduation.

They absolutely loved their ribeye and seafood dishes, which not only tasted great but were also beautifully presented.

The entire experience was elevated by the impeccable service.

Peterson’s · 7690 E 96th St, Fishers, IN 46038, United States
★★★★★ · Steak house

MashCraft Fishers

One Sunday, I decided to head over to MashCraft Fishers for lunch, and I must say, the place did not disappoint!

When I arrived around noon, the place was moderately crowded, giving it a nice, lively atmosphere.

We started off with some spicy breaded cauliflower bites and a soft pretzel, both of which were absolutely amazing!

For our main course, we had a variety of dishes, including shrimp tacos, fried bologna and egg sandwich, mac & cheese with bacon, grilled mac & cheese sandwich, tater tots, fries, and chips.

The homemade quality of the food was evident, with everything tasting fresh and delicious.

During my visit, I also had the chance to try some of their beers, specifically the Jamaica Joe and Hawaiian Delight.

MashCraft Fishers · 11069 Allisonville Rd, Fishers, IN 46038, United States
★★★★★ · Brewery

Sushi Club

As someone who absolutely loves sushi, it's always a challenge to find a place that offers both quality and variety.

Luckily, I stumbled upon Sushi Club, a hidden gem in Fishers.

The moment you step inside, you're greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for both family dinners and catch-ups with friends.

What sets this place apart is their all-you-can-eat sushi menu.

The variety is impressive, catering to all tastes and preferences.

I was blown away by the freshness and flavor of each roll.

My personal favorites are the spicy tuna and the rainbow roll - both taste like they were made with love and care.

Their sushi is truly a cut above the rest, so it's no surprise that I find myself craving it constantly.

Aside from their incredible sushi, Sushi Club also offers delicious soups, salads, and appetizers.

The service is always prompt and polite, making you feel well taken care of.

It's not just me who loves this place - even my 8-year-old enjoys the rolls and has fun eating here!

Sushi Club ( Sushi All You Can Eat ) · 7255 Fishers Landing Dr, Fishers, IN 46038, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

KOI Asian Kitchen

I always find myself on the lookout for new and interesting places to eat, and one such place that has caught my attention is KOI Asian Kitchen.

Their sushi has been the talk of the town, and I must say, they truly live up to the hype!

Being quite picky about my sushi, I can confidently say that KOI Asian Kitchen has managed to meet my high standards.

I've been to other restaurants where the sushi rice is either too hard or too soft, the ingredients aren't fresh, or the presentation is just sloppy.

However, KOI has been consistently excellent every time I've visited.

The ingredients are always fresh, the sushi is beautifully presented, and their house soy sauce is exceptionally tasty.

Aside from their top-notch sushi, I appreciate their quick service and reasonable prices.

I've had great experiences with both carry-out and dine-in options over the past year.

It's also worth mentioning their lunch specials, which are quite affordable.

KOI Asian Kitchen · 8350 E 96th St, Fishers, IN 46037, United States
★★★★★ · Chinese restaurant

Burritos & Beer Restaurant

Every week, my family and I find ourselves drawn back to Burritos & Beer Restaurant.

We probably eat there at least once or twice a week - that's how much we love their authentic Mexican food!

They offer a wide variety of tacos, burritos, and quesadillas, and their Jalapeño ranch is just out of this world.

Not only is the food absolutely amazing, but the prices are also very affordable.

I often order a burrito, and the generous portion I receive is always under ten dollars.

The family-run atmosphere adds a personal touch to the dining experience, making us feel welcome and appreciated every time we visit.

Burritos & Beer Restaurant, LLC · 14094 Trade Center Dr, Fishers, IN 46038, United States
★★★★★ · Mexican restaurant

Tiger Lily 2

As a frequent visitor of restaurants in the area, I must say that my recent dining experience at Tiger Lily 2 was truly exceptional.

The moment I stepped into the restaurant, I was delighted by its inviting ambiance and tasteful decor.

