15 Best Restaurants in Anna Maria Island, FL

A barrier island off Florida's Gulf Coast, Anna Maria Island in Manatee County is a popular tourist destination.

Once only known by Floridians, it is now a popular tourist destination for people all over the world.

Anna Maria Island has preserved much of the "old" Florida allure.

It has picture-perfect white sand beaches, turquoise Gulf waters, and charming downtown areas.

It's possible to see two of Florida's most iconic sights in one day: the dawn over Tampa Bay and the sunset over the Gulf of Mexico.

Pine Avenue is full of restaurants and establishments catering to tourists.

Here are the best restaurants in Anna Maria Island, Florida:

Skinny's Place

Established in the early 1950s, Skinny's Place is a casual eatery known for its handcrafted burgers, hotdogs, and homestyle sides served in a rustic setting with outdoor seating.

It's one of the only remaining places to enjoy the area's classic open-air atmosphere.

Skinny's Place is just 100 yards from the stunning Anna Maria Island beaches and has a beautiful "Old Florida" vibe.

Guests can choose from various burgers, French fries, and grilled chicken sandwiches of varying sizes.

There's also boneless buffalo chicken, veggie burgers, and Grandma's homemade Chilies, all of which are excellent.

Indulge a mug of Frosted Draft beer at a reduced price during Happy Hour to wash down all that food.

Stop by this classic burger and hot dog place on Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach.

Hurricane Hanks

Hurricane Hanks has been a hit for residents and tourists for many years.

This laid-back bar is well-liked by locals for its delicious beer-battered fish, sandwiches, and burgers.

You'll immediately feel at ease when you walk in due to the establishment's relaxed, unpretentious vibe.

They have something for everyone, and the daily specials are to die for.

The menu offers various options, from appetizers to desserts to great daily specials.

Menu items range from seafood to salads and beyond.

In addition, they serve an excellent burger.

Hurricane Hanks' reputation rests on the quality of the food and the warmth of the service.

The menu's highlights included dishes like gumbo, fish tacos with a blackened twist, and blackened shrimp tacos.

Chicken tenders, grouper sandwiches, and tuna stacks are also excellent choices.

Make sure to visit them when you go to Anna Maria Island.

They are located along Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach.

Los Chiludos Fresh Mexican Grill

Los Chiludos Fresh Mexican Grill is a laid-back spot that serves burritos, enchiladas, tacos, and other Mexican dishes.

It opened in a little storefront in Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, in 2008 before moving to its current location on Anna Maria Island, along East Bay Drive in Holmes Beach in March 2022.

Their dishes are delicious whether eaten in a restaurant or taken to go.

Food is never reheated in the microwave and is always made fresh.

If you want to try authentic Mexican food, Los Chiludos Fresh Mexican Grill is the place to go.

The chicken fajitas are prepared to order and come with a mountain of toppings like guacamole, sour cream, and cheese.

Their shredded chicken tacos, carnitas platter, and Los Chiludos are also to die for.

This place is excellent: great atmosphere, friendly service, and top-notch margaritas.

The Feast Restaurant

The Feast Restaurant is a casual American establishment known for its extensive selection of craft beers and seafood dishes.

It's known for its extensive menu, which includes seafood, steaks, salads, and creative pasta dishes.

In addition, the restaurant specializes in gourmet pizzas topped with fresh ingredients and tossed by hand.

The menu is thoughtfully curated to offer something tasty for everyone, focusing on different international cuisines.

It's updated twice a year to ensure loyal consumers always have access to new and exciting menu options.

In addition, The Feast Restaurant has an extensive selection of craft beers, microbrews, and wines that are sure to please even the most seasoned connoisseurs.

It would be best if you got the Escargot grilled in garlic butter and served with herb-infused French bread.

Then, don't leave without ordering the Salmon Buri: salmon rubbed with Thai spices and sautéed in clover leaf honey, served over coconut jasmine rice, with cucumbers, avocado, and sweet tiger sauce.

If you want more, you can find this place on T Marina Drive in Holmes Beach.

Beach Bistro

The classy Beach Bistro serves traditional Florida fare in a beautifully decorated dining room or on a patio overlooking the ocean.

This restaurant has been serving the neighborhood for over 37 years and remains committed to its goal of providing customers with the best dining experience.

They are still driven by their founder's unwavering belief that perfection is the only acceptable standard.

Beach Bistro is unrivaled in high-quality dining on Anna Maria Island.

The menu is extensive, and the restaurant's cozy and romantic environment is thanks to its proximity to the water and gorgeous harbor views.

