21 Best Restaurants in Elkhart, IN
Ah, Elkhart, my beloved hometown, nestled in the heart of Northern Indiana.
With her quaint charm and rich history, she continues to steal my heart every single day.
But it's not just the thriving arts scene or the signature Midwestern hospitality that makes me love Elkhart.
It's the food.
Yes, the vibrant culinary landscape here in Elkhart is nothing short of spectacular, offering a delightful mix of comfort food, exotic flavors, and gourmet experiences.
Trust me, if you're a food lover, you're in for a treat.
So, come on this gastronomic journey as we delve into the best restaurants in Elkhart, Indiana.
Our aim is not just to guide you to popular eateries but to encourage you to venture out and experience the city's diverse culinary landscape for yourself
Essence Restaurant + Bar
You can't say you've fully experienced Elkhart's culinary scene until you've dined at the Essence Restaurant + Bar.
It's not just a dining establishment but a full-blown, immersive gastronomic journey.
They are not just there to serve food but to ensure that your time at Essence is an unforgettable experience.
By the time I left, it felt like I was leaving a gathering of friends rather than a restaurant.
Now, let's talk about the ambiance - it's a dream!
The warm glow from the bar lights creates an atmosphere that's both cozy and sophisticated.
It's clear that every detail of the decor has been carefully chosen.
It's almost like stepping into a different world, one that's both luxurious and comfortable.
But the real star here, of course, is the food.
Oh, the food!
Each bite reveals the thought, care, and expertise that goes into it.
The Sea Bass?
Phenomenal!
The aged meats?
An absolute delight!
They even have Japanese sweet potatoes that are so filling and delicious that they could be a meal by themselves.
The Essence Salad and the mezcal cocktails are personal favorites of mine.
Their fresh fish and scallops never fail to impress, either.
What's exciting is that their menu changes with the seasons, so there are always new culinary delights to explore.
Hotdog Eddy's
Picture this, a lazy Saturday afternoon, and you are wandering the streets of downtown, stomach growling when you stumble upon a little gem tucked away in the corner - Hotdog Eddy's.
The ambiance is inviting, and the aroma of freshly grilled hotdogs fills the air.
From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with a robust laugh from the man behind the counter, Eddy himself.
His infectious humor and warm welcome make you feel like a cherished friend rather than a customer.
But the true delight lies in the food he passionately serves.
The menu, loaded with a wide array of choices, is just the beginning of your gastronomic adventure.
My first pick from the menu was the PORK E PIG, a hot dog wrapped in bacon, topped with BBQ pulled pork, coleslaw, onions, and pickles.
Each bite was a playful dance of flavors, a testament to the craft and creativity that goes into making each hot dog.
Soon, I found myself a regular visitor.
The downtown and Chicago-style hotdogs became my partner's favorite, while my kids couldn't get enough of their simple yet delectable hotdogs.
My partner also ventured out and tried the Cubano and Monica's hotdog, and she couldn't stop raving about it.
And it's not just about the food.
It's about the love and care that's put into every aspect of this place.
Iechyd Da Brewing Company
A trip to the heart of Elkhart is never complete without a visit to the Iechyd Da Brewing Company.
One of my favorite ways to spend an afternoon is by indulging in a flight of seven beers, each distinctly flavorful and unique.
While there are a few beers that might not suit everyone's palate, the overall array is impressive and quite varied.
When it comes to food, the Reuben sandwich is something you should not miss.
It's my first time trying this sandwich here, given that I'm not a sauerkraut enthusiast.
But oh boy, was it a delightful surprise!
It's a hearty sandwich that's just bursting with flavor.
I can't really compare it to anything else, but it's definitely worth trying.
Their pizza is another star on the menu.
The crust is perfectly crisp, and the toppings are so full of flavor that they keep you coming back for more.
Another thing that stands out at Iechyd Da is their pricing.
The beers are so reasonably priced that you might find yourself asking for seconds or even thirds.