His thoughtful and genuine approach made my dining experience feel truly special.

Now, let's talk about the delicious food!

The shrimp fried rice was simple yet incredibly flavorful, while the dumplings, both fried and steamed, were absolutely amazing.

I even tried some of their specialty items, and they did not disappoint.

Tiger Lily 2 · 7262 Fishers Crossing Dr, Fishers, IN 46038, United States
★★★★★ · Asian fusion restaurant

C.R. Heroes

I finally got a chance to try out  for the first time.

And let me tell you, it did not disappoint!

The menu had a wide variety of options, making it hard for our group to choose.

Eventually, I opted for the Philadelphia Cheesesteak, it was loaded with flavor and filling.

The rest of the party had nothing but great things to say about their meals as well.

Even though it was a busy Friday night, the service remained impeccable, and the food came out quickly and fresh.

Not only was the dining experience enjoyable, but C.R. Heroes also offers a bar area and a kids' game room.

Plus, they have weekly trivia nights, which I'm eager to check out soon.

C.R. Heroes · 10570 E 96th St, Fishers, IN 46037, United States
★★★★★ · American restaurant

Cafe Korea

I had been hearing good things about Cafe Korea from my friends, so I finally decided to check it out.

As soon as I walked in, I loved the warm lighting and spartan decor that gave the place a cozy, intimate atmosphere.

I opted for a table with a grill, which was a really fun way to enjoy my meal.

The food was absolutely delicious and seemed to be very authentic Korean cuisine.

I could tell that this was a family-run business, and it showed in the attentive and friendly service.

Cafe Korea has quickly become one of my favorite Korean restaurants in the area.

I've been back several times with friends, family, and even coworkers.

It's a great spot for both couples and groups, as the combos and grilling experience are perfect for sharing.

Cafe Korea · 11003 Allisonville Rd, Fishers, IN 46038, United States
★★★★★ · Korean restaurant

Hiro Hibachi Express and Sushi

Just the other day, I was craving some delicious Japanese hibachi and sushi, so I decided to pay a visit to Hiro Hibachi Express and Sushi, which happens to be one of my favorite go-to spots in town.

You can check them out here.

The relaxed atmosphere, natural light, and bright blue walls always make my dining experience enjoyable.

My go-to order is their lunch special, which includes two meats – I usually go for steak and chicken.

It comes with a generous serving of rice, vegetables, and of course, their amazing yum yum sauce.

On occasion, I also enjoy treating myself to some of their sushi offerings.

What I really appreciate about Hiro is not only their delicious food but also their top-tier customer service.

They truly care about their customers' experience and satisfaction.

Hiro Hibachi Express and Sushi · 13204 Market Square Dr, Fishers, IN 46038, United States
★★★★★ · Japanese restaurant

Healthies Fishers

One of my favorite spots to hang out and grab a healthy treat is Healthies Fishers!

The moment I stepped into Healthies Fishers, I was greeted by the warm and friendly environment.

It's always so clean, and the beautiful interior just adds to the overall experience.

Their genuine love for their customers makes me feel welcomed and valued every time I walk through the door.

One thing I truly appreciate about Healthies Fishers is the wide variety of options available on the menu.

Whether it's the indulgent yet healthy Oreo Dough shake or a refreshing energy tea, I've never been disappointed with my choices.

Plus, they offer gluten-free options and add-ins like probiotics, fiber, fat burner, or collagen to tailor the products to your specific needs.

Healthies Fishers · 11063 Allisonville Rd, Fishers, IN 46038, United States
★★★★★ · Health food restaurant

Chicago's Pizza

As someone who resides in the area, I've had both good and bad experiences at Chicago's Pizza.

The location is quite convenient, nestled right near Walmart in a small shopping center with ample parking.

The restaurant itself is quite spacious, with a clean interior and a nice patio area.