With their five-course meal plan, you may select from a wide variety of delicious dishes.

Smoked salmon, scallop pan roast, US prime beef tenderloin, and their desserts are just a few of the dishes you must taste.

Visit them on Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach for some amazing food.

Two Scoops

Since its opening in October 2007, locals have flocked to Two Scoops for its delicious dessert and classic American fare.

Among the many things on the menu are homemade ice cream, sandwiches, hot dogs, breakfast, coffee, subs, and more.

Two Scoops is renowned for its outstanding desserts with 32 varieties of handcrafted ice cream.

The store is very spacious and has an attractive aesthetic.

Try one of their many delectable shakes and waffles from their extensive menu.

Have one of their many tasty shakes or waffles, such as the Belgian Waffle, topped with butter, syrup, and strawberries.

Choose the Ultimate Scoops Hoagie, an eight-inch hoagie loaded with turkey bacon, ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing for a hearty meal.

If you're in a rush, grab a Scoops BLT with crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.

Stop by North Bay Boulevard and try one of their several ice cream varieties.

Sandbar Seafood & Spirits

Sandbar Seafood & Spirits is a beachside restaurant on Spring Avenue, serving traditional fare and dishes with creative twists.

It's at the far northern tip of Anna Maria Island, and people have loved it for decades.

Sandbar Seafood & Spirits is the place for amazing sunsets, excellent dishes, and pleasant conversation.

Discover the best of Old Florida, with breathtaking scenery and a welcoming vibe for the whole family.

Watch the sun go down while you eat with the sand touching your feet.

You can drink on their deck by the water or in their dining room.

You can try their Oysters on the Half Shell or Black Bean Hummus as a starter.

Then savor their NY strip, which comes with thick slices of chargrilled striploin, braised greens, fries, and peppercorn brandy sauce.

Finally, if you are in a hurry, you can order the Sandbar Burger, which is a half-pound chargrilled burger with fried green tomato, pimento cheese, tomato jam, Teddy's brioche bun, and fries.

Pizza Social

Pizza Social is a laid-back eatery that serves pizzas prepared from scratch, along with salads and artisan beverages.

Their specialty is homemade pizza, fresh salads, and other healthy options.

Their pizza ingredients, including the dough and tomato sauce, are made fresh daily.

Pizza Social uses only hand-tossed and stretched dough, creating a thin crust that is then covered in freshly shredded mozzarella.

Their authentic Italian oven bakes your pizza at 700 degrees until it's crispy and delicious.

Begin with a Greek Salad, which includes spring greens, cucumber, black olives, Greek vinaigrette, and other ingredients.

Then, create your pizza yummy pizza by starting with your favorite sauce and then topping it with pepperoni, Italian sausage, bacon, Canadian bacon, ground beef, sliced tomato, mushrooms, red onion, green pepper, and other ingredients.

If you're looking for some authentic Italian pizza, go to Pine Avenue.

Mademoiselle Paris

If you're looking for a casual place to get some subs, cheesesteaks, or baked goods, look no further than Mademoiselle Paris.

It's an adorable cafe with a wide selection of beverages and a nice patio for enjoying your meal.

This traditional patisserie serves a full breakfast menu and delicious French pastries.

Their Eggs Benedict, crepes, and pastries are almost as good as what you'd find in France.

All of the baked goodies and iced coffee are delicious.

In addition, their wine-tasting evening is something you can't miss.

At Mademoiselle Paris, everything from the excellent cuisine to the French music, wine, and service is flawless.

It's the perfect activity for a night with friends or loved ones.

Come and pay a visit if you're looking for genuine French cuisine and atmosphere on Gulf Drive.

The Ugly Grouper

The Ugly Grouper is a bustling, laid-back restaurant specializing in seafood and burgers and features a cool giant metal fish sculpture.

If you're looking for a place to hang out and chow down, you've found the right place.

The restaurant is just walking distance from Waterline Marina Resort and the stores of Holmes Beach Plaza.

The Ugly Grouper is unlike any other eatery because it is located entirely in the open air.

It's an excellent option for a casual lunch or gathering of a large group, thanks to its plentiful seating.

There are several covered eating spaces, but there are also uncovered ones with picnic tables and a selection of activities for both kids and adults.

Try some of their famous Grouper tacos.

The tacos start as doughy flour but become crisp after being fried and topped with melted cheese.

Traditional meals and a variety of sandwich options can be ordered accompanied by a variety of potato, veggie, and grain options.

Ginny's and Jane E's

Located on Gulf Drive, Ginny's & Jane E's offers espresso, breakfast dishes, sandwiches, and cinnamon rolls in a cool, casual atmosphere.