The food, too, looks very tempting and well worth every penny.
What really makes this place a gem of Elkhart is not just the food and beer but also their monthly specials.
They always come up with something enticing that leaves you eager for your next visit.
Artisan
When you want an evening to remember with exquisite cuisine and delightful ambiance, Artisan is the place to go in Elkhart.
I remember my first visit when I ordered their filet.
Not only was it cooked to perfection, everything else on my plate was a perfect blend of flavors.
But the food isn't the only thing that keeps me coming back.
The second time I visited, I tried their tasting menu.
It was an explosion of taste and creativity - every bite better than the last.
My partner tried the same but with wine pairing, and it was fascinating to see how every sip of wine complimented the food on our plate.
What sets Artisans apart is their attention to detail and their hospitality.
They made my partner, and I feel special every time we visited.
Their unique dishes and desserts always managed to surprise and exceed our expectations.
One unforgettable instance was when they made special accommodations for our anniversary.
It was a truly remarkable experience.
My most recent visit was for my partner's birthday.
We celebrated in style at Artisan.
They even placed a birthday card on our table prior to our arrival.
We ordered Shrimp risotto, salmon, and cream Brûlée.
It was all incredibly delicious.
Their online booking system was a breeze to use.
El Fogon Restaurante y Taqueria
There's something special about the food at El Fogon Restaurante y Taqueria that keeps me coming back for more.
Every Friday, like clockwork, my coworkers and I head over to El Fogon for a lunchtime fiesta.
It's a small, quaint place with a big heart.
Don't let the size of the parking lot or the building fool you.
The intimate setting is what makes this place so special.
The restaurant is always spotless, and the wait for food is never too long.
The decor is warm and inviting.
My favorite part is the seasonal tree they keep redecorating for every holiday - it's a small but thoughtful touch that adds to the overall ambiance.
What about the food, you ask?
To say it's to die for would be an understatement.
My personal recommendation is the Chili Colorado with beans, rice, flour tortillas, and chips.
It's an explosion of flavors that leaves me happily satisfied every single time.
If you're in the mood for something different, the chicken sope, pork sope, and chicken quesadilla are all crowd-pleasers.
Wash it down with a refreshing glass of horchata, and you'll understand why El Fogon is my go-to Mexican spot.
Kao's
"On a random Tuesday evening, my taste buds were itching for something refreshing, and I knew just the place to satiate them - Kao's.
A gem tucked in the heart of downtown Elkhart, this restaurant has quickly become my go-to spot for divine Asian cuisine.
I remember my first experience; I opted for their online takeout service.
It was so convenient.
However, stepping inside to pick up my order, I was welcomed with a warm and inviting atmosphere.
I ordered the Mi Cha, Jungle Fried Rice, and Rocket Shrimp.
And oh boy, were they a hit!
Each dish was cooked to perfection, enough to make your taste buds sing.
Not to mention, their portions were quite generous.
I'd dare say their food lasted me a few meals.
The subsequent visits only further solidified my love for Kao's.
Their Pate Sandwich and Egg Rolls are some of the best I've tasted - scoring a solid 10 and 9 out of 10, respectively.
I already have my eyes on the Taro Egg Rolls for the next time.
Las Adelitas Taqueria
You never know where the road will take you, and that's the beauty of life.
One such serendipitous detour led me to Las Adelitas Taqueria.
My first bite of their freshly fried chips and tangy salsa had me wondering why I didn't discover this place sooner.
The Mixed Fajitas and the Chile Rellenos, both served piping hot, had a savory depth that was complemented beautifully by the freshness of the ingredients.
Once I dug into their Cali burrito, I knew I had struck culinary gold; it was packed full of flavor, and the fries served with it were hot and crispy, just the way I like it!
The service was friendly but not intrusive, just as you'd expect from a family-owned business.
Cappy's Northside Bar and Grill
There's something to be said about a place that serves up warm comfort food with a side of nostalgia.