On one particular visit, I arrived early to pick up a pizza, and it was fresh out of the oven.

Chicago’s Pizza · 13204 Market Square Dr, Fishers, IN 46038, United States
★★★★★ · Pizza restaurant

1933 Lounge by St. Elmo

Let me tell you about my recent experience at 1933 Lounge by St. Elmo.

My partner and I decided to try this place out after hearing some rave reviews from our friends.

And I must say, we were not disappointed!

The minute we walked in, I could feel the intimate atmosphere and the excitement of the other patrons.

I opted for their famous prime rib, and it was cooked to perfection with a delightful spice on the outer edge.

My partner had one of their signature steaks, and they were equally impressed.

We also enjoyed their superb Old Fashioned cocktails, which were expertly crafted and presented.

We had such a great time that we're already planning a return visit with a group of our friends.

1933 Lounge by St. Elmo · 9707 District N Dr Suite 1120, Fishers, IN 46037, United States
★★★★★ · Restaurant

Bento Café

I recently decided to try out a new Asian restaurant in my neighborhood called Bento Café.

The sleek setting and the wide-ranging menu offering sushi rolls, sashimi, pad Thai, and lo mein instantly caught my attention.

I was amazed by the size of the sushi rolls that I ordered; they were so generously sized that just five rolls took up an entire tray!

The flavors were delightful, with the Philadelphia roll quickly becoming my favorite.

I've had sushi all over the U.S., and compared to others, Bento Café's offerings were not only delicious but also reasonably priced.

In addition to sushi, I also tried their chicken fried rice, which surprisingly stood out more than I expected.

Bento Café · 9778 E 116th St, Fishers, IN 46037, United States
★★★★★ · Asian fusion restaurant

Tequila Sunrise Mexican Restaurant

One of my favorite places to eat in the area is Tequila Sunrise Mexican Restaurant.

I've been there quite a few times, and I must say that their food never disappoints.

The prices are quite reasonable for the portions you get, and the quality of the food is consistently top-notch.

I do have to admit that the service can be a bit hit or miss.

There have been times when it took a while to get our drinks or place our orders, but I've also had visits where everything was prompt and efficient.

Despite this, I still find myself going back because the food and atmosphere are worth it.

One of my favorite dishes is the Chile Verde, which is absolutely delectable.

The margaritas are another highlight and always hit the spot.

In fact, I've tried a few of their different flavors and have yet to be disappointed.

Tequila Sunrise Mexican Restaurant · 11653 Fishers Station Dr, Fishers, IN 46038, United States
★★★★★ · Mexican restaurant

El Lago Mexican Restaurant

I've been to El Lago Mexican Restaurant a couple of times in the past month, and I must say, it never disappoints.

Even though I'm not usually a big fan of Mexican food, I can't resist the delicious dishes they offer.

The Cozumel Fajitas are my go-to order, and the portion size is quite generous.

On my last visit, I tried their horchata and was impressed by how good it tasted.

The habanero sauce added just the right amount of kick to my meal, and the atmosphere in the restaurant is always inviting.

It's worth mentioning that I've brought my siblings and little cousins here before, and despite our age differences, we were all treated with respect and had a great time.

El Lago Mexican Restaurant · 10150 Brooks School Rd, Fishers, IN 46037, United States
★★★★★ · Mexican restaurant

Final Thoughts

I feel incredibly fortunate to live in Fishers, Indiana, where there's such an abundance of amazing restaurants to choose from.

Whether I'm in the mood for fresh, mouthwatering poke from Ali'i Poke Fishers or authentic Mexican cuisine from Tequila Sunrise Mexican Restaurant, I know my taste buds are always in for a treat.

Each dining experience in Fishers brings something unique to the table, and I can't wait to continue exploring the ever-growing culinary scene in this great city.

Spotted a mistake, have some feedback, or just want to chat with our editorial team? Click here to get in touch.
Find out more about Travel Lens and read our editorial guidelines here.