At the shop, you may view a one-of-a-kind assortment of artwork and antiques culled from the collections of local artisans and pickers.

This one-of-a-kind establishment allows guests to choose between intimate nooks and spacious tables for group meals.

Their food is always prepared fresh, with no added hormones or preservatives.

The best breakfast on the island, bar none; the service and the food are top-notch.

Every morning, Ginny's and Jane E's bakes fresh bread from scratch.

The menu offers a wide variety of classic dishes and modern favorites.

Get the crème Brulee french toast; it's out of this world.

Their sticky buns and cinnamon rolls are also noteworthy.

They also have excellent sticky buns and cinnamon rolls.

Drink a fruit smoothie, cold beer, or mimosa to wash down your meal.

Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus

Anna Maria Island's Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus serves traditional German food.

Every meal is prepared from scratch using recipes from Bavarian and Austrian grandmothers.

They also provide a wide variety of premium German draft beers and wines, making them a local go-to destination.

These home-cooked Bavarian and Austrian dishes will hit the spot if you're craving German cuisine.

Diners can enjoy an atmosphere reminiscent of traditional German "Gemütlichkeit."

Each time you visit Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus, you will be treated to an unforgettable meal of authentic German cuisine.

Their famous Wiener schnitzel is a gastronomic treat; it is pan-fried, breaded, and served with Mushroom Cream Sauce.

Similarly fantastic is their Rheinischer Sauerbraten, which consists of sliced beef loin marinated in red wine and spices and then slowly cooked in brown gravy.

Visit them on Anna Maria Island along East Bay Drive in Holmes Beach.

The Waterfront Restaurant

The Waterfront Restaurant is Anna Maria Island's finest restaurant.

It is a laid-back beachside eatery that serves seafood from across the world.

Their staple menu is always centered on the freshest, highest-quality ingredients of the season.

They are cooked in a traditional style, with an emphasis on using only fresh, natural ingredients.

The cottage dates back to 1922 and was one of the first structures to be constructed on Anna Maria Island.

The cottage was destroyed by fire, but it was rebuilt and reopened in October 2005.

Each dish at The Waterfront Restaurant is carefully crafted and tastes fantastic.

Grouper tacos are a must-try, filled with flavor thanks to grilled flour tortillas, Cheddar Jack cheese, Jicama Slaw, and Pico de Gallo.

Their pasta primavera with olive oil, fresh seasonal veggies, roasted red pepper, grilled portobello, roasted garlic, feta, and linguini is exceptionally good.

The bar has a wide variety of drinks and creative cocktail options.

So, what are you waiting for?

Go to South Bay Boulevard to get some fresh seafood dishes.

Bridge Street Bistro

Bridge Street Bistro is a high-end, casual restaurant with a menu that focuses on seafood and a bar.

Dine outside on the terrace on the third floor and enjoy the best view of the Gulf of Mexico on Anna Maria Island.

It is north of Longboat Key at Gulf Drive South in Bradenton Beach.

The atmosphere is relaxed and sophisticated, and casual attire is recommended.

Feel the warm tropical breezes and see the gorgeous sunsets.

You can get delicious, freshly prepared food at Bridge Street Bistro without breaking the bank.

It would be best if you tried their cauliflower appetizer, stuffed shrimp, crab cakes, ribeyes, filet mignon, and seafood aurora; they are well-seasoned and tasty.

You should leave space for dessert because their homemade desserts, like chocolate mouse cake and New York-style cheesecake, are delicious.

Other Restaurants Nearby

Tide Tables

Tide Tables is a laid-back seafood place with great views of the Intracoastal Waterway.

The authentic atmosphere complements the excellent meals they serve.

While you dine, take in the stunning views of the Intracoastal Waterway, rich marine life, and the working waterfront of old Cortez Village.

They only use the freshest fish that can be found in Cortez.

Tide Tables offers delectable appetizers, salads, soups, specials, mouthwatering desserts, and a well-curated assortment of beer, wine, and other refreshing beverages.

You won't be disappointed by their delicious grouper fish tacos or smoked ribs.

If you want to sample a little bit of everything, you can have a combo basket with fried, grilled, or blackened jumbo shrimp, large sea scallops, and mahimahi.

Check them out in Bradenton for delicious seafood.

Final Thoughts

Anna Maria Island is the perfect spot to unwind and relax.

It's the ultimate vacation destination, offering sun, sea, surf, and—best of all—great food.

The best restaurants in Anna Maria Island, Florida are a testament to the island's exquisite culinary scene, so be sure to check them out on your visit!