That's exactly what you'll find at Cappy's Northside Bar and Grill, a cozy little joint that's been around since 1945.
Even on the busiest nights, there's an inviting, laid-back atmosphere that immediately makes you feel at home.
The real stars of the show here, however, are the food and drinks.
The cheeseburgers are nothing short of amazing, easily some of the best you'll find in Elkhart County.
For the more adventurous, the menu also boasts dishes like white chicken chili and a smoked ham sandwich that are sure to leave you satisfied.
And let's not forget about the drinks.
Whether you're looking for a quick pick-me-up while waiting for your to-go order or unwinding after a long day, the cocktails are a must-try.
And did I mention the ginormous slices of cheesecake for dessert?
It's the perfect sweet end to a delightful meal.
Antonio's
Italian cuisine is indulgent at its best, and no place in Elkhart delivers that better than Antonio's Italian Restaurant.
From the moment you step through the door, you're greeted with a warm, inviting atmosphere that immediately makes you feel like you're in a rustic Italian villa.
The first time I visited Antonio's, I was drawn in by the sizzle of the Chicago-style pizza fresh from the oven.
Topped with a generous sprinkle of meat, every bite was a burst of flavor.
It's cooked perfectly and served so hot you can see the steam rising.
It's, without a doubt, one of the best pizzas in Elkhart.
But don't just take my word for it; try their lasagna.
It's simply heavenly!
The layers of pasta, cheese, and sauce blend together in a harmony of flavors that makes you reach for that extra piece before you even finish your first.
Another time, I ventured beyond the pizza and lasagna to order the Alfredo shrimp penne pasta.
The pasta was cooked to perfection, and the creamy Alfredo sauce was a perfect companion to the succulent shrimp.
My partner went for the chicken Alfredo with spaghetti and thoroughly enjoyed it.
I can't forget to mention the fried Calamari.
It's crispy, flavorful, and a great start to any meal.
The Vine
There is no better joy for a food lover than stumbling upon a hidden gem in their own neighborhood, and The Vine is just that.
A must-visit joint for any food explorer, its menu will make you want to dine there every day.
I have been going there for quite some time now, and the place never ceases to amaze me with its sheer variety of food options and the perfection with which every dish is prepared.
With a relaxed bistro vibe and contemporary decor, it is the perfect place to enjoy a hearty meal with family or friends.
And if you're a wine enthusiast, you'll be amazed by their ample wine options.
It's not just the food and wine but the ambiance, too, with the patio seating offering a great view, making the dining experience truly delightful.
The Vine's steaks and pizzas are to die for.
The steaks are cooked to perfection, juicy, tender, and full of flavor.
The pizzas have a perfect crust and generous toppings and are cooked exactly how you'd like.
And for pasta lovers, their cheese tortellini with pesto cream sauce is an absolute delight.
But what really steals the show is their dog-friendly policy.
They go out of their way to make our four-legged friends comfortable, offering them water bowls and treat bags.
It's a heartwarming sight to see our canine friends being pampered and loved.
Michael's Italian Restaurant
It's a rarity to find a restaurant that feels just like home, but Michael's Italian Restaurant in Elkhart is one exception to the rule.
I've been dining at this family-owned eatery for years, which never ceases to amaze me.
There's simply something magical about the place, which has been serving traditional Italian meals since 1917.
They're always there to greet you with the most welcoming smile, and it's an exceptional part of the experience.
The food at Michael's is, of course, the star of the show.
Whether it's their irresistible pizza or my personal favorite - the pasta salad, every dish is a testament to the culinary expertise inherent to this restaurant.
The cheese & crackers are something you cannot miss.
The portions are generous, the food is flavorful, and the quality is consistently excellent.
Chubby Trout
I have to admit, I've become quite a regular at Chubby Trout.
It's the kind of charming, down-to-earth joint where every visit feels like a mini-vacation right here in the city.
It's a unique blend of steaks, seafood, sushi, and an impressive selection of craft beers and mixed drinks that combines for an enticing dining experience.
I still remember my first visit.
The food, of course, is the real star of this show.
My personal favorite is the Chubby Trout.
However, I've also tried the Sesame Ginger Ahi Salad upon a friend's recommendation and was certainly not disappointed.
The flavors hit just the right notes, and the presentation is always on point.
What adds to the charm of this restaurant is the cozy atmosphere.
Whether it's the first visit or the tenth, the ambiance never fails to make you feel welcome.
And let's not forget the portions!
Not only is the food delectable but also plentiful, leaving no room for any dinner regret.
Their dessert menu is another delight.
It's a sinful indulgence that's worth every single calorie.
I'll let you in on a secret - make sure to order a dessert, no matter how full you are; it's that good.
Chubby Trout isn't just a restaurant; it's an experience.
It's where great food meets great service in a fantastic environment.
And the best part?
You don't have to travel far to get here.
Flippin Cow
You haven't truly tasted a gourmet burger until you've savored the juicy goodness of a burger from Flippin Cow.
Nestled in our tight-knit community, Flippin Cow has become my go-to spot for all things comforting.
One bite into their specialty burgers, and you'll be dreaming about it for days to come.
Trust me; I've been there!
When I feel the need to unwind after a long day, I find myself craving for their mouth-watering burgers and house-fried chips.
Fresh, crisp toppings perfectly complement the succulent patty, delivering an explosion of flavors that makes every bite memorable.
Pairing this with their cocktails adds the cherry on top of a perfect dining experience.
Despite being a bustling place, especially during the lunch rush, the service at Flippin Cow remains top-notch.
You'll be seated promptly, and your orders will be at your table before you know it.
What I love most about Flippin Cow is their lakefront patio.
Dining by the lake, with a cooling breeze wafting through, adds an extra layer of relaxation that's hard to find elsewhere.
It's the perfect spot to enjoy a calm evening with friends or family, basking in the tranquil atmosphere while enjoying scrumptious food.
Soto's Mexican Cuisine
You know that feeling when your palate craves something zesty, spicy, and full of flavor?
That's when I head straight to Soto's Mexican Cuisine.
This tucked-away treasure in Southgate has been my go-to place whenever my taste buds yearn for the authentic taste of Mexico.
I remember one sunny afternoon; I was particularly hungry.
A trip to Soto's was in order.
I ordered their steak gordita and a chicken quesadilla.
The gordita was a delightful surprise, packed with tender steak, and the quesadilla was a cheesy delight that melted in the mouth.
The accompanying rice and beans were cooked to perfection, with a nice balance of spices.
But what caught my taste buds by surprise was their corn in a cup.
It was a sweet and savory concoction I couldn't seem to get enough of.
And let's not forget the chips and guacamole - freshly made and a perfect appetizer that set the tone for the meal.
On other visits, I've tried their huaraches and steak tacos, which are also fantastic.
Their hot sauces, available in ketchup bottles, add the right amount of heat to the dishes.
I've even stopped in for lunch while hosting a Harvest event, and their food was a hit!
Re-Pete's Simonton Lake Tavern
Well, Friday nights at Re-Pete's Simonton Lake Tavern have become somewhat of a tradition for me.
You see, there's just something special about this place that keeps drawing me back.
The atmosphere is lively and fun, yet relaxed enough to enjoy a quiet drink or two.
They are friendly, and efficient, and go out of their way to make you feel at home.
And let's not forget the food - oh, the food!
The menu has largely remained unchanged since the tavern changed hands a few years ago, and thank goodness for that.
It's bar food done right, and it complements the wide selection of cold beers and liquors perfectly.
The cleanliness of the place is something I always appreciate.
You could practically eat off the floor!
Well, I mean, not that you'd want to with the great food they have here.
Speaking of which - the Frog Legs.
I’ve heard from some retired Union Electricians who frequent the place that they are exceptional.
Cooked to perfection and served with your choice of dip or sauce.
I also have a soft spot for their wings - they are meaty, full of flavor, and just the right amount of messy.
And let's not forget about the cold beer that goes along with it.
It's the perfect way to wind down after a long week.
Smokin Fattys BBQ
You know you've hit the jackpot when the scent of sizzling barbeque wafts through the air, enticing even before you step foot in the door.
That's the magic of Smokin Fattys BBQ, a spot I consider a jewel in the crown of our local culinary scene.
For those first-time visitors who are perplexed by the menu, fret not!
They make the first-time experience a breeze, and I guarantee you'd want to come back to try more.
The crab legs are a must-try - so flavorful they don't need to be drenched in butter.
But should you choose to, their Cajun butter is an excellent companion.
What really reels me in every time, though, is the seafood boil - the pièce de résistance.
Believe me, it's worth every mile of the journey, even for those who drive an hour to get here.
But don't leave without trying their trio smokehouse, a treat that awaits for dinner time.
Oh, and why not wrap up the feast with a dessert?
It's almost sinful not to.
The prices are really reasonable too.
Imagine getting a scrumptious meal, a couple of refreshing margaritas, and leaving a good tip, all for less than $30.
Now, that's a steal!
They make the experience more than just about the food - it feels like a hearty, warm gathering.
Bird in the Hand
Picture the perfect weekend - getting your loved ones together and heading to a local hotspot to devour delicious, simple, and affordable eats.
That's what you'd get when you venture to Bird in the Hand, a gem nestled in the heart of our city.
It's the kind of place that serves sandwiches so scrumptious you can't help but savor every bite.
The chicken sandwiches, in particular, are a must-try!
They are not just flavorful but filling as well - perfect for when you're famished and craving comfort food.
And don't even get me started on the fries - heaping portions of perfectly cooked, well-seasoned delights that'll leave you wanting more.
What makes the experience even more enjoyable is the atmospheric charm of the place.
Watching the culinary marvels unfold in the kitchen adds to the anticipation, all the while surrounded by a lively yet cozy atmosphere.
It's the feeling of a friendly neighborhood joint where everyone's welcome, amplified by the fun tunes playing in the background.
For the first-timers, do give the popcorn chicken, chicken tenders, and the single-smash burger a try.
The hot and honey and spicy sauces accompanying these dishes are nothing short of lip-smacking!
And if you appreciate a place that pays heed to your dietary needs, you'll be glad to know that their service is commendable.
Bangkok Place by Kami
The other day, I had another superb meal at Bangkok Place by Kami, a charming little bistro tucked away in our city.
The warm, inviting atmosphere immediately puts you at ease, with the organic, authentically Thai decor adding a touch of exotic charm.
I love the simplicity of the place; it's not trying too hard; it's just effortlessly cozy.
I opted for the chicken red curry and my partner the Thai basil chicken.
Both dishes were fantastic, bursting with flavor and just the right amount of spice.
If you're not a fan of spicy food, don't worry, Kami is always ready to offer more rice to balance the heat.
And believe me; the food is worth the spice.
What I appreciate most about this spot is the cleanliness; it's spotless.
You can even catch a glimpse of the kitchen, which is organized in a tidy fashion, reflecting the care that goes into every dish served.
It's not exactly bustling; it's more of a quiet, relaxed kind of place.
Perfect for a quiet dinner or a catch-up with friends.
There's also outdoor and indoor dining, so it caters to everyone's preference.
I recommend the classic Pad Thai or the Crab Rangoons; they are some of the best you can find in the city.
Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano
Trust me, no culinary adventure in Elkhart is complete without a stop at Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano.
The first thing that strikes you is its unassuming exterior, but as they say, don't judge a book by its cover.
The moment you step inside, you're greeted by a cozy atmosphere and the warmest service you could ask for.
The food, oh the food!
It's nothing short of outstanding.
I still remember the first time I bit into their Toscana Gnocchi - it was like a little piece of Italy on my palate.
My partner swears by their chicken parm in a house-made vodka sauce, which, I must admit, gives my gnocchi a run for its money.
And the desserts, they're the stuff of dreams.
The carrot and chocolate cakes served with red wine reduction sauce still make us think of Christmas.
Their calamari is another must-try.
Big, meaty pieces cooked to perfection.
If you're a fan of spicy food, their Saccotini will have you breaking into a sweat in the best way possible.
Don't forget to top it all off with their homemade tiramisu - it's the proverbial cherry on top.
Heinnies
Every place has that one spot where the locals gather, and everyone knows each other by name.
In our city, that place is Heinnies.
If you're looking for a neighborhood spot that feels like home, this is it.
This family-owned eatery and bar has been serving up classic American fare for years, making it a firm favorite among us townsfolk.
Let me start by saying the food here is comfort on a plate guaranteed to leave you sated.
The burgers are legendary, the steaks are done to perfection and the simple American fare is always delicious.
If you're looking in for a quick bite for lunch, the salads are substantial, although be warned, they charge extra for additional toppings.
But honestly, they're worth every cent.
When it comes to dinner, the prime rib is a must-try.
It's nothing short of phenomenal, and it's so massive you won't need sides.
Just picture it, a big slab of char-broiled meat, tender, juicy, and bursting with flavor.
Trust me on this; it's a carnivore's dream.
If you're like me and enjoy starting your meal with an appetizer, the potato wedges loaded with bacon and cheese are a treat.
They're thick-cut, crispy, and oh-so-cheesy.
Pro-tip, the ham and bean soup, it's so good that it even beats my mom's homemade version.
And if you're still able to fit in some dessert after that feast, don't miss out on their Snicker cheesecake.
They know the menu inside out and are always ready to offer a recommendation..
523 Tap & Grill
Whenever I'm in the mood for a sophisticated dining experience, I always head over to 523 Tap & Grill.
This polished grill has an industrial yet contemporary vibe that never fails to impress.
Not to mention, their creative martinis are simply to die for.
However, bear in mind that the service might not be everyone's cup of tea.
It's a bit slow and lacks the warm Midwestern hospitality I'm accustomed to.
It feels like they're trying to emulate a posh Manhattan-style but end up missing the mark slightly.
I've often gone there for lunch, and while the wait time for meals can be a bit long, it's worth it.
Once, I decided to go for their Filet Mignon, which did take a while to arrive.
But believe me, the New England Clam Chowder they serve twice weekly is divine.
It's worth every minute of the wait.
The food, in general, is a delight.
Their veggie sides are not your usual steamed variety but come with caramelized onions and other tasty additions.
And oh, the Margaritas!
They are stellar and not to be missed.
Final Thoughts
Having indulged in the culinary delights of Elkhart, Indiana, for years, I can confidently assert that the city has a rich and diverse food scene.
Whether you want a mouth-watering hotdog from Hotdog Eddy's, a pint of craft beer at Iechyd Da Brewing Company, or a taste of Italy at Antonio's Italian Restaurant or Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano, you're sure to find something to savor.
It's these experiences that make dining in Elkhart a delightful adventure, one that I look forward to continuing.
Recent posts
10 Incredible Breakfast Spots in New Orleans You Need to Try
12 Incredible Restaurants in Lancaster PA, You Need to Try
12 Incredible Restaurants in Asheville, NC You Need to Try
22 Best Things to Do in Old Town Alexandria, VA
25 Best Things to Do in Westport, CT
20 Best Things to Do in Westport, MA
16 Best Things to Do in Woonsocket, RI
26 Best Things to Do in Huntsville, AL
30 Best Things to Do in Altoona, PA
28 Best Things to Do in San Angelo, TX